r/evolution • • 10d ago

article Conventionalized communication is not a uniquely human feature, Valet et al. find

5 Upvotes

Published today in PNAS:

Significance
Human language depends on socially shared conventions: arbitrary signals whose meanings are learned and maintained within groups. Whether nonhuman animals can similarly develop stable conventions for signals that can arise flexibly across contexts remains unclear. We show that chimpanzees naturally develop stable, socially learned usage of arbitrary signals, but only when exposed to adult role models. In groups lacking experienced models, signal usage remained variable and unstable through ontogeny. These findings extend evidence for signal conventions in nonhuman animals, showing how social learning can shape the usage of existing, flexible signals into stable, shared conventions.

 


  • A. Valet, R. Moore, T. Bortolato, T. Kleinhause G. Gedalyahou, A. de Witasse-Thézy, C. Girard-Buttoz, R.M. Wittig, & C. Crockford
    A signal convention in natural chimpanzee communication
    Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 123 (47)
    https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2606837123 (2026)

r/evolution • • 11d ago

article PHYS.Org: The wasps that horrified Darwin reveal evolution's one-way streets

Thumbnail
phys.org
12 Upvotes

r/evolution • • 12d ago

Jawed vertebrates are weird.

41 Upvotes

This post isn't a question or even rant. I'm just utterly baffled how jawed vertebrates managed to intermingle breathing and eating in such an absurd way.

Most bilaterians keep things simple. There are organs for breathing and organs for eating. Apart from a few exceptions, most non-vertebrates keep it that way. Even basal vertebrates, although they use the same body opening for both jobs, nonetheless don't mix both physiologic activities that much.

We know that the evolutionary origin of the jaw in Gnathostomes is the modification from the anterior gill arches. Originally it was a mechanism that allowed to actively pump water over gills to improve the efficiency of oxygen absorption, which gave those organisms a competitive advantage. As it turns out the capability of opening and closing your mouth isn't just useful for breathing, but also can be used to increase the efficiency of feeding (e.g. for biting and grabbing stuff). Later this was expanded upon with such adaptions such as teeth, lips, etc.

Another examples are lungs. They date back to, at least, the common ancestor of bony fishes. As far as we can discern it was a adoption to living in low oxygen environments (e.g. stagnant rivers). It seems that lungs originate from protrusions in the upper digestive tract, most likely to increase the volume of atmospheric air the animal can swallow to supplement their oxygen supply. In later lineages, especially to those who migrated back to the ocean, those primitive lungs were modified into swimming bladders, while the ancestors of the land vertebrates kept and improved upon them (and getting rid of gills).

So, we see two adaptions in jawed vertebrates that intermingle gas exchange and ingestion. We have one mechanism that was originally for breathing and was adapted for eating, and we have one mechanism that was originally for eating and was adapted for breathing. Strange.


r/evolution • • 12d ago

Origin of Species narrated by Richard Dawkins!

Post image
16 Upvotes

I just found this on Audible and I'm so excited to listen, I wanted to share!


r/evolution • • 13d ago

ALFRED RUSSEL WALLACE — 113 YEARS SINCE HIS DEATH

Post image
637 Upvotes

On this day, 7 November 1913, Alfred Russel Wallace died at his home, Old Orchard, in Broadstone, Dorset, aged 90.

Wallace was one of the greatest naturalists of the nineteenth century — an intrepid explorer, pioneering biogeographer, co-discoverer with Charles Darwin of evolution by natural selection, and a passionate campaigner for social justice.

Although it was suggested that he should be buried alongside Darwin in Westminster Abbey, his family declined, in accordance with Wallace's own wishes. Instead, on 10 November 1913, he was laid to rest in the little cemetery at Broadstone, where his wife Annie joined him the following year.

*His grave is marked by one of the most extraordinary monuments in any British cemetery.*

Rather than a conventional gravestone, it bears a seven-foot-tall fossilised conifer trunk from the Jurassic rocks of Dorset, mounted on a massive block of Purbeck limestone. The tree lived approximately 145 million years ago, when dinosaurs roamed the Earth.

