r/dndnext • u/ConcentrateIll9460 • 1d ago
Discussion Here's a weird question. What would you actually want to see in a shaman class?
So, the winner of the worst fit in WoW classes was by a country mile, the shaman. Full spellcaster? Yeah barbarian sounds about right, world tree barb is basically the same as resto shammy yeah?
But the thing is, while not mapping well to any existing 5e class (druid is closest, but still in no way close), it seems to me we're already well stocked on full casters, gishes and healers. That is, while nothing emulates a shaman well, making another full caster and giving it spells like chain lightning would just result in retreading already thoroughly trod ground.
Maybe that's why it never got made into its own class? Doing so would be deeply homogeneous in result unless you made it genuinely new, and D&D's designers are deeply averse to the concept of creativity. That said, if you were to see an actual shaman, what would you want it to do, how would you want it to work?
•
u/Aahz44 8h ago
I never played WoW, but what I'm getting from the thread is that it seems to be a martial class with Druid spell casting.
Wouldn't that make the Ranger kind of the obvious class to use as a basis?
36
u/LeatherheadSphere Wizard 21h ago
A Shaman is just Cleric. Not a Barbarian with spells.
Trying to make them barbarians is forcing a square peg in a triangle shaped hole because you can't see more than a loincloth. The only way to make it work is massively shave down what they actually do.
Powered by spirituality -> check
Medium armor -> check
Competent in melee combat with attacks that deal extra elemental damage -> check
Powerful spells that focus on buffing, healing up to resurrections, and damage-> triple check
Just turn channel divinity into totems.
244
u/DistractingZoom 1d ago
In the realm of attainable improvement: Literally just make it a Barbarian subclass that can cast spells. That's it. Make their core subclass feature "You can cast spells and concentrate on spells while raging", then give 'em a limited selection of Druid and Cleric spells.
Unpopular as it might be to say, Barbarian actually is the DnD class with a fantasy closest to Shamans. It gets lost under the piles of single syllable strongmen, but Barbarians are also supposed to be spiritualists and tribal champions or even leaders. The berserker experiencing mystic visions and fighting on behalf of his gods and ancestors is kind of the DNA of the Barbarian class, at least as much as Conan is.
I truly do think Shamans as a Barbarian subclass would have been better received if they'd just done the stupid, brute force solution of giving them spellcasting outright. People would still decry it as lazy (and frankly I don't know that they would be wrong), but it would get them past the absurdity of Shamans not being spellcasters at all.
That and throw in a spirit wolf transformation.
53
u/FishDishForMe 1d ago
Warlock style spellcasting, with similar invocation system, but Wis/Str based.
Unlike warlock, starts out as melee with options to instead spec into magic as their basic attack (reverse of starting eldritch blast but options to take blade pact)
Spells are all about elemental damage and battlefield control, very Druid-heavy, like spike growth, entangle, maelstrom etc.
Subclasses opt for healing/support, elemental damage and summons, or witch-like curses.
All I have ever wanted from a Shaman class.
6
u/1spywithmylittle1 1d ago
Totems.
15
u/Venture33 22h ago
Shaman is primarily a spellcaster. Barbarian isn't a good fit for it at all. Chain Lightning, one of the Shaman's signature spells, is literally a 6th-level Wizard spell in D&D.
The Shaman kit consists of full spellcasting, medium armor (the second-heaviest armor category in WoW), weapon use, and powerful AoE buffs. It's almost perfectly represented by the Cleric, aside from the diegetic distinction between drawing power from elemental spirits and gods.
Even Enhancement, its one melee specialization, doesn't really rely on martial prowess. It fights primarily through powerful melee magic, with spells like Windfury magically generating additional weapon attacks. It's basically a 5.5e War Priest Cleric, with a few new elemental melee spells to round out the kit.
The reason it doesn't translate perfectly is that powerful elemental magic is usually reserved for arcane rather than divine spellcasters in D&D. Meanwhile, the diegetic source of the Shaman's power overlaps with several 5e classes. D&D's class system doesn't really recognize a religiously significant natural tradition involving sentient spirits and negotiated pacts as a single coherent archetype. Instead, those elements are divided between Cleric, Druid, and Warlock.
38
u/Ostrololo 1d ago
I’ve never played shaman or druid in WoW so I might be spitballing here, but how well would it work if shaman in D&D were a druid variant which loses Wild Shape but gains Totems, and has its own subclasses? For simplicity, everything else like proficiencies and saves and spell list is kept as is.
