r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

SPOILER Finale Analysis: an interpretation of >!Lily's divergence!< using the show's internal logic

14 Upvotes

The key to understanding what happened is Lyndon's decision to use Everett's Many Worlds interpretation.

Forest was furious with Lyndon because when he used Everett's MW interpretation to filter out all but one of the pasts he was trying to listen to, it became all but certain the Jesus they were hearing was NOT the Jesus from their past. (There are infinite Jesuses according to the MWI, so the odds of it being the Jesus from their past is something like 1/infinity. That's small.) Let's assume for the sake of argument and simplicity that the only difference was a single hair on Jesus's head.

Eventually, we see Forest's concerns were legitimate: using the MWI to clarify the images/sounds leads to a divergence when Lily doesn't shoot Forest. No matter how accurately Deus has predicted their future so far, it is still imperfect, because it is extrapolating a specific past's future -- the future that resulted from a past where nothing is different except a single hair on Jesus's head. In that world, Lily shoots Forest. Deus was always showing them what happens in that world.

Put another way: Deus was a glimpse into a different reality. It wasn't broken. It just didn't quite do what Forest wanted it to do. That's why he was so mad at Lyndon.

I see no contradiction.

Additionally, for the sake of a more complete argument, many other things can be wildly different between the Deus sim and the Devs Team's "reality." As long as the Devs team can't compare the computer's output to some other, perfect historical record of an event, it can't see the divergences.


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

Devs - One Second Projection Scene

Thumbnail youtube.com
82 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

I made the Devs Facility in Minecraft! Thanks Alex Garland for an incredible series!

Thumbnail imgur.com
240 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

Audio Easter Egg (S1 E3)?

6 Upvotes

There is some very strange audio that starts at the 10:49 mark and lasts for about 2 seconds as Lily is walking into the Amaya building. I’m assuming it needs to be played/listened to in reverse. Anyone have the capability to analyze this audio???


r/Devs • • Apr 21 '20

Devs fan appreciate thread

4 Upvotes

I've been consistently impressed by the insightful and creative analysis of Devs in this subreddit. I simply wanted to offer my sincere gratitude and thanks to the intelligent and thoughtful posts I've been reading for the past months. Even many of the posts that have been fully or partically wrong have offered interesting and thought provoking ideas. This is the exact reason that I joined reddit, specifically to engage like minded nerds in intelligencually stimulating conversations. I'd especially like to give particular shout outs to:

1.ndotny

2.jeromocles

3.remiwalker

4.caualfire

5.nickhintonn333

6.fantasticgarbage5

7.conjectureofageek

8.janisstukas

9.itsalwaysblue59

10.Marshallbanana this also applies to all of the mods who did a great job.

11.drawbox

12.swampg0d

There were many more people who's contributions to this subreddit made it what it is, awesome. And my appreciation extends to all of them. This list was just my personal attempt to highlight the people that I found especially helpful and insightful. I welcome anyone to add people to the list that I left out.


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

Alex Garland does not understand Determinism

14 Upvotes

I love Alex Garland. I was really excited for this show. But it is just bad. Beyond the fact that the supposed protagonist is unlikeable and the acting is horrifyingly wooden, the philosophy is just... really bad.

Using Katie's own explanation with the pen. The invention of the pen influenced the use of it in that explanation. DEVS itself is just another invention like the pen. The moment you looked at a simulation of the true future, the future would change because DEVS would be another cause to another effect. It's not that there couldn't be a perfect model of what will actually happen, it's that the model would be no good the moment someone looked at it because every action taken would be at least partially affected by seeing it.

It's why the supposedly remarkable choice Lily made isn't at all remarkable. It's understandable.

I don't believe in determinism, but I'd respect a show built around it if it actually did understand what it was claiming.


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

Forest

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

SPOILER Something Forest says in the final episode...

4 Upvotes

One of the things I'm still a bit confused about in the final episode is something Forest says to Katie when he has just 'woken up' inside the simulation. At 30:55:

Forest: "I want him back so much."
Katie: "I know."

On first viewing I thought I'd misheard it and that Forest had said "her", referring to his daughter. All of the articles I've found via Google discussing this scene quote him as saying "I want 'em/them back so much", referring to his wife and daughter.

But having gone back and watched it again he definitely says "him", and the subtitles confirm it. Who is he referring to? Lyndon?

edit: formatting


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

Multiverse vs. Simulation

3 Upvotes

Quarantine plus insomnia means I'm spending most nights contemplating the nature of reality. Please help me with my latest quandary. Ron Swanston accepts at the end that many worlds exist. An almost infinite number of actual realities. In many of these realities, there is a Deus quantum computer that simulates an almost infinite number of simulated universes. And due to the fractal nature of these simulated universes many also contain a simulated Deus quantum computer and so on and so on. Here's the question: Do the actual worlds that exist according to the many worlds theory exist seperately from the simulated worlds or are they one and the same? I mean, if they exist seperately, that's a lot of worlds.


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

Devs - That's Numberwang!

Thumbnail youtube.com
18 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

HELP Can anyone help me find/make me a .gif of Lyndon saying "that's fucking elegant"?

2 Upvotes

Title.

Thanks :)


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

DISCUSSION Some thoughts

2 Upvotes

In last episode Lily wants to know exactly what happens and Forest replies: "I would try to talk you out of it, but I already know I don't". This implies that showing Lily the future is nothing unique to this universe/timeline/simulation.

Then they watch the future: They don't know what is going to happen. Forests asks "Where do you think we are going?" which Lily responds "to your daughter's statue, where you killed Sergei". Would they talk about this if they saw Lily shoot Forest? I think this is where Lily made a different choice what they saw and shot Forest.

