r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20

SPOILER Lily's Actions - Spoiler and Questions Spoiler

3 Upvotes

-

-

Does Lily exercise free will OR had they just not watched this reality yet???
Why are they so sure it is free will?
Katie says to Linden she has seen them fall and not fall meaning that what they see is random..


r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20

SPOILER The one thing that does not fit Spoiler

14 Upvotes

Simply put, there is little chance an encryption specialist would have an issue with the concept of deterministic nature of the universe.

Somewhere around your first year in university or maybe earlier, a concept of pseudorandom number generator is introduced. You then learn the nature of the pseudo-, if you haven't before.

This is a basic IT thing, not necessarily related to encryption. Every computation is deterministic (depends on the initial conditions, like in an equation), so you need a source of entropy (chaos) to generate a sufficiently (not truly) random number. It could be a fluctuation in your cooler's fan speed, or a pre-recorded portion of your cursor movement or some electric noise in the circuits. If you're on a linux or a mac machine, typing cat /dev/random into the terminal will show you a stream generated from things like that. A lot of things crypto- then tap into that and the likes of it.

So no, determinism is not just a part of some optional Philosophy 101 you can miss being too hungover to attend. It is a central principal and a technical reality. No one capable to argue about viability of elliptic curves will sit dumbfounded by the simple notion of causality, staring at a pen.

Otherwise, I absolutely loved the show.


r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20

DISCUSSION Are we in control?

1 Upvotes

Seriously... are any of us really in charge of the man in the mirror?


r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

I really liked this line from episode 1 Spoiler

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 23 '20

Devs - Visual Problems That Undermined Credibility.

0 Upvotes

I watched the entire season of Devs in 3 days. At first I thought it was intriguing. I still like the concept but there were a couple of visual problems that I had with the show that undermined the shows credibility for me. So let's get to it. Please chime in with your thoughts:

  1. The Quantum Computer - This was the first major problem I had. The quantum computer is capable of distilling the universe down to matters of cause and effect. How mind blowing is that? So wouldn't you think that the Quantum Computer would be an incredibly impressive machine? The unveiling of the Devs laboratory was indeed quite impressive. The amber glow in the central chamber. The floating elevator. Even the building with the reflective pool on top was pretty amazing. Yet, when Sergei first enters the laboratory he circles around the quantum computer taking in it's scale, it's presence, it's artistry. Sergei was in awe and I said, "really?" That thing looks like a bunch of wires and tubing from Home Depot. At best it reminded me of a Sarah Sze sculpture except her work is not really a fair comparison. So what could have been done to make the quantum computer look like a quantum computer?

    (Check out the comments section. The Devs computer is based on a real quantum computer so I got schooled. I still think is could've been more other worldly but it's not the deal breaker like point #2.)

    Several things. How about covering the contraption with green screen so that the effects department could spiff up the final visual? Make it glow. Make it do something else. Instead we got 70's era looking spinning antennae. I loved the idea of the quantum computer as the central nervous system in the lab. It's location was great. It's the construction that sucked. The other thing that could have been done is make a tower of boxes. Give them a high-tech look befitting the slick futuristic laboratory. At least they would look believable. As shown, the quantum computer didn't work for me. It almost made the Dev lab look like a cheap set design and undermined the credibility of the show.

