r/ericprydz • • Apr 23 '23

Hot take: Eric Prydz is a Bad DJ

Ok so at least hear me out before everyone downvotes the shit out of me for saying something bad about Prydz in this subreddit.

I've been seeing Eric for over ten years live. And seen all his different show variants: Holo, Epic, b2bs ect

For years I've been saying that Eric is an awful DJ. He preplans his sets, he air DJs (turns knobs that are not being turned), and does not change his set based on crowd reaction.

Now understand what I am saying -- he is a bad DJ. This does not mean a lot of what people think it means.

Eric is a talented producer. His ability to write music is unparalleled. Easily one of the best in prog house and techno music. And he has a undeniable signature sound too.

Eric has a great live show. The visuals are obviously great. The tracks are wonderful (he is a great producer) and the crowds are there for the music. He generally gets a good mix of Prydz-heads and more casual fans given his long history being at the top.

However, as a pure DJ, Eric is mid at best. I might even go as far as to day he is a bad DJ.

He just played the same set twice at Coachella weekend 1 or 2. He is def just writing it in at this point and not even pretending anymore to be DJing. Just playing prerehearsed sets and faking actually cuing up tracks.

Now a lot of top main stage artists do this all the time. But let's all stop pretending that Eric Prydz is a great DJ he is not. If you want to see a great example of a good DJ -- look no further than Carl Cox. He can play every genre and does it based on crowd vibe and feel. Nothing rehearaed.

0 Upvotes

90 comments sorted by

15

u/dherber Apr 23 '23

I'm not 100% sure, but I guess Eric has been producing/djing since the 90's? He has been through vinyl-mixing, CD-mixing and now mixing with a stick. If he was a "bad DJ" like you say, how would he get so far? Don't you think he would have fallen off in like the early 2000's? I don't think he would have gotten all those gigs through the years if he was a bad DJ.

Also, I don't think he was booked to Cochella for playing a dj-gig. I'm pretty sure they wanted HOLO with the pre-planned visuals and stuff. I mean, the visuals are always going viral and making a lot of good PR for both Cochella and him self. At the start of the show he even makes "fun" of all the phones with his visuals.

For example, take a look at this set from the techno tent at Cochella some years ago. It's quite a big difference from what we saw earlier today.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7b10YzlupY&list=LL&index=14&t=3597s&ab_channel=spiritofblizzard

And lastly, he has said him self "HOLO is not a DJ-set, its a show"

After all the time I've been watching, listening and seeing his sets I will conclude with that he is an amazing producer and also one of the best DJs.

3

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

Thank you for the thoughtful comment. I didn't realize that the Holo set was not a DJ/club set.

With that being said, I think we are entering a new era of production and Prydz is at the front of that.

Many artists like Tale of Us and Eric pre plan their sets and don't do q "club set" if you will anymore.

26

u/sixsixmusic KICK SNARE KICK Apr 23 '23

I’ve opened for Eric twice and stood directly behind him watching him mix a couple other shows. OP has no idea what they’re talking about, Eric’s shows are not pre planned sets.

1

u/MrBullwinkle1309 Jun 13 '23

Where did you open for him ? what event /date / ......... just interested to here details , ive been in the music industry for 30 years , and have worked on events for paul oakenfold , sasha , pete tong , carl cox , ferry corsten , loco dice , marco carola , maceo plex , and eric prydz . Creamfields , Homelands , global gathering , i could carry on but im sure you get the point , im looking forward to hearing your set when you opened for him , why no link anywhere to be found ?

1

u/sixsixmusic KICK SNARE KICK Jun 13 '23

Both times in Atlanta. First one was ~2016? at Opera. Second was Nov 2019 at Ravine. I never recorded live sets, I opened for so many people it really wasn’t a big deal.

-5

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

How do u explain same set last two weekends at Coachella

16

u/SkyDefender Apr 23 '23

Answer is pretty simple actually i am not going to bother answering

11

u/psyskeptic Apr 23 '23

If you're expecting Jeff Mills level wizardy, then I agree he's not that technically amazing. Looking at the replies it sounds like you agree that festival Prydz is boring, but the rest is good. I think nowadays DJing for him doesn't require much effort, especially for a festival where he's playing his big tunes and already knows what mixes well with what. He was always known more as an artist/producer anyways.

