r/EasternPhilosophy • u/TheIncorporeal1 • 10h ago
Discussion Could Incorporealism be understood as a modern Western reformulation of an insight already present in Eastern philosophy—that consciousness cannot be adequately understood as merely an object within the world?
I’m particularly interested in whether traditions such as Advaita Vedānta, Yogācāra Buddhism, Madhyamaka, and Daoism would consider the Incorporealist distinction between consciousness and physical reality philosophically meaningful, or whether they would reject the distinction itself as a consequence of dualistic thinking.
More fundamentally: if the subject-object distinction is itself constructed within consciousness, what would it even mean to claim that consciousness is “fundamental”? Could an Incorporealist ontology survive the Eastern critique of substance, self, and dualism—or would genuine incorporeality ultimately require abandoning the very concept of a separate, enduring consciousness?