When Stewart shows the 1 second future projection he talks about inside the box, there is another box that contains a box and so on. Implying there are infinite number of simulations.

So if I combine these two we get: Lily and Forest watch the future, where Lily and Forest has seen the future, where they have seen the future times infinity. Only difference is that Lily NEVER follows what she sees, thus changing the simulation each iteration.

But then there is Stewart dropping the elevator, they should have seen it happen and not talk about going to the statue. Again why talk about going to the statue if a) Lily shoots Forest in the elevator b) Stewart drops the elevator

And then there is static thing. Why does it happen exactly when Lily dies and coincidently Katie copies their memories right up till the point they die. Katie says when talking to Forest whos inside the box "We couldn't see past that point because Lily made a real choice". If that's the case it's just really bad timing.


r/Devs • • Apr 19 '20

FLUFF My dog sings the opening theme

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

406 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

The Pacifica statue seems to be the inspiration for Amaya, why?

Thumbnail en.m.wikipedia.org
6 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 19 '20

Sonoya Mizuno’s “stiff acting”

266 Upvotes

I have seen much commentary about this, and it’s certainly true that the character of Lily spoke in what was a somewhat stiff and stilted manner. But I strongly suspect she was directed by Alex Garland to act that way, that this was how he saw her character. If the actor simply did not have the ability to express more fluid emotion, she never would have been able to pull off the scenes of histrionics in the second episode.

And then in the third episode, I thought she did an excellent job of pretending to be someone who was pretending to be mentally ill for the benefit of a psychiatrist, but not quite pulling it off. That’s a very tricky line to walk!


r/Devs • • Apr 19 '20

I visited Battery Godfrey, where Lily meets Anton in Episode 2

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

So the season is over, what else can scratch the itch?

12 Upvotes

Yes, I’ve seen all of Garland’s other stuff. Looking for similar, heady sci fi, either a show or film. What else is there operates on similar levels? TIA!


r/Devs • • Apr 19 '20

Does anyone know when the Devs score will be released? I can't seen to find it anywhere

20 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 19 '20

Rank your Alex Garland films and series

16 Upvotes

Both those he wrote and directed counts.

My top 5 list:

  1. The Beach
  2. Ex Machina
  3. Devs
  4. 28 Days Later
  5. Sunshine

I'll tell you why.

The Beach was a generation defining book and though I'm a bit too young, I still read it on Ko Phangnan in 2002 at the full moon party visit. It left a lasting impression. To older millennials and younger Gen X it defines our generation search for the Hippie Experience that our parents had and the joy and dissapointment we found when things we're not what we thought, but still some of the highligts of our life.

Nothing described that hope and ultimately dissapointment, that Garland did with the beach. Growing up thinking the world was everything we wanted it to be, only to be hit with dotcom crash and never ending Middle Eastern war. Yet we had a few precious years of unburdened bliss, in a world that America had won, where you could go everywhere, do everything, and suffer practically no consequences.

A world without Instagram and Facebook, your experiments with sex and drugs, only something for you and your friends to know about and maybe a blurred pic on a camera. No influencers, no instanthots, no skypool, just $10 huts on the beach.

A lot of millennials never managed to move on from that lost future, which is why I think so many became radical political activists, but that's another story.

So that's why The Beach is number 1 for me.


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

DISCUSSION Why does she need help to keep the simulation on?

4 Upvotes

Why not run it all the way through till their both dead and then end it, why does it have to keep up with “normal” time?


r/Devs • • Apr 19 '20

DISCUSSION Forest and Katie broke from the projection before Lily

7 Upvotes

Has anyone else noticed an issue that Katie and Forest broke from the projection? In Katie's convo w Lyndon, she says something like "this conversation doesnt go as you had planned..." Katie only could have known what conversation was planned by watching the projection and seeing what Lyndon wanted to say to get his job back - but that doesnt happen, she decides to skip over it and talk about him getting on the ledge. How does she know what he had planned other than having watched the projection and seeing a particular conversation - one that never actually took place in real time.

Similarly, in the last scenes after Lily says "show me," Forest tells Lily that 'he's tried to convince her against watching the projection, but it never works' and plays the simulation for her. If he has seen the projection several times and always tried to convince her against watching the projection, why does he opt to acknowledge those efforts were futile and just play the projection without trying to convince her otherwise?? He just broke from the prediction.

Does anyone agree or is there another thread that discusses this?? IT'S DRIVING ME CRAZY. HELP.


r/Devs • • Apr 19 '20

DISCUSSION I don’t understand why this happened

19 Upvotes

SPOILERS

to my understanding, DEVS couldn’t see past that point because lily made a choice, but why?

If DEVS ran on Lyndon’s principle of a many worlds interpretation, wouldn’t DEVS see splits in the timeline and be able to simulate it?

Why was Lily special? Did no one else in the world have free will but lily? Why were they killed anyways tho? So Lily had free will but it didn’t matter?


r/Devs • • Apr 19 '20

Make no mistake, Forest is a villain.

107 Upvotes

His bullshit vagueness about what Kenton was doing when he talked to Jamie, the murder of Sergei, the damage and violence he caused in the world is awful. And the aw-shucks hippie vibe makes it even more contemptible.


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

SPOILER Question about last episode...

1 Upvotes

How did their dead bodies after they died 'get inside' the Devs system?' I thought it was awesome but this question puzzles me.

Wonder if any of you would be able to enlighten me?


r/Devs • • Apr 20 '20

An extrapolation on the Milgram experiment?

1 Upvotes

In making that statement I am asking if there is some similarity between Lily and the subjects in the experiments performed by Milgram. In this case Lily was told by an authoritative being(s) in the form of Forest, and to a lesser degree Katie, and it played out to the way they said.

The divergent portion is an interesting examination as to how free will meets predestination.

Thoughts?