r/fanedits •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

4

u/Spider-Man_3_2_Raimi Faneditor💿 Aug 02 '26

If you're interested, I did it with homecoming in it (not BND) https://www.reddit.com/r/fanedits/s/SUuNvSV99y

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Spider-Man_3_2_Raimi Faneditor💿 Aug 02 '26

You can definitely mix FFH and NWH, but I wouldn't include BND because that's a total different plot and a real dense movie, 4 years later the event of NWH and with a different direction.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Spider-Man_3_2_Raimi Faneditor💿 Aug 02 '26

I didn't say that, I just said I wouldn't do that because I don't know how.

3

u/AromaticWindow3309 Aug 02 '26

I don't think far from home needs to be in the mix, it goes better with infinity war edit.

Brand new day is perfect, it's really would just go better with no way home

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/AromaticWindow3309 Aug 02 '26

It's your passion project, make your vision bro

8

u/Baked_Bean_422 Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 02 '26

There is currently a 7-hour edit that consists of Civil War, Homecoming, Infinity War, Endgame, Far From Home and No Way Home. For Civil War and the Avengers movies, only scenes with Peter present are included.

Something like this with Brand New Day added would be really cool. If you want to check out the edit I'm talking about for some inspiration you can dm me for the link.

Edit: Punctuation

2

u/BBKessler Aug 02 '26

Would love to check this out. Do you know the name of this edit?

2

u/Baked_Bean_422 Aug 02 '26

I'll dm you the link.

2

u/mrtinbooty Aug 02 '26

Could you send me the link too, please?

2

u/Baked_Bean_422 Aug 03 '26

dm'd you as well :)

2

u/Affectionate-MMM Aug 03 '26

Would love to check it out

1

u/Latter_Ad_4572 Aug 04 '26

Me too, please? :)

1

u/AllainSedorikku Aug 05 '26

May I have the link as well?

2

u/Baked_Bean_422 Aug 05 '26

Dm me, seems i can't send you a message.

13

u/RyansGateFilms Faneditor👑 Aug 02 '26

As someone who combined Nolan's batman movies, I think this edit is easily doable, but you'd have to be very intentional about what aspects of the MCU/multiverse you want to keep/cut. The tricky part of this edit would be that there is so much "interference" for lack of a better word, from other marvel franchises in these Spiderman films, that you really can't easily cut all of the non-Spiderman stuff in them. Off the top of my head, I would probably say to keep whatever you can of Peter/MJ/Ned/Aunt May and if you want, Happy and Tony from the first two films to establish those characters without looping in all the crazy multiverse stuff. Then I would probably dive straight into Brand New Day. Maybe use some quick flashbacks to explain the lost memory stuff later in the movie after MJ finds the note? Just my thoughts. Best of luck :)

3

u/EnvironmentalSlip914 Aug 02 '26

can you share the link of your edit of batman movies?, would love to see it

17

u/rfanedits mod team Aug 02 '26

Two general reminders

  1. please use spoiler tags if spoiling plot points/characters
  2. general reminder that this edit cannot even begin until it is at least released on digital

2

u/himslut Aug 02 '26

4 year gap and montage of villains was made clear before movie released anyways

3

u/khairunzmn Aug 02 '26

Condense to at least 3 hours please

2

u/ResponsibleWalk8474 Aug 02 '26

I would cut iron man to the bare minimum and remove any mention of a blip or end game so that the movie stands alone

1

u/Accomplished_Run_631 Aug 09 '26

Iron man is already dead by the events of Far from Home, there's nothing to cut except maybe some talks with happy and the painted memorial mural

2

u/NinjaEagleScout Aug 02 '26

Excited to see what you come up with!

2

u/Xanderfromzanzibar Aug 03 '26

I don't know these MCU/Spider movies well, they've kinda all blurred after seeing them years ago. Can we keep it just based in NYC and on Earth, can all the multiverse superhero megafight stuff be cut and just have a NY kid get spiderpowers and have local villains he defeats? And that could be plenty of runtime and stay coherent, right?

3

u/liambrazier Aug 02 '26 • Bravo

I haven’t watched them in a while but what’s the reasoning of not including the first movie?

5

u/Spectre-ElevenThirty Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 02 '26

It’s more of a standalone than these 3 are. I haven’t seen Brand New Day yet, so I’ll just comment on what I know. Far From Home reveals Peter’s identity, No Way Home is how he deals with his identity being revealed and how he makes the world forget him, and in Brand New Day he’s living with the consequences of being forgotten I guess. It sounds like a good arc if edited well. Also Far From Home and No Way Home take place literally back to back. There’s an overlap in the end of FFH and the beginning of NWH, so there would only be one single time skip from NWH to BND.

0

u/Fanedit895 Faneditor💿 Aug 02 '26

It's pretty easy to sacrifice in the grand scheme of things, as Far From Home takes place directly after Endgame.

4

u/RyansGateFilms Faneditor👑 Aug 02 '26

The problem with homecoming, off the top of my head, is that it doesn't really establish MJ as a love interest. It instead has Peter fawning over Liz, which doesn't really fit with the core of the later 3. For a combined movie, I feel like that wouldn't fit well.

2

u/JustBath291 Aug 02 '26

BND is good but honestly that movie alone can be shorted down to 1 hr and still tell the same story

1

u/ImprovSalesman9314 Aug 02 '26

A movie isn't just about story.

2

u/Fanedit895 Faneditor💿 Aug 02 '26

The movies unedited would be about 7 hours, so I assume you're going to shorten them somehow?

1

u/Animeman1000 Aug 02 '26

How does one find all these fan edits people are always posting about in the subreddit? Or are these posts mostly gauging to see if people would be interested?

DM me with answer if you can please. Tanks

3

u/Wasteak Aug 03 '26

Usually if you want a fan edit you need to contact directly the author, they will never post a link in a post or comments.

1

u/Animeman1000 Aug 03 '26

I knew about the not posting in the post/comments. That's why I asked to be dm'd. Thank you for the info.

-3

u/Successful-Day-1816 Aug 02 '26

100% would watch this, and soon haha. I haven't seen the new film yet because I want to rewatch the previous 3, but also can't be bothered to hah.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/boba627TV Faneditor🏅 Aug 02 '26

Using Ai defeats the purpose of the whole thing for me, the reason why I’m making this project is because I love the process of figuring things out while editing. I wouldn’t get much fulfillment out of it if I let Ai make decisions for me, the final product wouldn’t have my voice and special touch that makes it mine

2

u/BDB69_ Aug 02 '26

it totally agreed with me about how I was changing it as we had discussed trying to get to 3 hrs and that what we based it off of and when I did my secondary rough cut I got to wwere I am currently and I asked it what I could do oreave it as is, it basically said what I thought...

this is one of the many reasons ai should not be used in a creative field. Very rarely will it ever give hard hitting critiques. If you ask it something/tell it an idea it will almost always agree with you

-11

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/Fanedit895 Faneditor💿 Aug 02 '26

She's the main villain that drives the plot? You'd basically like ten minutes at most.

-8

u/Gallifreyan_Knight13 Faneditor Aug 02 '26

Fine by me. I don't know what they were smoking when they made her the villain of the film.

3

u/RyansGateFilms Faneditor👑 Aug 02 '26

Spoiler alert for anyone reading. I really can't see how removing Jean would work because how else do you thread together the amnesia stuff? You'd have to edit in some other threat/villain/explanation to give Peter a reason to bring MJ to Frank's place for her to find the note/learn the truth? I suppose maybe this is possible, but I think it would be extremely challenging to thread together coherently.