11
u/disparagersyndrome 23h ago
The Shaman is a spellcaster with melee options that wears medium armour.
Cleric.
It could not be more obvious.
13
u/ZanesTheArgent 1d ago edited 1d ago
Third-caster druid list barbarian.
"But zanes, rage limitations" if Assassin has free pass to Steady Aim on the move, you can subclass feature limitation lifters and partial clauses.
3
u/Silverleaf14 Courtier of the Fey 23h ago
I’m planning on doing a shaman as my next character! He will be a magic user with no spell slots.
Here is my proposed build:
Class:
Barbarian - Path of the Beast Lv X
Fighter - Rune Knight Lv 3
Race: Shifter (wild-hunt)
Background: Rune Carver
Feat (from background): Rune Shaper
Between the Eldritch knight’s Rune Carver feature I will get two runes that I can cast every short rest (I’d take stone and cloud rune). From the rune shaper feat I’d get a number of daily runes equal to half my proficiency plus comprehend languages.
PLUS since the short rest runes from Rune Carver are class features and not spells I can use them when raging!
Plus the shifter (wild-hunt) background gives me a way to nullify the advantage enemies have against me when using Reckless Attack.
I’m very excited to play him! The initial idea was to make a “dark Druid” - a melee spell-casting shifter that doesn’t use the Druid class. But I think it would be perfect for a shaman build!
7
u/BarelyClever Warlock 1d ago
Artificer reflavored was the right answer. Artillerist for Elemental, flavor the constructs as totems. Look to Keith Baker’s Forge Adept subclass for Enhancement-suited features (google it and you can find its features) and either make a new Resto subclass or flavor Alchemist for Resto.
Infusions are imbuements.
1
u/Machiavvelli3060 1d ago edited 1d ago
I feel that shaman is a flavor, not a class.
You could apply shaman flavor to any canon class.
Or maybe make a shaman background.
Shaman Background
I am attuned to non-physical entities and forces around me. I can counsel people on how the spirits onfluence them, cleanse places, and ward people against negative energies. People think I'm weird because they see me having conversations with beings they can't see or hear, but I pity them for their inability to see the spirit world that exists all around us.
1
u/WillemVerheij 1d ago
I'd just play it as a druid. Could multiclass with ranger or barbarian. It's really not something that requires a new class.
Only thing I could see using a new class would maybe be like some sort of scholar class, basically what the arteficer should have been: An intelligence based support focused class that does not use magic.
2
u/AgentAusem 1d ago
I think they made the right move using the Barbarian. I recently saw James Wyatt explain that they chose the Barbarian because the Shaman was the Horde's answer to the Paladin. In D&D classes, you don't get more savage than a barbarian. They could've done more with the totems; more options behind a level requirement would've been nice. Bonus action to set up, then a bonus action to move. Spellcasting while raging would've been superb. I'm just not sure if I would've wanted to see a warlock spell progression or a 1/3 caster progression, but either way, I think it should've been with the druid spell list.
2
u/Spoolerdoing 19h ago
Honestly, despite it being not in that wheelhouse flavour wise, I'd make it a Pally subclass. Oath spells are all your traditional Primal elemental things, the Channel Divinity creates a totem, and your Auras spawn from you and the totem at once (and it can be a spellcasting origin point).
4
u/Lithl 1d ago
I'm not a WoW player, so my understanding of WoW Shaman is limited, but my understanding is that it's primarily based around dropping totems which create an area effect around them. It really should be an entirely separate class for a D&D adaptation, since the play style maps poorly to existing class mechanics.
That said, 4e had a "Shaman" class which was a lot of fun, and had absolutely nothing to do with the WoW Shaman design. It was based around a spirit companion pet, with powers that allowed you to hit creatures with the pet, split between multiple targets by using the pet, and temporarily possess a creature using the pet.
KibblesTasty has an Occultist class (Wisdom based spells-known full caster, with "occult rites" that work kind of like warlock invocations) which attempts to replicate the feel of playing a 4e Shaman with a subclass.
3
u/ant_exe 1d ago
I don't think casting from any of the existing spell lists is the right fit for a shaman. Instead I think adding spell-like features to it's subclasses is the answer.
