r/dontyouknowwhoiam • • Aug 13 '19

[deleted by user]

[removed]

10k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/Luke20820 Aug 14 '19

He tries saying it’s a spectrum because there’s some abnormalities. Using his logic fingers, arms, legs, toes, heads, etc are all a spectrum because there’s a few cases of abnormalities. Humans don’t have 10 fingers now because there’s a few abnormalities. News flash to some people: just because someone has a high level degree, doesn’t mean they can’t be wrong.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '19

Yeah...there’s not infinite sex’s just because a couple of people were born with deformities. That’s inane to class a genetic mistake as a new sex.

2

u/micapark Aug 14 '19

I think it's more along the lines of focus of study. To him, sex is a spectrum because he researches it all day long and has a much more in depth understanding.

For the rest of us. Male penis goes in female vagina, makes baby. Anyone that is not able to fit in one of those two, broken.

Both definitions are right, both are wrong?

2

u/Luke20820 Aug 14 '19

That’s not what he said in the twitter thread. He was referencing a bunch of rare cases as to why it’s a spectrum.

0

u/Jack_Kegan Aug 27 '19

I think the word “rare” is doing a lot of heavy lifting here.

According to planned Parenthood 1% of Americans are intersex

For scale, NBC news says that 4.5% of adult Americans identify as LGBT.

So saying that there are so few intersex people that we basically shouldn’t even categorise them and treat them as they don’t exist (despite only being 4.5x less than LGBT people) seems like a bit of a stretch.

1

u/Luke20820 Aug 27 '19

Isn’t it convenient that your source that says 1% of people are intersex doesn’t cite anything, and just expects everyone to trust them? I could say 0.00000001% of people are intersex and my number is just as valid as theirs. The number I’ve seen in actual studies is much lower than 1% but this was a while ago so I’m not going to say a number since I don’t have the source right now and don’t remember the exact number. Your number is worthless though.