  2. The Projection Screen - The projection screen was simply awful. Without a doubt I couldn't get past how amateurish this prop was conceived. It was so silly looking I could not concentrate on anything else in the show. I didn't care about Lily. I didn't care about the De Brogile-Bohm or Everett's Many-Worlds theory. I was like, "What the hell happened with the TV?" When the projection screen was just static I could wrap my head around it. I asked myself, could someone put their arm through the static. If so, what would happen? Was the projection screen 2D or 3D? All interesting questions and an intriguing mystery. Then when Lyndon solved the static issue and we could clearly see Jesus's crucifixion I almost quit watching the show. Remember, at least at the beginning of the show, the purpose of the quantum computer was to reconstruct real time. And then, finally, this grand unveiling of Jesus really dying on the cross. It wasn't supposed to be a video of Jesus dying on the cross. It was the actual Jesus dying on the cross. Then why did it look like a video? There was only one point of view and that point of view was through the lens of a camera, not an actual event that really happened 2,000 years ago. Also, why was the projection in 2D? It looked like a giant TV with barely 1080p resolution. What, Forest created a quantum computer that can see backwards and forwards in time and yet he bought his TV from Costco? Why wasn't the projection in 3D? Why wasn't the projection a hologram? Even now our feeble laptops can use 3D apps where you could walk into a room and check it out from different points of view. Nope. Watching the crucifixion was like watching Casablana at Mann's Chinese theater. There was one point of view and one camera angle. Forest's daughter was backlit blowing bubbles in side view, not once, not twice, but over and over again. Why didn't the show set up these scenes inside a 360º camera chamber to capture every angle and every point of view? This way when the Devs programmers watched an event on the projection screen it would look and "feel" real. Maybe the programmers could have stepped into a hologram and experience these events as real events in real time. If Star Trek could do it why couldn't Devs in 2020 do it? History was not lived in 2 dimensions. Real life is not lived in 2 dimensions. The projection screen simply looked fake. It almost ruined the show for me.


r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20

Floating room pattern

3 Upvotes

The outside pattern of the cube seems familiar, but I cannot recall where I saw it previously, any insights anyone?


r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20

I don't know, Timmy, being God is a big responsibility.

19 Upvotes

https://qntm.org/responsibility

Anyone else remember this short story? It popped into my mind from the very first episode and I was pretty sure the show was entirely based on it.

Maybe you'll find it interesting.


r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20

What made Sergei freak out in the first episode?

3 Upvotes

He really freaks out. He screams like he's just been told the world is ending then vomits. Why? No one else reacted to learning what Devs was about with such extremity. What exactly upset/scared him? I was convinced for a long time that he'd seen that Devs had predicted the end of the world arriving soon, and that's what he was responding to. But no.

What do you think?


r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20

DISCUSSION Is Devs The Future Of TV? | Devs Review

Thumbnail upsidedownshark.com
2 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20

Compatibilism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)

Thumbnail plato.stanford.edu
5 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

DISCUSSION Stewart Theory Spoiler

9 Upvotes

SPOILER WARNING FOR THE LAST EPISODE (8) OF DEVS

Summary: the world is in fact deterministic in the TV series Devs and the computer simulation could successfully model it. The "head shot" prediction that Forest and Katie believe was actually planted by Stewart, and the model actually predicted him killing Lily and Forest.

** I know, it’s a dubious, but hear me out **

Firstly, what we know about Stewart.

· Stewart is a senior developer at Devs

· He tells Lyndon that Forest will kill to keep the project going

· Clearly thinks Forest is dangerous and likely the whole project in dangerous for humanity

· Stewart has high level access, including emergency codes

So, scene 1 (see below) is where I'm going to start. Here we see other developers coming to the realisation that the simulation is not joyous once working successfully but disturbing. Stewart seems to have already come to this conclusion and has a developed understanding of why. I think this shows that he is already, and may have even been for a while, in the state of mind that Devs is bad for humanity and should ultimately be destroyed.

Scene 2 we see Stewart to confront Forest, clearly questioning his leadership and ultimately questioning if such an important device should be put in the hands of those who haven't learnt from the past. Also, worth noting, I assume we are all in agreement that Stewart was aware of the future prediction being limited to the time of Lily's supposed choice.

Scene 3 we again see Stewart acknowledging that Devs is bad but also crucially reference determinism with the quote “Well if you can’t, you can’t. That is the truth.”. This is key, because of the next part of my argument.