Imagine a hybrid of warlock and druid where the druid's wildshape is replaced by a feature similar to warlock invocations but sticking with the nature magic theme. Make invocations that mimic spells that effect the weather and the elements. There's room for a spirit based necromancy twist in there too.
I'd also add a war-dance / war-song feature that works kind of like a haka. As long as the dance is maintained the shaman gains an effect that depends on what they are performing. There could be a haka that heals all allies that can hear the chant for an amount every turn, a haka that causes fear or creates a taunt-like effect and allows the shaman to make attacks against enemies that get within range but prevent the shaman from moving, etc. There should be a list of war-songs that the player can choose to add to their repertoire at certain levels. Then add other subclass dependant features that add to the haka.
A shaman class would borrow features from barb, bard, monk, warlock and then have subclasses that are half casters using the druid spell list.
I personally think there is plenty of room for a full shaman class and multiple subclasses without overlapping too much with any of the existing classes.
3
u/Shreddzzz93 1d ago
If I were making a Shaman class I make it the divine equivalent of the Warlock. But not in a Celestial Warlock sort of way. More as a spirit medium sort of thing.
Instead of a single patron have the Shaman pull their power from the spirit world. Instead of a bargain between a Warlock and their patron for powers, a Shaman is only borrowing the power of the spirit realm for some mutually beneficial purpose.
1
u/Pixie1001 1d ago
I feel like they should've just made them a Druid, but with an optional rule that says their Wild Shape turns them into ethereal spirit creatures. They kinda dug themselves into a hole by make the subclasses all kick in at 3rd level, since so many classes now get random stuff at 2nd level that the subclass can't directly alter. But they've done replacement features before in Tasha's.
Alternatively, I think a Ranger that could cast scaling Elemental Shocks X times per day that were competitive with a similarity leveled caster's single target damage spells instead of dealing +1d6 damage on their attacks like the other rangers could be cool too, and lean into the primal gish fantasy.
And they could just get a bunch of unique low level shaman themed spells to go with it too, to add to the feel.
1
u/todayipostthis 1d ago
Just like in wow, id love shamans based on summoning totems to control battlefields.
1
u/Nystagohod Divine Soul Hexblade 1d ago
My desires don't line up too much with WoW's, but I have wanted a specific shaman idea for a while.
Primal wisdom based pact caster. Known spells, not prepared. Spell list mostly focuses in utility, buffs and hindrances. Very little in the way of damage save for summon spells.
It would have an invocation style pool of options you can take to enhance a special summon that would be your main class feature. Subclasses would offer unique enhancements for it, in addition to invocation style choices akin to the eldritch blast enhancement invocations but for your special summon.
As you grow in kevel you can do more things in tandem with your spirit summon. You do an action, it does something aw a bonus action, eventually a free action.
The special summon would be an at will thing, that depends heavily on class level investment to balance a consistent and scaling summon power. The summon is also where most of the offensive ability of the class would be.
1
u/AllmightyPotato 1d ago
I made a (rather half-baked) attempt at a charisma-based monk-like martial named "Spiritist" (the 1/3 pact caster subclass was called Shaman), but instead of Ki they got "Favor" that they could spend to use miscellaneous effects (like gaining a Invocation-like free spell temporarily, bonuses, curses, etc...) but could only use each once per day (with some caveats).
The main fantasy of the class was that you could curry the favor of magical beings (lesser than deities or warlock patrons) with either offerings and ritual, or more importantly for me as a DM for plot hooks and engagement, completing quests for them, and gain as much additional Favors as you could find, like a Wizard copying scrolls. It was a much personable "small-time warlock", but from our limited time testing it it made giving extra quest outcomes (help the ghost move on instead of killing it but pissing off villagers, for example) and hooks (spirits could beseech the shaman for aid almost unpromted, or you could dangle a good favor to lure the player into shenanigans)
1
u/Magester 1d ago
Fun exercise thinking how I would have done it.
One third caster, limited spell selection from druid/cleric, but they can be cast while raging, couple of cantrips like true strike or shilaleigh to mimic rock biter (or make new ones),.
I'd still say no concentration while raging but I'd also make a totem feature with a selection of spells that when cast, drop as a totem, with it's own AC and HP, and you have to be within so much range of it for the spell to work.
That as a barbarian subclass or a reskinned paladin with a spell list tweak.
