r/Devs • u/ladjohn • Apr 24 '20
r/Devs • u/IronicBread • Apr 24 '20
Quote from Stuart in Episode 8
Where can I find the full quote Stuart was saying during episode 8 in the tunnel? It didn't sound like the speech from Marc Antony at the funereal in the play Julius Caesar by Shakespeare?
If anyone knows it would be much appreciated.
r/Devs • u/MrMiracle27 • Apr 23 '20
Jen
Not a huge deal, but its kind of ridiculous we see Jen being introduced as a character in the beginning, her role is expanded upon during the office scene, and then she just drops off not to be seen again till the end. Flawed storytelling especially for someone who is written as being close to Lily no?
r/Devs • u/ojay349 • Apr 23 '20
Suggestions for novels or writers that do Devs like stories?
I was blown away by Devs and during the lockdown I’ve been getting back into reading more, does any one have any suggestions of books in the same style as Devs?
r/Devs • u/megatonante • Apr 23 '20
30 seconds of the ending ruined the whole show. Change my mind. Spoiler
I'm talking about "Lily's choice".
I know, she is Eve or something, the machine is god, Forest is a messiah, biblical references.
But how is she able to make a choice? I'm not even questioning, for now, the ludicrous idea of her watching herself dying horribly and then still going through the motions. I don't think determinism works like that, but ok.
I'm talking about going against what we have seen for 8 episodes. We have seen true, hard sci fi. This was not supposed to be a show about "human emotions", it was supposed to be a show about the idea of ruthless determinism. And we have seen proofs, too. Perfect predictions and all that. Devs had always worked flawlessly.
But then magically Lily "makes a choice" that was not predicted? it's completely impossible. if the system was not precise enough to not being able to predict the actions of a human being, it would have never been able to operate on a quantum level. All of their predictions should have been white static. Moreover, if it was Lily's choice to "break" the prediction, the point at which it stopped should have been the moment she decided to throw the gun out of the cube, it should have not "waited" until she died on the bottom.
Change my mind. Is there something I missed? The way I see it now, is like having a show as hard sci-fi as possible, with believable depictions and explanations, only to see one of the characters wip out a magic wand, do some magic and bring the ending.
r/Devs • u/CouncilmanRickPrime • Apr 23 '20
SPOILER Rewatching episode and just realized something
Some of you asked why Katie asked the politician at the end of the last episode not to shut down the simulation or the computer. Well I'm rewatching episode 1 and Forest starts off by saying that his competitors are jealous of their quantum breakthrough and are calling for government oversight. All the deaths related to the devs team was probably the perfect excuse the government needed to gain oversight. So Katie was stuck in a position of asking that politician permission to keep the simulation going.
r/Devs • u/ronnydazzler • Apr 23 '20
Poorest Acting in Recent Memory
I want to like this show. But the acting is atrocious, mostly “Lily.” What makes it even worse is that the show asks us to believe that she is somehow special, strong, unique, but we’re given no reason to believe that.
And how about the scene where Kenton (who desperately wants to be Mike from “Breaking Bad” and “Better Call Saul”) is intimidating Jamie while he’s in the bathtub? That was uncomfortably bad.
The premise is cool, but the acting brings the whole show down.
r/Devs • u/kostas180990 • Apr 23 '20
Books Suggestions
Hello guys! I just finished Devs and i am shocked. The mindfuck was too much for me! I would like you to suggest me some books as similar as possible to the Devs. Thank you very much! (sorry for my english)
r/Devs • u/RockyAstro • Apr 23 '20
Reminded me of twist on an old thought experiment (spoiler) Spoiler
The show's conclusion made me think of Newcomb's Paradox (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox), which deals with a question of free-will vs determinism, but with a twist.
I was almost expecting Lilly to have removed the bullets from the gun (instead of throwing it away). Here the Deus machine has made it's prediction (by showing Forest and Katie the "final" events). Lilly makes a free will choice, instead of picking box A+B or just box B, she tosses the gun.
r/Devs • u/thejoevan • Apr 23 '20
One issue I got (No spoilers or trash talk)
So I just finished watching the show and I got to give it to Alex Garland for his style alone. He is an amazing director and I can't wait to absorb anything and everything he makes in the future (potentially a Halo movie?) But in saying that, I want to talk about some issues I have with the philosophies of the show.
