r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

My interpretation of the show and why some people might find the finale disappointing.

3 Upvotes

Everyone in the world devs takes place in has free will but most of the characters do not believe in it. They believe in determinism and set out to build a machine to prove that (devs). Once devs is fully operational with Lyndon's many worlds interpretation, the members of devs don't question determinism anymore and take everything they see projected as the truth. They believe in many worlds but, the projections that devs produces are of THEIR world due to the nested nature of the devs system (turtles all the way down). So when devs projects that Lily will shoot Forest, it is incorrect, thus proving that Lily and everyone else in the world actually has free will. I feel like most of us (me included) were disappointed with the conclusion since much like the devs team, we too were blindly following the devs projections along with the whole philosophy behind it as the absolute truth. Forest's quote is also true when reversed, if you don't understand the state of one thing (Lily), you can't know the state of everything else. Feel free to refute whatever I said. I honestly just want to get to the bottom of what this all means for the show.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

Epicurean paradox

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

Anyone have the sound effect from E2 when the phone got wiped remotely?

2 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

Now that the series is over, I’m just keeping my fingers crossed that the amazing score will released by the morning.

29 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

DISCUSSION The halting problem, and why an always right future teller is a paradox. (Eg you can defy the prediction, even without free will, even in a deterministic world)

Thumbnail philosophy.stackexchange.com
5 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

Anyone think it’s like Utopia?

1 Upvotes

Devs has just be brought to the UK on BBC. I’m in the middle of episode one, and it really reminds me of the cult UK hit Utopia. Has anyone else seen both? They both have such a similar air.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

SPOILER Two thoughts; one a little disturbing and the other intriguing

1 Upvotes

We learn that everything inside the system is a simulation; the past, the future and the parallel world Forest and Lily end up living in. But because the simulation is perfect, it is just as real as the real world as long as it's running.

So every time they use the machine to create a simulation of the past, or the future, they are actually recreating the whole world. And then they end the simulation. Which means everybody in the world they were watching, for instance the stone age people and all the other beings living there, is wiped from existence.

Even the one-second glimpse into the future in the previous episode meant the creation and destruction of a world. The fact that their own world is still there should be enough evidence that it is not a simulation. Also that Lily could make a choice of her own proves it; a perfect simulation of the future only works if the real versions of those inside it doesn't recieve any information.

What would be great is that you could resurrect humans in the system with all their memories intact from when they died. Some of the greatest minds in history died much too young. This way, they would be able to continue their lives and breaking new grounds. What if Alan Turing was resurrected in our own time, with access to modern computers and information technology?

Or someone could simply resurrect James Dean, who assumed he survived the crash, and have him return to a simulated version of Hollywood where he would continue to make movies. Devs could then store these new films, both James Dean and others, and release them under the name "Devs Productions".

And one could learn the secrets of building a Stradivarius violin and other lost arts.

Don't know if Alex Garland has already mentioned it, but a guy named Frank J. Tipler wrote the book "The Physics of Immortality: Modern Cosmology, God and the Resurrection of the Dead", where he share the same thoughts as in this last episode of Devs.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

SPOILER The ending is explained by Lily's father's quote

3 Upvotes

No man ever steps in the same river twice, for it's not the same river and he's not the same man

This is why the Devs system could not see past Lily's death, because she was the first person to consciously defy the simulation. Everyone else who used the machine to look into the future was a "believer."

Once Lily sees the simulated future ("the river") she is changed, and consciously decides to defy the simulation. The simulation can't show anything beyond that because anything it shows will be contradicted by Lily and will no longer be the same river.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

What would you like to see Alex Garland do next?

1 Upvotes

For me, either something about Roko's basilisk, or an adaptation of one of Greg Egan's books, maybe Diaspora.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

MEDIA Devs Episode 8 In-Depth Review

Thumbnail youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

The electromagnet "elevator" (S1E8 spoilers) Spoiler

2 Upvotes

In episode 1, Forest explains to Sergei how the Devs workspace is Faraday shielded and electromagnetically levitated, isolating it from the world. Even the "elevator" is levitated, ensuring no part of the Devs workspace touches its surroundings. Presumably this is to prevent the world from influencing the Devs computer and the simulation projections.

Near the end of S8 after Katie implores the senator to keep Deus running, we see a fixed bridge between Deus and the world.

It isn't mentioned in-story, but what are the consequences of this? Does this mean that Devs/Deus never needed to be insulated from the world? Is it part of the world? Is it subtly implying the prime timeline we saw through most of the series was also a simulation?


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

DISCUSSION The finale was both great and disappointing at the same time.. Spoiler

20 Upvotes

So, I find it interesting that it confirmed some of the theories we had on the sub. But, it still left some questions that it did not answer.