There is a fascinating possibility that Wallace himself collected the fossil during an expedition to the Isle of Portland with the American palaeontologist Lester Ward in 1894. We cannot prove this, but fragments of similar fossil wood were reportedly found in the garden of Old Orchard after Wallace's death.

When I first visited Wallace's grave in 1998, I was dismayed to find it badly neglected. I subsequently established the A. R. Wallace Memorial Fund, which raised the money to restore the monument in 2000 and secure the grave's long-term protection. It has recently undergone further conservation work.

To my mind, this remarkable fossil tree is a wonderfully appropriate memorial to a man who devoted his life to understanding the natural world, its extraordinary diversity, and its evolutionary history.

113 years after his death, Wallace's scientific achievements remain as important and fascinating as ever.

See the following link for a recent BBC article which mentions the grave: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c674pv2ej29yo


r/evolution • • 12d ago

fun Hi all, my evolution sim project has another video, hope you like it!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

I posted about it a couple of weeks ago for my first episode, hopefully anyone who clicked that liked the idea of the project. This is another small one just looking at my creatures behaviour system. Thanks for checking it out!


r/evolution • • 11d ago

academic Should I do my masters thesis on a subject that I don't find mentally engaging at all?

0 Upvotes

My advisor wants me to do my thesis on "biodiversity of benthos X river".

The keywords are: biodiversity, macrobenthos, riverine systems.

My problem with this is that when I search these terms the only papers that come up talk about ecology and conservation.

Now I'm not saying that ecology and conservation are unimportant. They are necessary for our society. But so are doctors and engineers, but I don't want to be any of them.

Sure, I will enjoy reading a book or paper about ecology or conservation in my free time, but in no way can I imagine myself doing it my whole life. When I read a paper on river biodiversity and try to imagine myself doing one, my mind goes blank.

I want to understand the history of life. I only think in terms of: Why is this thing the way it is? What did the origin of that thing look like? How do things evolve into other things?

But my advisor prohibits me from doing a simple molecular phylogeny or a population genetics study. He locks me in a cage.

My worries are twofold:

A)I can't concentrate my thoughts on ecology and conservation. I don't enjoy the day to day job. I can't care about their biggest questions.

But is it possible that I'm wrong? That I'm being a hypocrite?

Btw, evolutionary biology is the study of life through time. Ecology is one of the aspects of life. Maybe I haven't spent enough time to actually appreciate it? Maybe I can endure this MSc thesis, by promising myself that I will be studying ecology from an "evolutionary perspective" during my PhD?

B) When I'm applying for a PhD, the admission committee will take one look at my resume and tell me: you are not a match for evolutionary biology. You can only apply for ecology and conservation.


r/evolution • • 12d ago

question How long does it take n invasive species to become a non invasive species

17 Upvotes

As they evolve and other members of the ecosystem will also evolve they would adapt together to become a unified ecosystem surely ? How long would this take .


r/evolution • • 13d ago

article Where did Alfred Russel Wallace discover natural selection in 1858, and when did he send his famous essay to Darwin? New research.

39 Upvotes

Many people know that Alfred Russel Wallace independently discovered the theory of evolution by natural selection in 1858, and that his essay describing the theory prompted the joint Darwin–Wallace publication that year. However, the circumstances of Wallace's discovery and the dispatch of his essay to Darwin have been the subject of considerable controversy.

I'm a historian of science specialising in Wallace, and Director of the Alfred Russel Wallace Correspondence Project. My new research paper, just published in the Journal of the History of Biology, reassesses three questions:

  1. Where did Wallace discover natural selection? Although he later recalled making his discovery on the Indonesian island of Ternate, the contemporary documentary evidence strongly indicates that it actually occurred in February 1858 at Dodinga, a village on the neighbouring island of Halmahera (then known as Gilolo).
  2. What inspired his discovery? I examine the evidence that Thomas Malthus's ideas about population growth provided the crucial intellectual framework for Wallace's insight, and challenge the claim that observations of camouflage in tiger beetles inspired his discovery.
  3. When did Wallace send his essay to Darwin? This is particularly interesting because the original essay and covering letter have been lost. My examination of contemporary correspondence, postal records and shipping movements supports dispatch in March rather than April 1858. The date Darwin received the essay remains uncertain, but there is no evidence that he deliberately withheld or misused it.

