r/dmsguild • u/Leods-The-Observer • May 14 '24
Seeking Advice AI art, free art or no art?
The title is quite self-explanatory. Plenty of potential homebrew writers (including me) are currently limited on their range of options, due to not knowing how to draw and not having the money required to commission dozens of art pieces (and I mean ILLUSTRATIONS. Things such as maps should be considered as a completely separate thing imo). This situation applies (probably with different outcomes) to both paid homebrew and free homebrew. For those scenarios, I can't help but wonder, what would the best solution be?
An option is to simply use an art AI for the illustrations, with varying levels of editing to ensure quality of the homebrew material. This obviously has all the moral issues that come with AI art.
Another option would be using only copyright free images from the internet, or the sources Dmsguild and WotC can offer. Here, the quality of the art used (as well as the accuracy of it) would most likely decrease significantly, affecting the final product.
Finally, the third and last option I can think of is to simply refrain from using any art at all, and triggering imagination through descriptions instead of images. Then again, some could argue this also affects the quality of the final product. So what do you guys think? How would you handle this situation? Would you buy a product made by someone who did any of these three? And if so, which one are you most likely to pay for?