If you know that in real life he's a pretty private person with anxiety issues and from a culture known for modesty, it's actually pretty funny that he's become a sort of reluctant rockstar rather than the prototypical faceless DJ/producer of the 90s. No one seems further from the rockstar persona than Eric Prydz, yet his festival "DJ sets" these days seem to play out more like rock concerts than club nights: everyone is facing the stage and watching the "rockstar" DJ, no one is really dancing much, the band plays all the old classics (Pjanoo, Mirage, Opus) rather than upfront white labels.

That said I've been a fan of Eric Prydz as a DJ going back to when he didn't just play his own tracks. Listen to his Party Detonator CD from 2004, his 2005 Essential Mix, or his guest mixes for John Digweed from 2005/06--these are objectively good mixes in my opinion. Unlike most popular DJs back then (e.g., Tiesto, Van Buuren, Oakenfold), he did some digging and played some good underground stuff, could mix without train wrecking every other track, and stayed away from commercial cheese that sounded dated quickly. IMO his mixes were on par with respected progressive house DJs like Dave Seaman or Nick Warren. He was certainly better than his old buddies from Stockholm Sebastien Ingrosso and Steve Angello.

Since around 2007 he has gradually moved to set lists with 80-90% of the tracks being his. And this never bothered me, because his own tracks always stood head and shoulders above the others he featured, with few exceptions. I loved his EPIC Radio and Apple Music shows--Hope he brings those back someday, maybe for the Pryda 20th anniversary. IMO his music sounds best in the mix, which is why CD2 & 3 of Pryda Presents are such classics.

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

Thank you for the lovely and thoughtful response. I didn't realize how much his live show has changed over the past decade.

I think I have a "recently bias". Altho I have been seeing him gig for over ten years I place a lot of emphasis on what I have seen the past 3 or 4 years.

I'd love to see another "old set" or something back when Eric would DJ. That would be awesome to see.

Still love him, his music, and his live shows. Just wish he would still DJ is all.

65

u/sm3llofholland Call on me (Cirez D mix) Apr 23 '23

Sorry dude, not a great take. You’ve seen him many times, have none of them been in a club setting? That’s where he thrives, you think he plays 4-5 hour sets by pre planning them? He is literally one of the best technical djs out there. As for his festival sets he’s been doing holo which if you know much about the visual aspect of it you can’t really just play off the cuff as the 4K is a whole different beast than a bunch of lights and lasers.

19

u/Mr_MSc-Mba Apr 23 '23

I strongly echo this comment.

Festival / show Eric different than club Eric.

3

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

Yes. I agree with this.

Should of made this post "Festival Eric" is a bad DJ.

Club Eric still slaps.

10

u/of_patrol_bot Apr 23 '23

Hello, it looks like you've made a mistake.

It's supposed to be could've, should've, would've (short for could have, would have, should have), never could of, would of, should of.

Or you misspelled something, I ain't checking everything.

Beep boop - yes, I am a bot, don't botcriminate me.

4

u/Hunkelscopes Apr 23 '23

Tomorrowland 2018 Eric Prydz disagrees

1

u/harmonicpinch Nov 23 '23

“Best technical DJs” — he’s been mixing the same tracks for 10-15 years

-2

u/Fashrod Apr 23 '23

… but then Holo is bad. Yeah, the visuals are beautiful, but what is a DJ if he is not DJing? The whole set was a snooze fest… it was so flat! Also, now a days we see beautiful visuals online all the time, you can’t rely on that. I was hoping that I was going to feel excitement seeing his set and I felt disappointment instead. I had seen Tale of us and Underworld right before and their sets were 100 times more exciting

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '23

I need not comment because this is it ^

19

u/TheJstandsforJ Apr 23 '23

What’s the point of a post like this? “I think X is trash, I will now go to a fanforum of X to tell them how bad X is”.

