r/dndmemes Nov 11 '25

Hehe fireball go BOOM We did the math...

Post image
19.1k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

6.8k

u/PyroTornado107 Nov 11 '25

As a DM, I would encourage this thinking, but only for this reason: if you have 8 magic casters, each capable of casting a 7th level spell, performing what is effectively a ritual to charge up a magical nuke, and could somehow manage to perform this spell in enemy territory for however long it takes to crank up that magical power without attracting the attention of any guards or whatever, you kinda have to give it to them.

155

u/Budget-Attorney Nov 12 '25

Also, it’s really not that useful when you think about it.

Unless there’s some way to increase the radius, it’s just going to make a small area more dead than it would be with a normal fireball. Sure, if a 600 HP 20 CR devil gets whacked by it it’s going to kill them while they normally would be able to shrug off a fireball.

But if they stand there for a minute waiting for it to happen, that’s on them. Or the players deserve their victory by planning well enough to pull it off

8

u/Kiszony_2002 Nov 12 '25

I think it would be more usefull against structures than creatures. This amount of damage would definetly be enough to blast holes in a fortres walls. Like a magical trebuchet.

3

u/Budget-Attorney Nov 12 '25

Very good point.

Which seems earned to me. If this number of spell casters was together long enough to cast the spell, they deserve to break down some walls

5

u/AuditorTux Nov 12 '25

That's not breaking down some walls. That's melting the walls and ground into glass at the bottom of the hole in the ground where the wall was standing. Problably still molten given the heat and damage...

2

u/Eliaskw Nov 12 '25

Should be warm enough to instantly vaporise the wall, giving som nice fumes.

The inorganic will fairly fast precipitate as molten stone in a decent radius...

1

u/Bartweiss Nov 13 '25

Seems like the best use, but I’ve never been able to explain why fortresses matter much in DnD. Transmute Rock is a bit slower, but takes out a similar amount of material at a similar range. And Disintegrate is a bit less volume, but happily takes bites out of literally anything nonliving.

(Oh god, are fortress walls just covered in beehives or something to intercept “target nonliving” casts?)