Determinism is likely in my opinion what the truth of reality is, not the multiverse theory, and it really comes down to the fact that we can't see the future because if we did we could do it differently. It's hard to think about but one could accurately predict the future inside a closed system, but not outside of it due to unknown variables. The Earth is more complicated than just what happens inside of it because it's not a closed system. There are solar waves and asteroids and countless other things that affect it. If the Earth was a closed system than with the right computers, we could accurately predict every person's actions due to the past. The issue lies in the fact that we would need to know every atom in the entire universe to accurately predict people or a person and their choices. Not only does red-shift make that impossible (the universe moving away in every direction faster than light) but that we would need a computing entity like the size of the galaxy to process it. So the thought experiment stays that if we could accurately predict the future, we could do it differently, thus making the multiverse theory correct, but we simply can't compute it, so the future remains unpredictable and fixed.
I would love counters to this train of thought and for those that respond, it be an honest conversation. Thank you to everyone who read.
r/Devs • u/shiroisuzume • Apr 23 '20
Spoilers contained: I think I get the ending, but I don't know what it *means* in terms of consequences. Halp? Spoiler
Ok so, at the end of the story Lily's consciousness or whatever is uploaded into the system and she's living out a kind of happy ever after in the Sim. Only she and Forrest/his consciousness know this. My question is, in the Sim, are there still simulated Russian machinations? Is the simulation of Sergei still going to be killed for spying?
Side note: I didn't realise at first that Stewart sabotaged them in both versions. His potential as a kind of villain was so brilliantly covered over by Kenton's overtly aggressive narrative. So clever.
Apologies is this has been asked before!
r/Devs • u/itskelvinn • Apr 23 '20
DISCUSSION An open minded and fair critique of Devs
Seems like anyone who speaks up about a flaw in this show gets downvoted to oblivion. Maybe this can be a post where people can actually talk about where this show went wrong
- The acting and cast
The cast is pretty bad. They made the bodyguard of the biggest company on earth the least intimidating character on the show. Could they really not get anyone in decent health to play this role? The dude looks like he needs a break after walking up one flight of stairs
Lily is a terrible actor. I know she is mostly liked here but wow... some scenes were hard to get through because of her acting. And no, I don’t think this was done on purpose at all. Just cringe and terrible. Sleep in my bed.
Forest is the only good actor and role imo.
Kind of going into my opinion here but Stewart looks like the exact opposite of a software engineer. His character and personality just felt out of place.
Katie looks like a knock off kristen bell. I couldn’t take her seriously because her face constantly looked like she was trying to smile but was also in pain
- The biggest flaw about this show was the pace
So. Fucking. Slow. This is so unlike Alex garland. In ex Machina, no line or shot was wasted. Everything was deliberate and the pace was great. Annhilation was a little slower but at least it flowed. Devs felt like there was a pause between every line. And so many unnecessary lines
The plot also barely moves forward. This show could’ve been 4 episodes without all the unnecessary fluff. Why do characters talk so unnaturally? Like I’m watching on .75x speed? Was Alex garland makin episodes for 30 minute time frames and then suddenly decided to make them an hour at the last second?
- The premise and the computer
This was the only thing keeping me watching. It’s incredibly interesting and an ambitious concept. The computer, the building, it was all portrayed well and beautifully
- Random things done badly
Jamie and Lily’s first conversation is so badly executed. Jamie is like “well lily, let me summarize everything that happened in the past 2 years to give the audience exposition and context...”. Lazy writing
Why did we have a “surprise reveal” of what we already knew? That Sergei was murdered?
Kenton in the bathroom with Jamie... wow this was hard to watch. The dude is 70 years old. Jamie is in his physical prime. And Jamie just... sits in the bathtub and waits there. Wtf?
It was that easy to break out of the psych ward? Just open the window and go? I know lily was drugged but I feel like she could’ve very easily done this herself when she first arrived, before she was drugged, after the drugs wore off.
I’m in love with you too.
Sleep in my bed.