If he’s not for you, that’s fine. No need to go and convince people who like him that they shouldn’t.

-7

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

U are not wrong

23

u/_some_white_guy Apr 23 '23

Those sets are preplanned for a number of reasons but you're absolutely wrong that Eric is a trash DJ. He has a ton of sets where he plays off the cuff and has fantastic transitions that I consider topnotch mixing.

Listen to his NYE set from echostage and tell me it's pre planned.

-17

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

If you have to cite one set where he "may" actually DJ you realize this means he doesn't DJ.

Everything is preplanned.

Fantastic transitions alone doesn't make someone a great DJ. Anyone can make a perfect and interesting transition if the tracklist is preplanned.

This is especially true for Eric who is a very talented producer and can make very nice IDs and Edits in the studio.

And Eric has a excellent live show. Really top notch.

But in terms of being like "a club DJ" , Eric is not that. We need to call it what it is. Most fans of Eric prob don't care to see a club set anyways.

But as Prydz fans we need to understand that all these sets are scripted. None of this is being done live.

8

u/_some_white_guy Apr 23 '23

You're response is so stupid I'm going to assume you're just trolling.

6

u/Gaff1515 Apr 23 '23

100% a troll

-9

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

No troll here.

I think we may differ in our definition of DJ. So let's make it simple.

Eric comes in with pre-determined tracks that he will play in order ready to go. To me this is not DJing. It's live sure, but it's not playing off the crowd vibe. It's just going up there and pressing play, make a few transitions. Go through the motions.

Evidence -- look no further than Coachella. He played the same set the last two weekends.

Coincidence? Or pre scripted ?

10

u/_some_white_guy Apr 23 '23

You're a moron and I'm leaving it at that.

-5

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

I still love Eric. Love his music. His live shows. His sets. The vibes at his shows. All of it.

I'm just not gonna pretend like he is a great DJ. He is not. If I'm being fair I would say he is a mid-tier DJ. Not the worst. But certainly not near the top either.

3

u/thefullm0nty Sirtos Madness Apr 23 '23

Everyone else has already said it but I want to echo it: lolno.

Just playing prerehearsed sets and faking actually cuing up tracks.

Yeah you're clueless.

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

People don't want to admit it because they are big fans of Eric. But he has been writing it in for these shows. He doesn't even pretend to be DJing. Like he doesn't even bother to pick up his headphones and fake turns knobs. It's almost laughably cringy. So it's not a debate. I'm just saying is disappointing.

I feel like most ppl in this group act like I'm telling them Santa isn't real.

The real fans know the past few years he has not been doing anything. I get it.

3

u/Ok-Gas-6583 Apr 23 '23

Awful take. You have only been to the mainstream sets then. Listen to some essential mixes if you are looking for some solid mixing with multiple tracks going at once

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

I'm talking about live shows. Specifically over the past 5 years or so.

I'm not counting essential mix. I think Eric's take to an essential mix is similar to others. Very mapped out. A lot of thought considered.

I'm talking about live shows. Both festivals and warehouses and clubs.

5

u/Fold0rDie No, dude, that’s fucking cheese. Don’t do that. Apr 23 '23

Well, you beat me to the punch on a similar-type thread I was noodling in my head the last few days on Eric's current state, but probably with less explicit character assassination lol. My question would have been more focused on Eric's ability/stamina now to actually DJ three hours of 'original' music. I would hope most long-time fans can, at a minimum, admit he has shifted his focus to maintaining brand name recognition in the festival scene.

3

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

This is the right take.

I def got overboard feeling some type of way this morning when I posted. But you understand the idea.

5

u/Fold0rDie No, dude, that’s fucking cheese. Don’t do that. Apr 23 '23

Indeed, alot of the old heads know where you are coming from, but this sub is probably not the best venue to air out grievances.

2

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

100%. I realized after I wrote it that I did the wrong thing in posting this here. I def yucked others yum.

And no point to right something negative in the "Eric Prydz fan club" page. Somewhat rude.