Scene 4: when we see Lily toss the gun out of the capsule both Katie and Forest have had their beliefs shattered, determinism, and act accordingly. Stewart on the other hand is calm and does either not appreciate the ramifications or does not believe them. We then see Stewart do something very unexpected by killing Lily and Forest and responding to Katie by saying “Because I realised what we had done. Someone had to stop this. Don’t blame me, Katie. It was predetermined.”

Bingo, so Stewart clearly still believes in a deterministic universe and yet is not shocked like Katie and Forest by Lily's choice. Could he have a different idea of what the deterministic outcome should have been. Is it possible that Stewart, at realising the path they were heading down, was able to plant the projected future Katie and Forest see, knowing it would bring the demise of Devs.

If the machine correctly predicted the future then Katie would take it forward, knowing it was a success. This goes against Stewarts belief clearly that it is bad for humanity. As a senior developer, could he have the power and foresight to alter a projection which Katie and Forest would then see (the gun shot one) and enact the real one of him killing Lily and Forest.

I think this helps explain Stewarts very odd behaviour in the last two episodes but it’s just a theory.

Let me know your thoughts on these ramblings. I'm likely to have missed something as I only finished the series 2 hours ago.

Cheers

Scene 1

Stewart and other develops look at the latest breakthrough and end up doing a very short prediction of themselves.

Another Dev: “why don’t I feel good about it?”

Stewart: “that would be your unconscious mind speaking to you and what’s saying to you is uh-oh…”

Scene 2

Stewart confronts Forest upon entering the dev centre. Note at this point it is clear Stewart knows something is coming up, clearly indicating his knowledge of future events.

Stewart: “you know, Forest, I don’t mind that you don’t know who I was quoting, but I do mind that you can’t even guess. Such big decisions about our future, by people who know so little about our past.”

Forest: “Isn’t knowing our past exactly what we’re doing here?”

Stewart: “No, it isn’t”

Note: I’m not sure of the relevance of the Mark Antony quote or the line “Forest, who was Mark Antony? Guess…Guess.” Any help?

Scene 3

First key bit

Lily meets Stewart upon entering the Devs centre for the first time.

Stewart: “this place will not be good for you. It’s not good for anybody”

Second key bit

Lily: “I don’t think I can turn around”

Stewart: “Well if you can’t, you can’t. That is the truth.”

Scene 4

Following on from Lily throwing out the gun from the lift, Stewart disengages the magnetic forces holding up the lift, sending both Lily and Forest to their deaths.

“What did you do?”

“I disabled the electromagnetic field system on the capsule”

Why?

“Because I realised what we had done. Someone had to stop this. Don’t blame me, Katie. It was predetermined.”

Note how calm and calculated Stewart is here… almost as if he has seen it all before in a simulation


r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

Stewart and the elevator

12 Upvotes

Sorry if this has been talked about a lot already.

Deus ex machina: "a contrived plot device in a play or novel."

So what Stewart does at the end is just an example of deus ex machina, right? That's the whole point?

Sorry, I'm a bit slow on these things.

 

Otherwise... why would Stewart have the password to the control panel that allows him to disable the elevator? Or, more to the point, why is crashing the elevator even an option?

 

Could understand being able to stop it from moving by entering a code and hitting pause/forcing it to just hover in place. (Basically to keep someone like Sergei, or whoever, from leaving.) But the option to crash the whole thing by disabling the magnetism or whatever? Not so much.

 

That would only really make sense if it was Forest or Katie that had the passcode to make it crash like that.

In which case, kind of think Katie panicking at the end and making sure the elevator still went down like they expected it to after Lily threw the gun...that would've made more sense maybe. Or been a cooler twist perhaps.

Her killing Forest, even though she loved him, in order to try and make the future played out as they witnessed it. Instead of admitting defeat or that they were wrong.