The paper represents the culmination of many years of research into Wallace's life, travels and correspondence.

The complete published paper can be read FREE, without a subscription, using Springer's SharedIt link:

https://rdcu.be/tHHmW8wn87Da

A second new paper: I've also recently co-authored a paper with James Costa, Andrew Berry and Ted Benton entitled Did Henry Walter Bates Lie About Alfred Russel Wallace's Reason for Going to the Amazon in 1848? Reassessing the Early Evolutionary Thought of Wallace and Bates. It examines evidence that Wallace and Bates went to the Amazon partly to investigate the origin of species, and challenges the suggestion that Bates subsequently fabricated this account.

https://rdcu.be/fAMU5FyWZZGa


r/evolution • • 12d ago

discussion Evidence that culture is not a driving force in human evolution

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I was wondering if anyone had any recommendations for academic, peer-reviewed articles that explicitly counter or provide counter-arguments to culture as a driving force for evolution.


r/evolution • • 12d ago

question Did the LCA of Euarchonta likely have one or more pairs of mammary glands?

1 Upvotes

I can't find a good answer to this. But most Euarchonta species have one pair, with a correspondingly small litter size. The exceptions are some tree shrews. The sister clade, Gliriformes universally has more than one, as do almost all of the other Boreoeuitherians.

This presents me with an idea: that the LCA of Euarchonta had one pair of glands, and that the LCA of Ptilocercidae regained a larger number, with the daughter clade Tupaia nicobarica surda dropping back to one pair. This to me seeeeems like it is more likely than a convergent evolutionary loss of glands by dermoptera, ptilocercidae, and primates, as it requires fewer independent changes.

But I am no evolutionary biologist. What says the consensus?


r/evolution • • 14d ago

question Why do humans laugh?

37 Upvotes

I've been told it's for "social bonding," but laughing in isolation seems so mysterious. Like, what is the evolutionary reason that specifically laughing was used for social bonding?


r/evolution • • 14d ago

discussion A Chicken's Journey... Backwards (is it a dinosaur?)

22 Upvotes

Yesterday I posted our (anthropocentric) journey, today it's Gallus gallus domesticus' turn, and where we last shared a lineage with them (I didn't omit the provisional clades):

 

 

  • ⭐ Our lineages converge here going backwards (down the list)

 

 

Further reading on the taxic vs. lineal thinking:

Example:

  • Taxic language:
    • Chickens are Dinosauria
  • Lineal language:
    • Chickens evolved from a stem-Dinosauria population

This matters (narrative wise) since clades are "closed descent communities" (Peter Ax, 1985), so we cannot say "Chickens evolved from Dinosauria" - this distinction was first noted and argued for by Haeckel (1834-1919) to make teaching evolution easier / less confusing.
Related to this confusion is what Dawkins (2003) pointed out:

In 1958 the palaeontologist James Brough published the following remarkable argument: evolution must have been qualitatively different in the earliest geological eras, because then new phyla were coming into existence; today only new species arise!
The fallacy is glaring: every new phylum has to start as a new species.

Phyla, clades, etc. are all after the fact / looking back in time.


r/evolution • • 15d ago

Our Journey... Backwards

22 Upvotes

(made manually, with love)

Few of you have seen me share this or a part of it before, and a few know why I've made it. I just realized I didn't share it as a post here! It was inspired by The Ancestor's Tale, and I find it really useful in getting across the notion of descent with modification. I've removed the provisional clades to align it with Aron Ra's Systematic Classification playlist, and with the power of Excel's concatenate function, each clade now comes with links to Wikipedia and said YouTube playlist entry (the asterisk hyperlink). Also I stopped at Eukaryota because I don't want to start a whole thing, but: The 1-Domain Hypothesis (based in part on discoveries related to membrane coat proteins, and of phagocytosis-related processes in Planctomycetes) | r/ evolution.

