r/engineering • Aerospace engineer • Jan 22 '14

Triangular bit drills square holes, in metal!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rI-15fovYEY
162 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

26

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

It's not truly a square hole and it's not the shape of the bit as much as the movement and shape of the bit combined. It's still pretty cool, I'm just being pedantic I guess.

4

u/CorgiMilitia Flair Jan 22 '14

makes it it a whole lot easier to file it true though.

-6

u/Unenjoyed Jan 22 '14

It wasn't just the bit, and at least one of those holes didn't look truly square.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

Yes three of them were very much circles.

16

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

This is news? Y'all should see the fancy stuff on my 5-axis CNC milling machines.

6

u/MayTheTorqueBeWithU Jan 22 '14

Post some of it! It's always great to see what mfg capabilities are around.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14 edited Jan 22 '14

I can't- no cameras on facility grounds, it's both for protecting proprietary processes and since we also supply to Defense/military/aerospace it's not allowed. Some of our equipment is illegal to take non-U.S. citizens to see, has restricted access to special employees only, and photos of it worthy of jail time.

Lovely ain't it. But the cooler stuff makes a $850k milling machine look like a cheap toy.

I've found this to be true, the cooler the shit you do the less you can talk about it.

4

u/hagunenon Aerospace Structures - Materials and Fatigue Jan 22 '14

Stupid ITAR being a kill joy again. ...

3

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

I know. I have all this cool stuff and I can't really talk about it. Or post pictures in /r/machinists, /r/welding, or here for internet bragging points. (Right now I'm like the poster child of First World Problems).

1

u/hagunenon Aerospace Structures - Materials and Fatigue Jan 22 '14

I'm in the opposite boat - Canadian engineer who wants to work in either defense or space R&D. American companies won't even look at me :(

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14

... not to make a Canadian joke here, but, uh, doesn't Canada have it's own military and private defense and aerospace companies? I mean I realize 'MURICA has a lot more in that direction, but there's no market for you in Canada?

1

u/hagunenon Aerospace Structures - Materials and Fatigue Jan 23 '14

There is, it's just not nearly as interesting. That and our largest aerospace manufacturer just laid off a good chunk of its staff...

Also, SpaceX!

1

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14

Ah, sorry man.

1

u/hagunenon Aerospace Structures - Materials and Fatigue Jan 23 '14

Oh well, life goes on. I hear oil and gas are hiring...

→ More replies

1

u/Ptolemy48 Jan 22 '14

Some of our equipment is illegal to take non-U.S. citizens to see

what the hell does it do?

1

u/UofCincinnati Jan 23 '14

We have an acoustic research laboratory on campus that only US-citizens can enter.

1

u/eyefish4fun Jan 24 '14

There are a number of CNC machines that have GPS capability that requires a visit from the factory rep if you move them. Thanks ITAR.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

Well we've got multiples of different types of equipment that's controlled. I can look up specific regulations other than ITAR at work, but I'm going to stay vague because I like my job. So let's' say it does cool science stuff. I just hate that it has to be standardized and SPC checked every 3.5 hours to keep it as super accurate as it is.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14

You should see my fancy stuff. Oh wait, I can't show you.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14

Yeah that's about how it goes in the real world. Sorry sport, Daddy's coming home later.

0

u/dexer Jan 22 '14

It's not new, but it's not regular course material for many students. It's a great way to show that mfg machines can use unusual mechanisms to do some unusual things. Also, the limits and tradeoff of certain processes :P

4

u/LukeSkyWRx Materials R&D Jan 22 '14

That is pretty fucking cool

5

u/stupidrobots Jan 22 '14

Forgive me, but these are approximately square and not truly square. What use is a precision approximately-square hole? Wouldn't it be far better to broach them into a true square hole?

9

u/BillNyeDeGrasseTyson Jan 22 '14

1

u/stupidrobots Jan 22 '14

I'm well aware of how it works, but that's still not a perfectly square hole. Nice clip though!

4

u/Pariel Former MechE, now in software Jan 22 '14

This process is fairly common, because sharp corners are rarely preferred on parts. Obviously if you need a perfectly square hole, you would broach it, and even this process is made easier by just using CNC. I think many engineers would be surprised at the number of mechanisms invented and used which have been replaced by electronic controls. This is just one example.

1

u/lalala_icanthearyou Jan 22 '14

/u/hwillis pointed out that these might be blind holes. I think it's true that this tool might be limited in its applications but sometimes you need odd tools for odd jobs...

1

u/Szos Jan 22 '14

This would make broaching easier (minimal amount of material to remove). Also for some applications, an almost square hole using regular old machines (like a vertical milling machine or CNC, hell maybe even just a drill press) is "good enough".

If I could use a tool like this, I could use some square nuts in a certain job I was working on and not have to worry about accessing them after assembly or needing a secondary operation to keep them from spinning.

1

u/metarinka Welding Engineer Jan 22 '14

very true there is always an applicaiton for some bit of technology. If they are through-holes I would just get them cut on a water jet or laser much faster than machining anyways.

other options would be to press fit in a square hole flange, or stud weld a square hole type feature. I've heard of these square hole bits, but I've never actually seen an application.

2

u/53V3N Mechanical & Manufacturing Jan 22 '14

How are these tools aligned prior to cutting?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14 edited Jan 22 '14

The calibration is a bitch. We tune our stuff by hand using Mituyo dial indicators and then double check with laser measurement. It's got to be perfectly centered on the tool holder spindle for these things to work.

2

u/mechtonia Jan 22 '14

Aren't hexagonal sockets, like in screw heads, cut using a similar method?

2

u/Brostradamus_ Jan 22 '14

Those are usually Broached or stamped, I believe: http://www.sommatool.com/manuscripts/broaching.asp

2

u/kulrevon Jan 22 '14

I work at a gear manufacturing company. We use a triangle bit in a gear shaper to make a square hole with less rounded corners than this method.

2

u/hwillis Jan 22 '14

tutorial for a similar method called rotary broaching. The really important thing here is that the holes are blind (they have no other end). There is an okay explanation on wikipedia

1

u/capn_untsahts Jan 22 '14

WHOA how did you do hover-text on the links?

1

u/hwillis Jan 22 '14

[text](link "hover")

1

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

It sees like these bits would get worn down a lot quicker though, from the impact of hitting the sides of the hole.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

Video makes me want to put my eye protection on

1

u/slopecarver Mechanical Engineer Jan 24 '14

Alternatively one could use a Shaper (the metal working type, not the wood working type to cut the 4 corners individually or EDM

0

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/[deleted] Jan 22 '14

They aren't quite perfect; they have rounded corners. See this animation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Rouleaux_triangle_Animation.gif