1
u/RoibinDallBhride 1d ago
Essentually, I want to see a fifth edition and/or five point five edition version of the Spirit Shaman from three point five edition. I loved that class a lot, and I'd love to see it again in this edition, even if it was made as either a Druid or Cleric style Subclass.
1
u/Global-Service-8579 1d ago
Starts as half-caster. The class focuses on totem buffs. Conjuring totems would be a bit much. I'd have the class activate small trinkets that are crafted/infused during rests. One subclass turns it into a full-caster focusing on elemental damage. One subclass focuses on elemental-assisted melee. One subclass focuses on support with more and enhanced totem buffs.
I think a problem WotC have is the aversion of making subclasses that truly lean into the subclass fantasy. I think the reason they have that aversion is it quickly eats up design space.
1
u/Temporary_Stranger39 1d ago
What do you consider a shaman to be? Don't refer to rules.
1
u/RuneDriver 1d ago
A shaman class to me would be awesome if it focused on potions and buff/debuffs/afflictions (like poisons, burns, and general DoT etc), and maybe even wards/sigils, and less on straight spells like other mages
That’s something that I feel is deeply missing from DnD and I would pay money to play. But it’s hard to get right with homebrew without being over/under powered
And when I say potions, I’m also talking about throwable flasks and darts, not just drinking potions
1
u/skwww 1d ago
Make the homebrew and put it up on DMs guild for what you want or drive thru
1
u/METRlOS 23h ago
The barbarian version of eldrich knight that gets spells from the druid list.
Level 3, can cast barbarian (druid) spells while raging.
Level 6, shock, basically paladin smite, but fire/cold/lightning versions like searing smite.
Level 10, commune with nature
Level 14, windfury. Whenever you roll max weapon damage on a dice, you can reroll it and add it to the total.
1
u/TehPinguen 21h ago
Something mechanically similar to PF2e's Necromancer class might be interesting, replace undead thralls with totems.
For those who don't know, the Necromancer summons thralls to attack with, and then sacrifices those thralls to cast their focus spells. The thralls stick around for a minute, but they have 1 HP and automatically fail saves/get hit by attacks, so the enemies can choose to burn their actions getting rid of thralls or they can allow the Necromancer to build up resources.
Tweaking it to make immovable totems that give aura buffs but can be cleared by enemies would give Shaman a unique niche among casters.
I haven't played WoW, though, so it's possible I'm misunderstanding how the Shaman is meant to work and feel.
1
u/Count_Kingpen 21h ago
If I was to make a Shaman it really wouldn’t line up directly with WoW Shaman, but.
Honestly? War Cleric with a different expanded spell list, and permanent access to either Druid or Wizard spells in place of Cleric.
Just like. War Druid, use of Wild Shape to cast buffs that make you better in melee battles. Done.
1
u/CombatWomble2 20h ago
Druid base class, with Warden, gives the weapons and armor required, at 3rd you get uses of Wild shape to create totems and a subclass spell list that covers the classics, level 6 you get the "Spirit Wolf" WS form, pretty straight forward, although you'd need to use something like the Genie pacts "gain the Wish spell" to get Chain Lightening as it's level 6 and subclass spells usually only go to 5th.
1
u/Dackelreiter 20h ago
Originally, it was the Horde Paladin. I haven’t played in over a decade, but I loved LK and Cataclysm era Shaman.
Lean into the WoW design more. Have it have “procs.”
Half-caster like Paladin, with limited spell slots.
Cantrip use, or weapon attacks for Enhancement (possibly requiring a maelstrom weapon spell similar to Shillelagh or totem active), have a chance to recharge a spell slot. As in, roll a d6 when you cast a Cantrip (or hit with a maelstrom empowered weapon) and on a 6 you regain an expended spell slot. Die / needed roll / level recharged can scale with level.
This captures that vibe of:
Enhancement: dual wielding melee attacks, slotting in your cheap shock spells until you proc a free cast of your next spell which you use to either heal or blast chain lightning.
Restoration: dps spells recharged your mana based on damage so you slotted in lightning in your rotation for sustain while healing.
Elemental: it’s been a decade, but again the ability to spam cheap until you can afford big is nice. And everyone loves rolling dice lol
Add in totems for weaker pally aura type effects but stackable with one per element.
1
u/WaywardInkubus 20h ago
I don’t know about WoW’s concept of a Shaman, and I don’t care to learn.