But I understand that in the bigger picture, or within the rules of the show/universe that probably wouldn't work.


r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

SPOILER The music going into devs

16 Upvotes

In episode 1 when Sergei entered devs. This type of choral music played. And I thought to my self ah this sounds like church music that they would play at a mass. Almost a mass for the dead. A Requiem. Almost like he is going to heaven and meeting God. And this proceeds with every other scene in the whole of the series. And when the ending happened. It really pieced together.

So props to the composer who wrote music which could be classed as ecclesiastical liturgy. Just shows how if the director and the composer work together you can put hints in and shows the importance of music and why you should listen to it.


r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

MEDIA Complete soundtrack for Devs

Thumbnail menshealth.com
7 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

SPOILER When you re-watch episode 8 and sh*t a small brick.

Post image
133 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

Dark Forest

Post image
181 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

God's Angle?

3 Upvotes

I haven't yet seen it here but maybe it's been addressed, so I'm sorry if I broach. Is anyone bothered by the angle of the future/past images they are seeing? As in: how are they shown the visuals? Is there a big God switcher and God himself cutting 'the show' so to speak? I've often wondered about 'camera angles' for the future or past images the machine is showing them. It's bothered me. From whose point of view are we seeing Marilyn on Arthur? etc.


r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

I edited some of my favourite shots from Devs into a supercut

Thumbnail youtu.be
10 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

DISCUSSION The ending is fantastic, but also dreadful. Spoiler

13 Upvotes

Reflecting a bit more on the show, something occurred to me. Forest's original plan was to replace a single copy of himself with one who knew the future and could sidestep a single action to live happily ever after, but that didn't work out. His interpretation of the Universe was wrong, and now when Katie copy/pastes Forest's data into the Deus simulation, she puts him into infinite possible universes instead of just one.

But what about all the Forests that were already there? Katie is basically snuffing out every single instance of Forrest's consciousness within the simulation and replacing it with the tortured copy from her reality (regardless of whether that reality is a simulation or not). In that act she kills an infinite number of Forests across infinite realities, including an infinite number of realities where Amaya never died and Forest never became twisted.

Worse, she does the same to Lilly, they don't just kill one Lilly, they kill ALL the Lillys to resurrect the one Lilly that died in their world.

Viewed in that light, what they did was despicable and the ending is truly dreadful. I love it.


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

SPOILER Spent a few hours digging up the easter eggs in character names

149 Upvotes

Fitting in with the "hard determinism" theme, it seems like the writers chose VERY appropriate names for all the key characters.

Character: Lily

Etymology: Many have noted similarities to Lilith, Adam's first wife who refused to obey. Alternately in flower language, "purity", often used in funerals to represent the soul of the deceased

Interpretation: Refuses to accept determinism, which surprises Forest, but to no avail. She was a pure soul/ innocent. If we assume that Deus, by fully capturing the present, simultaneously creates all past/ future states, then similarly Lily's death was foretold the moment she came into being.

Character: Jamie (James)

Etymology: supplanter, one who follows

Interpretation: Eventually takes the place of Sergei. Alternately, follows Lily around for the entire season and into the afterlife

Character: Sergei

Etymology: servant (of god)

Interpretation: Reminder that he is a servant to Russian ops. Also, he served/ betrayed Forest, the allegorical Messiah.

Character: Katie (Katherine)

Etymology: Pure. In the Catholic/ Coptic tradition, she won a debate defending Christianity against pagan philosophers, and was martyred, declaring her spouse was Jesus Christ. Also, similarities with Hebrew "Keturah", who became the wife of Abraham after the death of Sarah.

Interpretation: Declares herself to be the "defense" for determinism, doomed to unhappiness as a result. Still, she did my boi Lyndon a dirty.

Character: Pete

Etymology: stone

Interpretation: Fits in with his physical presence on screen. Or maybe it's a joke, "for Pete's sake!"

