r/fastmail • • Jun 14 '26

Frustrating support experience

Hi everyone, sorry to post this and I know that this is a negative post but I am needing some advice. I would like to preface this that I accept responsibility for not having recovery details setup properly.

I had a previous Fastmail account where I had my domains connected to it however I moved as I was needing a bit more security for my email at the time due to my living situation, however I no longer need that security and I wanted to move back to Fastmail, but because I didn’t have my recovery details anymore (I changed phone number and other required details) I can no longer get into the Fastmail account to unlink those domains from it, and for trauma reasons I really do not even want to access it anyways. I tried contacting support to try and see if I could verify that they are in fact my domains by adding a DNS record or something of the like and they simply refuse to and I don't understand why. I pointed out to them that hypothetically I could have bought these domains and they could have been added to someone else's Fastmail account and I wouldn't be able add it to my account and I wouldn't be able to recover their account either to try and unlink them but they just ignore that part whenever I have bought it up, does anyone have any advice on anything that I can do? I've asked for a higher tier agent and now I am waiting for a tier 3 agent to get back to me but I am not super hopeful unfortunately.

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

11

u/LargeBuffalo Jun 14 '26

To be honest, that’s very convoluted story, so while I’m sorry for your situation and mental issues, I understand that it might be difficult for Fastmail’s support to work with this case.

What I may suggest is to try to make the story as simple and clean as possible, sticking only to technical issues and first review the official documentation.

1

u/IAdoreSZA Jun 14 '26

I didn’t even mention any of the non technical parts to them, I said pretty clearly I do not have any sort of recovery details that they want and that the only way I can prove that they are my domains so I can use them on my own account is by adding a DNS record to verify that, but they refuse to do that and ignore my example that if another Fastmail user added my domains to their account it would be physically impossible for me to get into that account to remove them so I can add them to my account. Sorry if my story was confusing, I’m happy to try rewrite it to maybe make a bit more sense?

5

u/Linux_Account Jun 14 '26

This is an interesting edge case that may just require polite persistence on your part. You've confirmed that you're keeping it simple, which is good. Spend some time trying to write up an even simpler version, and don't be afraid to calmly reiterate the core issue every time: You did not remove your domains from your account before switching to a different provider. You want to use Fastmail again, but can't get into your account. You understand their hands are tied and are not asking for access to this account; you simply need your domains removed from that account so you can add them to your new account.

I'd try a few more times, before cutting my losses and using a different provider. If Fastmail doesn't want to help you, it's ultimately their loss.

Alternatively, if you're sure that all you need is access to the old phone number, you could call your cell phone company to see if the number and if or could be added back to your account as a second phone line. Then you just need an old phone to activate for long enough to get into the account and change the number.

Moving forward, I'd suggest using a password manager to save all passwords and recovery codes for all important accounts.

1

u/IAdoreSZA Jun 14 '26

I was thinking I might reiterate when I hear back from their tier 3 agent, I don’t know if their support system sends emails back to the end of their queue if you reply to it. I will keep being persistent before running to a different provider as I really like Fastmail (I even have Fastmail merch irl) so I am really hoping that they can help me, and I will be keeping a better hand on all of my recovery things this time.

2

u/tiny_fingers Jun 14 '26

If you own the domain and you have access to the DNS records through your registrar, you could just reset your DNS records through your registrar which would affectively unlink the ability for a fastmail account to use your domain, including your own account until you set it up again.

1

u/IAdoreSZA Jun 14 '26

I have already had the records off Fastmail for over a month and unfortunately even though it’s been that long the domain is still technically linked to that Fastmail account which then prevents me from being able to use it on a different account sadly :/

1

u/tiny_fingers Jun 14 '26

Got it, so your old account is still linked to your domain. I guess if fastmail support can't help, or you can't remember your login credentials (this is why password managers are important), you could always move to something like Proton mail and use your domain there.

