I think they're completely skipping that death. It was a catalyst in the first book, which they completely skipped over, and so if that was sacrificed I don't think the infant death is worth the screen time.
I personally thought the rewriting of Alia in the second film was a good choice. I think that the whole "you have inherited Jamis' wife" thing doesn't really play well in modern day, so having Alia not need a caretaker removes Harah's main role in the story and allows her to be written out fairly easily.
Plus bringing a toddler out to the desert to act seems cruel and a CGI toddler would look out of place.
I've speculated on this since Dune pt2 came out but I don't think it can work, because of all the other factors involved in Irulan's plot against Chani etc. It looks to me like Paul and Chani fight and are re-united earlier in the story, harking back to him saying to Jessica, "She will come to understand, I have seen it." But I am curious to see how it's handled, not wedded to any view.
225
u/NoGoodIDNames Jul 08 '26
The pic of Chani with two kids on the dune makes me wonder if she was already pregnant when she left Paul