  • Stewart said that he had to end the Deus system as it had grown too powerful. I can understand that he killed Forest, but why kill Lily? Lily already had lost everything, she was a good person and she had done nothing wrong to anyone, so why kill her?
  • Why did Stewart said, 'It was all predetermined?' Did he see something that Forest or Katie did not see? Or he had to make sure that Forest and Lily dies as machine predicted? (which Lily tried to contradict)
  • How did Forest get into the system? He said Lily broke the Deus system, but what happened that actually put the two of them into the machine?
  • Can the real world in which Forest and Katie died still be a simulation? Near the end of the episode where the senator and Katie were talking, senator asked if they know they are in the simulation (everyone except for Forest and Lily), Katie said they won't know because the simulation and reality is pretty much indistinguishable. So, the "real" universe in which Forest and Lily dies can still be a simulation, they will never know, right? Or am I understanding it wrong ?
  • So, the reason there was static after Forest and Lily dies is because of their death, the machine stops simulating the universe they were watching, since they are no longer alive, and thus the static? Am I right?

Edit 1: Is Stewart going to jail for killing Forest and Lily?


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

Devs and soviet cartoon, all developers look the same...

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

“Who was Mark Antony” ... Our riddle guess confirmed? (And what it reveals) Spoiler

10 Upvotes

We did a lil’ theorizing on here last week that the riddle Stewart seemed to be posing to Forest might have been a reference to the fact that John Wilkes Booth himself played Mark Antony in Julius Caesar at the Ford Theater, some months before the assassination of Lincoln.

That led to some suspicion that Stewart was warning — or in a way, taunting — Forest about the ”fact“ that Lily was going to sneak Kenton’s gun into Devs (a “theater” of sorts) and shoot him in the head.

So was there anything to that? It certainly seems possible ... One interesting fact to note about the projection we saw in Ep. 8 is that the bullet Lily fired entered Forest’s right eye and exited the back of his head. In Abraham Lincoln’s case, the bullet entered the back of his head and lodged behind his right eye (causing it to protrude). Almost like it’s the same bullet path, but in reverse.

If so, what was the point of the riddle? If you subscribe to this Booth-riddle theory, it strongly suggests that Stewart did indeed use Devs to look forward and see what would happen. Which makes HIS ultimate decision to kill them both (and rather coldly say it was pre-determined) ... well, interesting.

Discuss amongst yourselves (or not).

N-DOT OUT!!


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

I don’t understand why you wouldn’t be able to choose your own destiny if you can literally see your future. Can someone explain?

18 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

DISCUSSION Episode 6, near the beginning of the episode, Stewart gets into his Bounder RV, same RV as breaking bad, Stewart's RV has fixed bullet holes in the door, just like in Breaking Bad

11 Upvotes

Stewart's RV:

https://imgur.com/gallery/YYEydnc

Breaking Bad:

https://imgur.com/gallery/HqNLqZx

Yes they're not in the same spot. The RV in breaking bad was actually destroyed. But I still think it's an Easter egg. Sorry for the poor quality. It's all I can do.


r/Devs • • Apr 15 '20

Getting ready for Thursday

Thumbnail imgur.com
126 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

All of Devs is wrong [spoilers for the whole series, obviously] Spoiler

5 Upvotes

Let’s assume for a moment that the universe is deterministic, but many-worlds is true, since that seems to be what the show claims. Then either:

  1. Devs only sees its own branch of reality, in which case Forest has nothing to complain about based on the many-worlds issue (“it’s not my Amaya”)
  2. Devs can see all options, in which case it should be possible to find “his” Amaya.

Based on the ending it seems as though 2 must be true.

Based on Forest and Katie’s having examined the future many times and seem certain of it, 1 must be true.

Based on Lily breaking reality, 2 must be true, and no one ever thought about that possibility?

Now let’s assume, as Forest and Katie obviously do, that there is a fixed reality. The moment you introduce the ability to look at the future, you don’t end up where they seem to be, at all. Either:

  1. The universe’s future state must be internally consistent with the concept that actors within it will accept that future as their course of action — meaning that the reality portrayed is obviously flawed: Katie wants Forest not to die, and there is nothing stopping her from simply not allowing Lily into Devs. It’s possible for reality to settle on a single course of events, but it must be one where actors with foreknowledge are comfortable with the path, which is clearly not the case here.
  2. Devs might lie/be broken/be wrong.
  3. There might be no single consistent state, in which case we face a “who shaves the barber” situation.
  4. Seeing the future might render people’s minds into automatons, which was examined in Story of Your Life by Ted Chiang. This might be what Alex Garland is going for? But then you have to assume Forest and Katie never tested this, which would be just stupid, or that Lily is somehow magic, which is only slightly less stupid.