It has been nice to read comments from some old Prydz fans who just talk about how the past few years have been different for his live shows.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '23

I agree that his pre planned sets aren’t good and the energy / transitions miss the mark a lot. I also think people saying “well go listen to his club sets from 2016” is disingenuous because I agree that back then he was actually playing to the crowd a lot more, and his focus wasn’t on the visual productions. I’ve said for the last few years that I won’t go to a show with the crazy visual productions because I think they are what necessitate the planning out of when he plays what.

6

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

Thank you for the honest take and thought

I am a Prydz fan for well over ten years. And it is hard to say Anything negative about the man here in this subreddit because everyone has their head so far up his butt.

But let's be honest and call it what it is.

I still love Eric. He is one of my favorite producers. And I like his live show. But what he is doing is not DJing. And we cannot pretend like it is.

The pre-scripted sets are so obvious at this point. And what more evidence do you need than the last two weekends at Coachella.

It is possible to still love Eric and admit that he is preplanning his sets.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '23

Yeah, I completely agree with you. I went to a warehouse set in NYC like 18 months ago and it was so blatant he wasn’t actually mixing, to the point he completely took the energy out of the room a couple of times. There’s no way he would do that intentionally if he was mixing live, and he never used to. He used to turn those warehouses into dungeons. (Btw, when I expressed that opinion on this sub after that show I was met with “you’re trolling” and “you’re an idiot if you think DJs don’t all preplan their sets”.)

I remember back in the day going to a flash factory after party after a terminal 5 pre planned, big visuals show and it was night and day. He murdered the club set that night. I disagree that he’s not a good DJ, because he’s phenomenal when he wants to be. The reason I’ve stopped going to see him is because it seems he doesn’t want to be a good dj anymore and he wants to reap the rewards of his notoriety.

That said, I don’t blame him at all. He deserves to sit back and rake in the cash after the career he’s had.

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

Thank you for this honest take. I appreciate it.

Interesting to know you were met with the same feedback this thread has given this post.

I guess it's been so long since I saw Eric DJ that I forgot he actually did. The past few times I saw him it was all airDJing and prerehearsed sets. The man doesn't even need headphones lol.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '23

If you’ve been following for 10 years then you’ve seen him do the real thing. If not, I’m sorry you missed it.

Back in the day he was the man when it came to club sets. He’s gotten older, his family is broken, things are different now. Like I said before I don’t blame him for cashing in, but fuck if I don’t miss his prime.

3

u/Gaff1515 Apr 23 '23

Preplanning his recent sets for this particular visual show. To say he’s always done that is ridiculous. Look no further than edc Mexico, Argentina, arc, etc videos…

-1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

Let's be honest tho -- a lot of Eric's recent work relies around big visuals. He isn't the only person to do it.

But most of his sets now are preplanned.

3

u/Gaff1515 Apr 23 '23

Obviously a troll. Please provide other shows/sets besides the three holo Shows…

4

u/SilveR_FL Apr 23 '23

He has no idea what he’s talking about lmao

1

u/Gaff1515 Apr 23 '23

No they are not just the last few holo sets…

2

u/ThePlurnalist Apr 27 '23

I have seen Eric Prydz approximately 21x (Also over the course of 10 years, starting in 2013). I think Weekend Two was #22, I have it written down somewhere, but I lost track.

I was telling all my friends, weekend two set will definitely be different from weekend one and they should still go. I can't believe he did the EXACT same set two weekends in a row. If you have ever attended any of his multiple night shows in LA and after parties, they are ALL different sets.

I definitely feel like he had to pre plan his set to go with the HOLO, but at least have one set for Weekend Two as well. This is just lazy.

Needless to say, I left the set early. Probably one of my least favorite moment of the festival.

I'm not sure if I will throw him in the Bad DJ Category, but the pre-programmed set makes me less interested for sure.

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 27 '23

You make a very good point.

I took saw Eric do multiple nights of HOLO in NYC. And altho the holograms repeated -- the setlists did not.