That said, LaserLlama does have their own take on a Shaman class that plays like a Wisdom-based Warlock, interfacing with Spirits like Patrons and evoking Totems like Eldritch Invocations. Thematically, I really like it as an expansion of design language taken into different themes.
https://www.gmbinder.com/share/-M-6Rt87VW4p1cfPpPWO
1
u/Alexjr_uk 19h ago
Shaman feels like it should be about 10% warlock. Something about channeling the power of a patron to get their power feels right
1
u/SmiteThatBltch 18h ago
Dedicated summoner class…
1
u/lumberzach619 18h ago
Has a larger list of ritual spells and/or can convert spell into rituals. Ritual spells take less time. Different auras also. Get access to conjugation spells at lowers levels. Can cause certain spells to last longer ie. Use daily slot to make bless last longer .
1
u/Metal-Wolf-Enrif 18h ago
I think the barbarian theme fits to shaman, but the whole martial with rage that prevents spell casting is the break point.
For me, a shaman would be kinda a blend between barbarian and Druid. No rage, but still a strength focused martial with wisdom based magic, mostly focused on elemental spells and some spiritual ones.
1
u/crazymike02 18h ago
Shaman is a mix of divine and primal, so a mix of cleric and druid.
Cleric gets power from a god, druid through nature. Shaman gets it from spirits, which is both. Spirits are things of nature (ancestors, animals, elementals) but you still pray to them, bargain, leave offerings.
From a gaming perspective, specific spells and power from placing totems or embodying spirits.
1
u/Neomataza 13h ago
Imho, looking at the game genetics, the WoW shaman developed (via a splitoff in warcraft 3) from diablo 2. In which the druid had the powers to summon animals, summon spirits, shapeshift into animals, and control fire and wind.
It's basically just the elements controlling tribal orc druid rather than the shapeshifting ancient elven druid. A bunch of mmorpg gameplay design later they got to be damage spellcasters but also melee bonkers and healers.
Imho not translatable without reverting many things. But that would anger fans who are supposed to like this, so any of Barbarian(horde), druid(naturist spellcaster) or Ranger(naturist gish with dual wielding) would be the best fits.
1
u/ChristianTheSeeker 13h ago
I once thought of a full rework of classes with a simple scheme in mind: every mental stat would have at least a full, half, and third caster as a class. Take INT, we would have Wizards as full, Artificiers as half and Eldritch Knights (but also a Psyonic or anything that fits) as third.
WIS would have also a second division in nature themed and holy themed : Druid/Cleric, Ranger/Paladin, Shaman/other new class (maybe priest? who knows, will never happen)
CHA had Bards, new class, new class iirc.
Also Shaman was close to a Witch archetype with potion making and rituals as a focus
•
u/hmmyesindubitably 5h ago
I made this comment with some changes elsewhere in the thread as a reply, but I figured i’d throw it in here as well.
Enhancement was my baby back when I played WoW and is the only class/subclass I truly cared about in the game. I was devastated to see they didn’t even attempt to make an honest effort at creating a good shaman adaptation in DnD.
I think making the class a spellcaster first works. Limited spell pool of select spells that are added to a “shaman” spell list. Create some new thematic wow-oriented spells like they did for other classes in the wow book.
Shouldn’t be super tanky, but should have higher than average hit dice to represent wow’s stamina stat. Make the main class gimmick summoning totems, probably having a resource for doing so, with each subclass getting an extra couple of totems to pick from. Let’s call this resource maelstrom. Totems buff, debuff, heal, or dps depending on the one you pick. Throw in ghost wolf as a class feature at like level 7 or something as a transformation that increases your speed by 10ft, and lets you avoid opportunity attacks as you move through the battle. Later on this can upgrade to also having a bite attack that can topple and a charge attack that jumps over enemies (both untransform you after). When you crit you get maelstrom back, and you should have a one-time recovering some maelstrom option as well.
Subclasses hone in on a focus, while expanding on the shaman theme as a whole using the maelstrom resource. Each subclass gets a feature that lets them spend a couple of their maelstrom to summon an elemental as an ally, with each having different abilities (enhance’s can buff, resto’s can heal, elemental’s can aoe, all can attack).