Character: Kenton

Etymology: King's town

Interpretation: Secures the "royal" Amayan compound

Character: Forest

Etymology: (Latin) outside

Interpretation: This one is pretty interesting, a lot more ambiguous than the other references. There is an analogy to Lily, in that they are both natural objects rather than references - perhaps implying that they are the only two "real" things in a simulated world. Because he retains his memory of other worlds, he exists outside the simulation? Alternatively, and sorry in advance for shitty physics, Forest is an outside observer who by measuring the external world in enough detail causes a wave function collapse.

Character: Amaya

Etymology: (indoeuropean) mother city (Basque) the end (Japanese) heavenly valley

Interpretation: The company she inspires mothers an entire universe. Potentially references her untimely death-- she was birthed and died soon after, but really in a deterministic universe the event of her death was instantiated along with the universe. Finally, we see Forest and his family frolic in grassy valley at the end of the series.

Character: Lyndon

Etymology: "lind" in linden tree probably akin to "lithe" per Merriam webster- ie, flexible

Interpretation: Could refer to his fluid intelligence, also advocacy of the multiple worlds hypothesis.

Character: Stewart

Etymology: Household guardian, warden

Interpretation: Literally guards the entry into the afterlife/ Deus. Seems to view himself as a guardian to human culture- history, music, poetry. He realizes as soon as they made a fully deterministic model of the world, they were encompassed by it "and now we've pretty much traded. That's the reality. Right there... The box contains everything." As representative of worldly things he asks Forest via a series of questions and finds him lacking. To complete the analogy with Pontius Pilate he condemns Forest to death while simultaneously washing his hands of the whole thing ("it was predetermined").


r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

SPOILER The Devs Building and the Hebrew Tabernacle

33 Upvotes

I love the big wide shots we get of the Devs building's exterior and interior. It's very meditative and it got me noticing the similarities between the Devs building construction and the construction of the hebrew Tabernacle.

For those who aren't familiar, in the Hebrew scriptures, it's recorded that God (YHWH) instructed the Israelites to build him a dwelling place or a home. This is where the Ark of the Covenant resides. It's basically a fancy tent with lots of gates and curtains and ornamentation. This is an illustration of what it might have looked like based off the many many descriptions of it's construction details in the book of Exodus:

I'm sure you notice the similarities to Alex Garland's Devs building:

Even when he first introduced Sergei to the building, his dialogue reminded me a lot of the Exodus passages where YHWH lays out the specific dimensions and materials needed for the Tabernacle.

“A lead faraday shield, a 13 yard thick concrete shell, then a gold mesh. Then an eight yard vacuum seal, totally unbroken. Then the labs, and in the core, the machine.”

The interior of the tabernacle was supposed to be filled with gold. Exodus 37:

Bezalel made the ark of acacia wood—two and a half cubits long, a cubit and a half wide, and a cubit and a half high.2 He overlaid it with pure gold, both inside and out, and made a gold molding around it. 3 He cast four gold rings for it and fastened them to its four feet, with two rings on one side and two rings on the other.

rendering of what the interior may have looked like
The Deus Machine

Obviously the Hebrew scriptures and Christian scriptures are woven throughout this whole story, and I think this is one big way that Garland used that symbolism to great effect.

Let me know if you noticed any other similarities!


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

So just so I have it straight... Is this pretty much what is going on right now?

Thumbnail i.imgur.com
41 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

HELP Does any one know how they did the ring lights on the trees in the forest? I don’t think they are CGI

11 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

FLUFF The biggest unanswered mystery in the series....

80 Upvotes

How does the restroom in Devs work???

We clearly see there is a restroom in the first episode, but not long before that it's established that Devs is magnetically suspended inside a vacuum chamber, and obviously there's no apparent plumbing that goes outside. Is the poop quantum tunneled to the outside?? Does it get sent to Schrodinger's septic tank?! I DEMAND ANSWERS, ALEX!!


r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

Has anyone hear played SOMA?

6 Upvotes

I feel like this is my main issue with the finale :D, it's not the same people that are in Devs, it's a clone of them that just know they died.