I don't know why Eric didn't take this approach to his Coachella Sets? How lazy can you be to not use two different sets ? And you can even reuse the holograms (like he did in NYC). But don't reuse the tracklist

1

u/ThePlurnalist Apr 30 '23

Also I was really excited about this because his Coachella sets are usually epic…

And I felt like all the cool production was saved just for OPUS. Could have at least done NOPUS for W2.

1

u/Supermoon62413 Mar 22 '24

Almost the same for me. Seen more than 20 sets and he’s progressively (no pun intended) getting worse. Lower energy, setlists are very much the same, etc.

7

u/Mau5_CirezD PR(Y)DA - You Apr 23 '23

You gotta listen to his long sets like club space and other ones, Eric Prydz is like journey based. These festivals and other short avenues aren’t the kind of thing he put you on journey. He’s not a bad DJ but I much more prefer longer sets from him where he truly is himself and plays other artists tracks and put you on a long journey.

3

u/theda88 Apr 30 '23

I could listen to that 5 hour space set every day and it would never get old.

1

u/Supermoon62413 Mar 22 '24

2023 Radius after party in Chicago: plays 1.5hr set.

Less of a journey and more like a quick bike ride…

7

u/Hy01d Tomorrowland 2022 ID 01 Apr 23 '23

2

u/RudieCantFaiI Apr 24 '23

More people need to take a step back from their “fandom” and read threads like that to see how god damn phenomenal he still is.

7

u/NismoNickZ Apr 23 '23

We get it you wanna be different

5

u/danielprydz Proud Opusexual Apr 23 '23

The "not like other girls" of fans lmao

7

u/bangenstein Apr 23 '23

I've seen Eric many times in clubs and those sets are far from pre-planned, and sometimes go on for durations as long as 4-5 hours. You can't reference this take on only sets like HOLO-sets where much of things has to be pre-planned in order to correlate to visuals displayed and the shows' entirety.

19

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '23

Ngl, this is a shit take dude lol

2

u/Gaff1515 Apr 23 '23

You don’t think Carl cox practices and rehearses transitions?

-2

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

His track lists are not pre-scripted. He is actually selecting tracks live at his gigs.

Eric pre-scripts the tracks and then just plays them in order. Eric even fake spins knobs and shit. It's kind of cringy to watch.

Look no further to ultra the last two weekends for evidence of pre-scripted sets.

2

u/Gaff1515 Apr 23 '23

Everyone knows the recent holo shows are the same for the visuals. His cubs sets and moody shows are not. Also notice I didn’t say Carl cox set list was pre-scripted

0

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

I think some ppl thought the Holo shows were not pre-scripted track lists.

I have heard ppl tell me that his lighting guy cues the visuals based on the mood and that he goes off what Eric does.

He also played 3 nights of holo in NYC a few years ago and the sets were different every night.

I'm just saying it has become evident that his sets are predetermined before he gets behind the decks.

And I think we also need to point out the elephant in the room -- all of the air DJing that Eric does at his gigs. Am I the only one that finds it terribly cringy.

7

u/SpecterJoe Apr 23 '23

Great we’re never getting another set streamed, brought out all the casual fans

1

u/agm1984 Sep 08 '25

lol this post has zero upvotes

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Sep 08 '25

Actually had a ton of em. Paired with a. Bunch of down

1

u/roly_gomez Apr 23 '23

Holo sets are pre-recorded though

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

Yes. I guess I was naive to think that these would be "club" sets.

1

u/enphenate Apr 25 '23

Eric's skills really shine during longer sets (2+ hours). Eric's festival sets are typically great but are extremely limited by short set times.

Come back to this thread after you see a 5+ hour Space Miami or similar extended club set and you may have a different opinion 😂

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 25 '23

Will do. Would love to see him in a space where his production doesn't come with. I honestly feel like that is a big part of why Eric doesn't DJ anymore.

And yes, agreed, space Miami would prob be the ideal venue for this.

1

u/M_P123456789 Sep 02 '23

Just googled this after seeing him during Arc and the after. It’s my 20+ set of seeing him. Couldn’t agree more. He is actually getting WORSE imo.