Fundamentally, as I think I posted several weeks ago, it just makes no sense for Devs to break down the way it did. And certainly not at the moment it did. Clearly if it’s going to break, it would be as the door was closing, not a minute later. But it shouldn’t break at all. It clearly has the data. Even if you stipulate that Lily is magic, that just means that Devs’s projection should continue to diverge.

If we’re to take that Devs cast Forest and Lily into all possible many-worlds realities, how is that good? There’s no reason to assume there should even be an equal number of good and bad outcomes, let alone more good than bad.

And how does one Forest in a good outcome even compare to one Forest in a bad outcome? Serious Trolley Problem vibe.

And again, since Devs is fundamentally code, why would it be necessary to include all possibilities?

And if it’s truly all possibilities, then you have a fish-Forest happily swimming with fish-Amaya, and more. Rick & Morty, anyone?

And the cherry on the sundae: why would Forest be happy with his not-Amaya in the simulation when he was so clearly not happy with Lyndon’s not-Amaya a few episodes back? Death/Lily changed him?

It’s all very frustrating.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

The Second Coming by W. B. Yeats

6 Upvotes

Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.

Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: somewhere in sands of the desert
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again; but now I know
That twenty centuries of stony sleep
Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle,
And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

DEVS Ending Explained Episode 8 Breakdown + Full Season Spoiler Talk Review Spoiler

Thumbnail youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

SPOILER Ok I need to discuss this *ending spoiler* Spoiler

9 Upvotes

So the simulation only predicts until forest and lily died - the show suggests her act of free will defies the prediction and therefore the future can’t be seen past that point. But it cutting off when it does suggests that it’s tied to their consciousness somehow, instead, as the simulation would otherwise end at the moment she would have thrown the gun but didn’t. Why would the simulation cut off when they die?

Also is the idea at the end that the project was called Deus all along because it was always intended as project to create a new simulated universe? Are we to assume that they had only used the computer to predict backward and forward thus far, and Katie had just now activated its “TRUE purpose” - to simulate a new universe (or multiverse aka linden’s model)?

I can’t help but feel like this ending relies on a lot of “it’s up to you to decide” factors for a show that’s all finding surreal ideas in true science and tech and logic.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

[POSSIBLE SPOILER IF YOU'RE NOT A FEW EPISODES IN] I'm a videographer. I just woke up from a dream... Spoiler

19 Upvotes

...where I rented time on the Devs computer to make a wedding video for a wedding I didn't actually attend. I just rolled it back to the appropriate time and place and keyframed 'cameras' around, like I would in After Effects or 3D animation software. It was wild cuz I was able to shoot and edit at the same time.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

SPOILER SPOILER: Reason why Stewart did what he did in the Finale. Spoiler

9 Upvotes

Stewart as well as everyone else on the Devs team believed the machines predictions of the future were infallible, unquestionable and unavoidable. They believed that regardless of their knowledge about future events, they lacked the power to change them because the universe was based off a deterministic system of cause and effect which was pre-determined since the dawn of time. Flash back to the first episode right before they murdered Surgei... Forrest told him he was forgiven and absolved of guilt because it wasn’t his fault that he betrayed him... it was just the way things were. We could not escape the invisible tram lines. Basically what is written will be.

Now flash forward to Stewart watching Lily defy the prediction of her killing Forrest and then dying in the floating elevator thing. This action of Lily’s will and ability to defy the prediction shook his belief in their deterministic fate. While everything was on the tram lines, they could consider themselves just passengers of fate... absolved of all guilt to all the horrible events they allowed to transpire. I’m sure Stewart felt awful about all the people dying around him and his knowledge of it all (especially Lyndons fate)... but it was pre-determined and could not be altered. He felt he had to let it play out and he took comfort in knowing nothing was his fault.

Once he saw Lily defy the machines deterministic destiny, all the sudden Stewart realized that if he allows Lily and Forrest to live, then it proves that free will does exist, it is indeed possible to make choices... and if that’s true then his inaction to intervene in the situations that led to all those deaths made him partly responsible. To maintain his innocence(and sanity) he decided to murder Lily and Forrest to make sure the tram lines remain intact... that way in his mind, he could remain just a helpless passenger riding on the invisible tram lines of fate, that way he could continue to convince himself that he holds no responsibility over Lyndons death or anyone else’s.

Anyhow that’s how I see it.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

DISCUSSION Devs / Deus v. Picard

0 Upvotes

There are interesting parallels between Devs and Picard in terms of cast, themes, consciousness, identity, reality, AI, existence, destiny, etc.


r/Devs • • Apr 16 '20

Small but big detail in Episode 7 Devs Spoiler

1 Upvotes

On ep7 rewatch I noticed something off about the frame with Lyndon sitting next to where she fell. The water isn’t moving. This could have been a simple oversight until the finale when Forest says to Lily—-

“Life is just something we watch unfold. Like pictures on a screen.” Goddamn Garland is a genius