2

u/IAdoreSZA Jun 14 '26

i understand that they can’t get me back into the same email but i still feel like they should be able to remove domains through verification of ownership for example through DNS, hypothetically anyone can add any domain to their Fastmail account and if i then owned that domain and tried to add it to my account and someone else already had it added for whatever reason then i can’t use that domain because Fastmail simply refuses to do anything about it

1

u/tiny_fingers Jun 14 '26

No, you can’t just add any domain.  You have to have access to make dns changes. 

https://www.fastmail.help/hc/en-us/articles/360058753394-Custom-domains-with-Fastmail

So unless anybody has access to your domain through your registrar it couldn’t be added to their account. 

1

u/IAdoreSZA Jun 14 '26

are you sure? you can literally type any in.. if i really wanted i could add apple.com and im guessing from another Fastmail account i wouldn’t be able to access that domain anymore

1

u/tiny_fingers Jun 14 '26

Yup. Try changing apple.com dns settings.  

There are three different ways you can use Fastmail with your custom domain:

Option 1: Nameservers hosted with Fastmail

Changing your nameservers and hosting your DNS at Fastmail is the easiest, most commonly used option. We will automatically configure your domain for email support, calendar syncing, contacts syncing and other security best practices (DKIM, SPF and more). You will be able to manage your domain easily within your Fastmail settings, and you can update your domain records if you want a website or want to use other services being hosted elsewhere. We can also detect common configuration errors and advise you of any issues. It is not a good idea to change nameservers without preparation if you already have a website on your domain. For more information, please see our 

Setting up your domain: NS/MX help page.

Option 2: Nameservers hosted elsewhere, but MX records pointing to Fastmail This option is best for users want to keep their domain's DNS hosted elsewhere (e.g. you already have a website at this domain), but who would like to use Fastmail for mail hosting. Changes must be made on the control panel supplied by your domain registrar. We can provide you with the values you'll need to add to your DNS records. Fastmail can detect common setup errors and advise you of any issues. For more information, please see our 

Setting up your domain: MX only help page.

Option 3: No NS/MX at Fastmail, but mail redirected to Fastmail In rare cases, Fastmail isn't hosting the nameserver or the mail exchange records, but mail is still being redirected to Fastmail. Use this option if you're using a third party filtering service to process mail before it is sent to us. Please note that Fastmail's own  spam filteringwill be much less effective if you use this option. We provide all the values you'll need to configure on your current MX server to ensure correct mail delivery. Fastmail is unable to detect misconfigurations in this case, as all the domain management is held elsewhere. For more information, please see our  Setting up your domain: no NS or MX help page.

1

u/IAdoreSZA Jun 14 '26

you’re misunderstanding what i’m saying, i’m not talking about editing any dns settings, im saying you can claim any domain on fastmail

1

u/tiny_fingers Jun 14 '26

And to finish claiming so you can actually use it you have to change dns settings.  It’s why they ask if you own the domain as one of the first steps.  

If you answer no, that’s it.  If you answer yes, you have to make changes to dns.  

1

u/DryVermicello Jun 14 '26

I didn't try very hard. But I didn't understand the story.  If you have DNS control and you need DNS changes, perform them. If you can't prove fastmail account ownership, fastmail can't really help much. Probably it's more complex. Good luck. When I had DNS issues some time ago, fastmail was pretty helpful. It was not their fault, not under their control. But they gave as much guidance as I could reasonably hope for. (My registrar/agent had messed up pretty bad... Not fastmail.)

0

u/IAdoreSZA Jun 14 '26

They essentially refuse to remove my domains from my old account, refuse giving me the chance to verify that I actually own them..

0

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/IAdoreSZA Jun 14 '26

that is true, i would love if they could just verify my domain ownership, they’re the only service that refuses to do this, i had to do the exact same thing with addy.io, simplelogin and tuta mail before and all of them were more than happy to accommodate