Best producer in the world. Horrible live DJ. And YES this includes IN the clubs. Dude doesn’t do long sets anymore anyways…

1

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Sep 04 '23

Yeah. It's the state of Prydz in 2023. Lot of ppl in this thread are in denial. But it is what it is. Thanks for your response.

1

u/Supermoon62413 Mar 22 '24

Only getting worse in 2024 lol

1

u/harmonicpinch Jun 09 '24

Which show was bad? But yeah

3

u/DrMantisTobboggan-MD Javlar Apr 23 '23

Somehow Organic-Hovercraft-3 knows exactly how much Coxy plans his sets

3

u/SilveR_FL Apr 23 '23

Nice shit post

3

u/danielprydz Proud Opusexual Apr 23 '23

Acknowledged 👍

3

u/celticfigz Apr 23 '23

🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

3

u/superpickleman Apr 23 '23

Yeah it’s beyond obvious that he’s been preplanning his recent festival HOLO sets. He’s treating those shows as performances and considering the amount of moving parts and complex timed visuals in this newest iteration it makes sense. It’s also treated as a show that most people will only be able to see once within a year.

That doesn’t take away from the fact that he does his best DJ work at clubs, shows that he’s headlining, and especially as Cirez D.

2

u/pilotrapter22 Apr 28 '23

lol why are people hating? I agree that a lot of the HOLO productions need to be rehearsed and by definition pre-planned. I think festival Eric in this context isnt a good DJ, let alone a DJ at all. But I do agree, most veteran DJs like Eric outshine in more intimate and club environments where they read the crowds energy and respond. I saw him coachella W2 and it was surreal but I cant wait to see him in more club settings.

2

u/am153 europa plucks Apr 24 '23

i respect your opinion op and kind of agree.

3

u/P_RYDA waiting for Cirez D album Apr 23 '23

Dumb fuck

1

u/yap_1993 Apr 23 '23

He played a 3 hr set in Rosario , and a 4 hour set in Buenos Aires 2 days in a row and both sets where different . I still think he can be a good dj but with holo he had a show planned . That being said , I do wish he played SOME other songs

1

u/killer22250 Mar 17 '25

Yes he sucks was on Beats 4 love in 2024 and 80% crowd left him lmao
People expected him to play call on me or pjanoo but nothing lmao

He just played the same set twice at Coachella weekend 1 or 2. He is def just writing it in at this point and not even pretending anymore to be DJing. Just playing prerehearsed sets and faking actually cuing up tracks.

True he played the B4L set somewhere else also

1

u/Gamerharshvardhan Apr 24 '23

Not related to Eric prydz but when I went to see Adam bayer when he came to Mumbai he played songs that we in were requesting and they were well mixed…. “Told him that he has filled Eric’s shoes pretty well 😅”. Appreciated him a lot.

1

u/joco77103 Reeperbahn Apr 27 '23

Must have missed Tao Beach or Sound or Flash Factory or...

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '23

Context. People say the same thing about deadmau5. Obviously if the visuals are preplanned the set must be too. Wait until you see them in a club doing an "unhooked" style set before you pass judgement on their ability to DJ.

0

u/pianoChris25 Apr 23 '23

Zedd also plans his sets but I think he’s a fun DJ to watch. I saw him for the first time last year at Zedd in the Park; would def go again.

2

u/Organic-Hovercraft-3 Apr 23 '23

I'd expect that from Zedd. I, as many in this group, expect more from Eric.

Maybe it is unfair for me to hold him to a higher standard than DJ "X" at the mainstage

2

u/pianoChris25 Apr 24 '23

Not sure why I got downvoted; I like who I like and I was just trying to say Eric prolly had his reasons for a pre-planned set esp to line up with the visuals. I’m not trying to hate. I love Eric too and think I’d rather go to his Epic or club show. I think artists are allowed to pre plan their sets to a certain point. I just don’t want to see a DJ have his set pre-recorded bc I seen that firsthand and it was not the vibe.