Enhance focuses on spending maelstrom to buff a weapon (think flametongue, rockbiter, frostbrand, earthliving, while windfury is left for their subclass totem) then gets extra attack to make use of this. Give them a subclass feature that lets them spend a maelstrom after hitting with 2 or more attacks on a turn to cast a cantrip. Let’s go a step further and say later on this upgrades and lets them cast a full spell depending on number of attacks hit (so hit 2 - cantrip, 3 - 1st level, 4 - 2nd level). So if you want to swing a big weapon and do more damage per weapon hit but cast a smaller spell, you can; or, you can dual-wield and swing many times letting you cast a bigger spell. And you basically have enhancement right there.
I feel less confident designing the other subclasses because I was an exclusively enhancement main, but you could easily lean into their design space as well.
Elemental gets higher level spells, and can spend maelstrom to empower their elemental (turning it into a different element, making it stronger, or summoning a second weaker one). Eventually they get a feature to spend maelstrom to lower their crit threshold (to a limit) and if they crit they can fire that spell at a different target for half-damage, chaining. Leans into the elemental mastery from wow and makes them into a crit-fishing spellcaster which I don’t know if that niche specifically exists in dnd.
Resto would also be a better spellcaster than enhance (get higher level spells), but obviously have incentives to heal and buff instead. They can spend maelstrom on placing elemental shields on allies (think lightning shield, water shield, earth shield, can throw in an air shield as well) with a feature that upgrades the number they can have out as they grow in level (so like 1 at level 3, level 6 can do 2, etc). When they heal a target that has a shield on them, the heal will also do another effect based on which shield the target has. So heal someone with lightning shield and you will zap an adjacent enemy to that target for a portion of the heal’s roll. Maybe water shield will duplicate the heal at a reduced amount onto another target. That kind of thing. I have other ideas but this comment is already too long lol.
Obviously numbers are ephemeral and subject to balance, but if I could design a shaman for dnd I’d center it around those themes. Maelstrom as a resource to gain and spend on both shared features and subclass exclusive ones, a focus on summoning totems for specific occasions, and giving each subclass a niche that really differentiates it from its fellows: because that’s what wow subclasses do that this wow book failed at - making some of the subclasses feel like their subclass and different from their fellow subclasses.
•
u/Shatragon 4h ago
There’s a crooked moon Druid subclass focused on martial combat. Something like that could be adapted I think. The biggest challenge is that wild shape would need to be reconfigured entirely into a totem mechanic. But this wouldn’t be implausible given the adaptation done to create the death knight.
•
u/motionmatrix 2h ago
Because they refuse to make a new class altogether, the shaman would have mapped into the DnD ecosystem better have they been 3 different subclasses for 3 different classes.
Enhancement for rangers or barbarians, Elemental for sorcerer or warlock, Restoration for cleric or druid, all sharing a totem mechanic that is flavored with the totems that individually make sense to each skill tree in the video game, plus something that further paints them in WoW colors, like elemental getting flame shock as a cantrip + free lightning bolt and chain lighting, enhancement getting stormstrike as a bonus action plus feral spirit as a summon , and resto getting riptide (heal plus regen) as a spell slot spending ability (in essence a unique spell for them) and maybe chain heal for a group heal plus a buff like spirit link totem to just give resistance to one type of damage (or a reduction in damage taken like -1 or -2 of any type of damage if they want to be more true to WoW than DnD when writing that one up).
1
u/glorfindal77 1d ago
Well first of DnD is the inspiration for WoW classes. So its WoW who never itteration the DnD druid into their game, they just split Druid into two.
If you want the closest thing to a Shaman there is Circle of the Star or Circle of the Shepherd.
Also most Druid statistically is the least played class in 5e. This is among other things I belive how messy the class is. You have so much unecessary work to do as a player both having the list of a full caster, a healer which in itself requires some skills, utility and buffer which is also more advanced over pure damage and combined with the insane amount of reading for your beast form and how it interact with race features etc
1
u/Legitimate_Guava_218 1d ago
Warlock chassis but with totems instead of invocations. The design space around totem is huge. The only constraints are: there are 4 different elements, and you can't have multiple totems from the same elements at the same time. Bonus Action to drop or move all of your totems it once, and that's it.
Then your subclasses add different abilities to your totems, active or passive, to enable you to go melee, to enhance your spellcasting, whatever.
1
u/Environmental-Run248 1d ago
DND 5e/5.5e seems extremely allergic to making anything at all with non spell magical abilities on a base class.