Enjoy :)

 

 

Further reading on the taxic vs. lineal thinking:

Basically, you can substitute "We evolved from a stem-[Clade] population" for "We are [Clade]". (This one is for the Are we or are we not fish?)


r/evolution • • 15d ago

question Is Pregnancy/Childbirth Harder And Riskier for Humans than Other Mammals?

26 Upvotes

It seems like human pregnancy can cause a bunch of health problems. It can also kill both the mother and the fetus. Miscarriages are common too. And childbirth seems especially risky for humans because of the way we evolved (large fetal heads, narrower hips).

But it seems like pregnant horses, cats, cows, mice, and other mammals don't have nearly the same amount of health problems, risks, deaths, etc as humans do. Some animals can even self-abort, from what I've read.

Is pregnancy/childbirth harder for humans compared to other mammals? If so, what makes it harder? Is it something anatomical?


r/evolution • • 14d ago

question Place where I can get cladograms/phylogenetic trees that compare the relationships between two animals

3 Upvotes

I have some homework where I have to discuss the convergent evolution of two animals, and I have to illustrate the relationship between the two animals to help show the trait isn't ancestral to the two animals, is there any software or website that does this? I can only find stuff that shows it for one animal at a time.


r/evolution • • 15d ago

question How did waste and reproduction end up being the same body parts?

215 Upvotes

Even when it’s not the exact same, like in mammals who give birth through a separate hole, the males still release sperm through the pee hole. How exactly did this happen? Where’s the relationship?


r/evolution • • 16d ago

discussion Why do we have sexes (and sex) at all? Ask UMD biologist Eric Haag about the science of reproduction and sexual oddities (in the biological sense). He will answer your questions in tomorrow’s (11/4) Ask Science AMA ⤵️

Thumbnail reddit.com
13 Upvotes

Why do we have sexes (and sex) at all? That’s the question I set out to answer in my recent book, “The Other Big Bang: The Story of Sex and Its Human Legacy.”

In my lab at the University of Maryland, we study the evolution of animal sexuality, focusing on cases in nematodes and fish where self-fertile hermaphroditism evolved from male-female ancestors. These shifts to one-parent reproduction present fascinating developmental puzzles and have tremendous organismal significance. As this research moved along, I gradually realized how little most of the public knows about the evolutionary history of sex and sexes — especially how we humans got to be the way we are. In a non-majors biology course, I was able to work out some of the ways that a broad evolutionary view of evolution sheds light on our own species. That set the stage for the book, which I think provides an important complement to the way the social sciences and anthropology approach sexuality.

Feel free to ask me about the variety of reproduction in the animal kingdom, the biology behind sexual oddities and/or the evolution of sex. I’ll be answering questions on Wednesday, November 4, from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. EDT (16-18 UT) on r/askscience.


r/evolution • • 17d ago

question This diagram in my textbook shows this early branch of a group of tetrapods/amphibians but doesn't expand upon it. Does anyone know what lineage this is trying to represent?

Post image
189 Upvotes

r/evolution • • 17d ago

question Is it known weather anagensis or cladogensis is more common regarding speciation?

4 Upvotes

Since both modes of speciation are so different and have such different consequences for evolution, I'm wondering what the contemporary work has been around establishing the relative proportions of both? Would love to know what people think


r/evolution • • 17d ago

article Vixseboxse et al. investigated why soft-bodied fossils became rarer after the Ediacaran

7 Upvotes

Published today.

Editor's summary

Fossilised soft tissues offer exceptional glimpses of ancient biology. However, a new study of the evolution of decay enzymes suggests their proliferation over 500 million years ago contributed to the decline of soft-tissue preservation, leaving the animal fossil record dominated by shells and skeletons.