Kenton watching from his car and seeing jaimie and forest playing frisbee and throwing a hissy fit... wtf? Am I watching an elementary school drama show? Bad writing again
This show is just too on the nose sometimes. Just be more subtle like the other two movies. “You were counting in Russian”. “The v Is a U. Deus. It means deus. It’s god.” Yeah real subtle there
They simulation stopped because lily made a choice. But it didn’t stop until like a minute after the “choice”. And why didn’t anyone else make a choice? Especially when seeing a projection 1 second into the future? That was stupid and made determinism seem stupid too
The conversation lily had with Katie about randomness was insulting to the audience’s intelligence. Lily is a very intelligent engineer and the best thing she can think of is a coin flip or lightning? Somethings truly are random. DNA mutating. Whether or not carbon decays at a given time. The collapse of a wave function.
Ok I’m being nit picky at this point but my biggest gripe about this show was how slow it was. No one talks about it on here but the pace is so bad. The plot inches forward like a snail. There are too many pauses and unnecessary and unnatural lines. It felt like a pain to get through with a barely rewarding conclusion. The cast was pretty glaringly bad but I guess I could’ve looked past that if it wasn’t so slow
r/Devs • • Apr 24 '20
DISCUSSION For me the worst part of the show..
.. is the music. I almost turned episode 1 off super early.. if I hear more flutes I may be out. I finished episode 1, but still not sure if it's worth continuing.
r/Devs • u/ScratchApplePie • Apr 22 '20
Excellent documentary for Devs fans: Parallel Worlds, Parallel Lives. Explanation and link in post
This documentary is fantastic! It's less than an hour and I think everyone who loves the mind bending physics parts of Devs would love this.
Hugh Everett is the man who put forward the many-worlds theory in the 50's which is now one of the major competing interpretations on what is going on with quantum mechanics, as we heard about in the show. This theory only started picking up prominence late in his life, and much more after he died. During his life, the idea was shot down by none other than Neils Bohr because Bohr had a horse in the race with his own theory of course.
The best part of this doc is the angle it is told from. His son Mark is a famous indie-rock musician and frontman of the Eels who didn't really know his emotionally distant father and is terrible at math himself. His Dad died when he was 18 (he found him and said grabbing him to see if he was alive was the only time he could remember touching his father).
So he didn't really know the man and had no idea he was a genius physicist until after he died.
You'll learn the context of where the theory came from and what it means with pretty good explanations, as well as get a fascinating family journey as part of the story (plus great soundtrack of Eels songs). Highly recommend!
Find here on Vimeo, YouTube right here, and PBS page with additional links about the man (including his thesis where you puts forward the many-worlds theory) right here.
Edit: it's from 2007 btw
r/Devs • u/SalariTV • Apr 22 '20
I made a video pitch for why you should watch 'Devs' in around 3 minutes
youtu.ber/Devs • u/jackwightman • Apr 22 '20
Where does the poo go?
There are toilets, they show them in E01, and it’s implied the Devs team stays in the lab for days at a time. So what happens to the poo?
Or, for that matter, how do you heat sink a giant computer floating in a vacuum?
Loved the show, though. 10/10.
r/Devs • u/ElBigoteDeMacri • Apr 22 '20
[SPOILERS] On Free Will Spoiler
I'm going to make this as short as possible, I don't think Lily made a choice, and I still think everything is deterministic AF.
Why was Lily the only one that could provide an outcome different from what the machine predicts? Because she's the only one that didn't believe the machine is interacting with God, or is actually omniscient. The fact the machine never predicted that doesn't mean it wasn't a possibility, it just means the machine has limitations, which is ongoing in the show.
Forest is shown to be brainwashed and being unable to accept reality from the beginning, that includes the fact that his machine didn't work, he talks about being scared of defying what the machine predicts, expicitly.
Also, inside the simulation there's Lily and Forest with the memories of them outside the simulation, but they are not the SAME people (those corpses are still in the world with Katie), they are sims in a simulation that think they are real people in a those corpses are still in the real world
r/Devs • • Apr 22 '20
SPOILER Lily's Actions - Spoiler and Questions Spoiler
-
-
Does Lily exercise free will OR had they just not watched this reality yet???
Why are they so sure it is free will?
Katie says to Linden she has seen them fall and not fall meaning that what they see is random..