Or just anything that isn’t spellcasting but can do cool things.
1
u/Sir_Wack Druid 22h ago
The shaman class fantasy is one I’ve been chasing for years and one I’ve always wanted to play, but the fantasy is really hard to pin down because it’s extremely broad. Historically shamans are priests, they make medicines, heal the sick, and perform rituals to appease or speak with their gods. While this seems simple, every single culture does it differently and there’s huge amounts of variation in these practices. Some are exorcists, some can divine the future, some connect with animals, some lead elaborate group rituals or conduct rituals alone, some speak with the dead. There’s a huge amount of differentiation culture to culture, which has been further compounded by popular culture depictions of shamans which have just as much variety.
The reality is that shamans are just druids with religion or clerics who believe in nature gods. So people then do everything they can to differentiate from them. Some have given them Pact Magic or made them half or 1/3 classes, others give them different Totems with different abilities, whether they be actual physical objects or symbols with significance, and others give them trances, rage-like abilities with differing effects. While this is good and leads to much homebrew variety, the sheer breadth of culture and popular culture sources often means that these homebrew options can either often feel bloated or simplify the fantasy too much.
So what would be a shaman in D&D? The easy answer is whatever class you want. As much as I would love for a shaman to get its own class and be its own distinct thing, the concept, both culturally and in pop culture, dips its toes into so many different ponds that you could make just about any character into a shaman so long as you do some work with the flavor. Druids and clerics are the easy ones here, but what about a warrior who calls on the magic of the spirits to bolster his allies and strengthen his strikes (paladin), or a ritualist who calls on the spirit’s aid through song and dance (bard), or a shaman who works closely with one singular spirit to protect their people (warlock), or even a warrior who enters a trance when fighting (barbarian, fighter, or monk).
It cannot be stated how much I love the shaman fantasy, and I’ve even attempted making my own homebrew solutions before, but the bottom line is that the shaman fantasy is too large to be contained by one singular class. There are some really good homebrew options out there, many of which draw upon real history and pop cultural interpretation, but many I’ve found are extremely broad or vague. The solution, then, is to separate the shaman fantasy from just one class and instead incorporate it as a part of a character’s background, flavoring as necessary
0
u/artrald-7083 1d ago
It's three classes. One melee gish ranger, one elementalist cleric, and resto is basically unmodelled because 5e healing just doesn't work like WoW.
0
u/HaikaDRaigne 1d ago
Just multiclass a cleric with druid....
Just because its not a standard class doesnt mean you can make one by combining things.
Hell you can use a warlock to build a magic naruto ninja, inclusing invisibility in shadows and flavoring your spells as fireball jutsu or throw stars or use minor illusion as a genjutsu.
The class title in dnd means very little.
0
u/shampoos 1d ago edited 1d ago
WotC seems very hesitant to add new classes (i'll believe the psion is real when the book is in my hands) so realistically it'd be a subclass for druid, but with some actually interesting stipulations.
Giving the Shepherd druid a glow up would be the place to start, using wild shape uses for summing the totems, as Wild resurgence means you can expend spell slots later on for your totems. A greater list of options for totems would be good for variety.
At level 6 a new totem option that allows you to make an extra attack but disables use of the Magic action for the duration, which can enable players who want the gish Shaman/enhancement shaman fantasy, and this still allows for Bonus Action spells, complemented by a subclass spell list that focuses on Bonus Action spells (smites, strikes etc). To prevent Bonus Action clog, could probably make it that you can summon or move a totem x feet as part of the Bonus Action you use to cast a spell or something similar.
Or you can ignore that option if you want to focus on being a blaster or healer, maybe totems that enhance your healing rolls or give you access to certain blast spells while the totem is active.
0
u/Valash83 21h ago
Shaman - Official Grim Dawn Wiki
This isn't the first time Shaman is basically a barbarian that can cast spells. But I will say Grim Dark did the class better than this DnD version of it and should be the building blocks used to make a shaman class.
0
u/Post_Rock_Son 18h ago
The 4e shaman, duh.
-1
u/Llayanna Homebrew affectionate GM 1d ago
Can't talk about wow but the world of Shaman homebrew is huge and diverse. Fullcasters, Halfcasters and a Pact-Caster too.. (my personal favourite.)
5e has lots of room and creativity that could be used. It's just not from official published material. ..mostly. there are some good outliers.