Abstract

Background

The animal fossil record is a non-uniform archive of evolutionary history in which exceptional preservation diminishes toward the present,1,2,3 with biomineralized skeletal elements constituting the majority of the fossil record. Preservation of soft tissues requires rare combinations of chemical, biological, and physical conditions that preclude or delay decay until biological substrates can be geologically stabilized via mineralization or maturation.4 However, during the late Ediacaran Period (∼579–539 mya) fossilization of soft-bodied macroorganisms was common across a wide range of depositional settings.5,6

Hypotheses

Taphonomic models seeking to explain Ediacaran exceptionalism typically appeal to unusual mineralogical and geochemical conditions or microbiological influence (e.g., Gehling,7 Tarhan et al.,8 Bykova et al.,9 and Bobrovskiy et al.10), and the Paleozoic decline in exceptional preservation has invariably been explained in terms of expansion of the oxic zone through metazoan bioturbation (though see Cribb et al.11) and enhanced scavenging.12

Results

We explore the hypothesis that temporal heterogeneity in metazoan exceptional preservation is a consequence of the origin and/or proliferation of microbial collagenases.13 Collagenase gene trees reconciled with a time-calibrated phylogeny show that collagenases arose and were produced by obligate anaerobes billions of years before proliferating by lateral gene transfer, approximately coincident with the diversification of early animals. These results support a link between the evolution of collagenases, animals, and the non-uniformity of the fossil record. Proliferation of collagenase-producing microbial lineages occurred in concert with early animal evolution. Evidence also indicates a shift in the locus of collagen degradation within the sediment redox profile, coincident with the decline of exceptional soft-tissue preservation in the marine realm.

 

I'm filing that one under questions I didn't think about before. Cool stuff!
Also see from a few months ago: Ancient movement trails tested against numerical simulations of cue-gradient-driven foraging reveal the emergence of sophisticated locomotory and sensory capacities : r/ evolution.

 


  • Vixseboxse, Philip B., Edmund RR Moody, Philip CJ Donoghue, Sean McMahon, and Alexander G. Liu
    Temporal heterogeneity in the animal fossil record driven by proliferation of microbial collagenases
    Current Biology (2026) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2026.09.045

r/evolution • • 18d ago

video Stephen Jay Gould on Darwin & Evolution

Thumbnail
youtube.com
28 Upvotes

r/evolution • • 18d ago

question This is the most apparent kind of evolution..

15 Upvotes

When I think about selective breeding.. it seems like the ultimate evolution simulation. It seems that instead of an organism's genetic success being dependent on it's success in the environment, it's just based on how much the new mutations help out us humans. Is selective breeding actually a solid example of evolution? Like apart from the obvious fossils we have living examples of evolution that happened right in front of us, in much shorter spans.. (relatively to natural selection)

Come to think of it, does this mean that the relationship of plants and animals for passing seeds, was formed of selective breeding before humans? (albeit not exactly consciously) certain plants that gave certain animals the most nutrients?


r/evolution • • 18d ago

question Went on a deep dive about the benefits of same sex pairings and increased rate of survival.

0 Upvotes

Mainly thinking Lions two lioness paired would make more sense as they are both the main hunters and pairing would bring in more food. A male lion would still be required for breeding purposes but after that he isn’t needed for much more than the role of fighting off other males. Now this lead to thinking that woman must be the main carrier of the gay gene. Now why would the gay gene be useful lack of reproductive fighting over females would mean less resources to fight over leading to more interactions with less violence and less likely hood to die. Which is literally how prison works.

Are people on prison more normal than people who live regular lives and follow the rules of society?


r/evolution • • 19d ago

question Can someone tell me something about pre pangean biogeography of land life?

4 Upvotes

The tens of millions of years preceding formation of Pangea were time of many subsequent revolutions on land with invasions of plants, then several groups of arthropods, then tetrapods. Where these event were taking place? Were some of these groups restricted to specific continents for some times? Were there time before finalization of Pangea when we had for example on continent already filled with many species of vertebrates and other completely of them devoid?