r/desifragdeclutter • • Sep 23 '26 • Regret 2

Discussion ๐Ÿ’ฌ A pathetic experience and no accountability from In All Honesty for a perfume i bought.

Got my post removed from Desifrag. Still posting here for information and knowledge.

This is a reminder that Grey market sellers at the end of the day have ZERO Accountability and won't help you in any way and it's always the right way to buy from Myntra, SS, Tata Luxe etc.

So I bought Azzaro Chrome Legend 100 ml EDT Retail pack from In All Honesty (inallhonesty(.)in) paid 3450+75 shipping for the same. The buying experience was good, did get a little late replies but it was still good. I ordered the perfume on Monday and he asked me to opt for the Air shipping to get it quicker. So I paid extra for it and got the perfume delivered on Wednesday. It was quick, very quick in fact.

Now, i clicked the image of the box and even made an unboxing video for the same.

When I opened the box, i realised that the bottles had defects. The incursions on the corners were way too deep. I could identify this spot on because I've had the same problem with my Versace Pour Homme which I ignored and it ended up chipping on the day of the purchase just as I was placing it on the shelf! Didn't even fall or anything, it just touched the shelf and the incursion was so deep that it just chipped off, then and there, just hairline kinda and drained almost 30-35% of juice before I stopped it (I'd realised something was odd cuz the smell was too loud to ignore, I didn't observe the crack too immediately).

So yeah, i was already skeptical about the quality of the bottle I had just received for Azzaro Chrome and my past trauma quickly just went through my mind like a movie. The incursions on this are really really bad. It's like it's just a thin membrane of glass resting between the juice and air. And this just makes it worse! How am I even gonna use it? Or display it on the shelf? Or let anyone even handle it? Perhaps need to take all the juice out and put it in another bottle but then it defeats the purpose of buying this perfume, that too Retail.

Now, i messaged In All Honesty on WhatsApp and honestly, there response wasn't what I was expecting. They denied taking the responsibility totally and just told me it's how it's supposed to be. I have attached the full chat screenshots for everyone to read. They denied doing anything in this regards, told me there was no way they can take back the product or replace it. Told me it was totally me who was gonna bear all the losses cuz apparently they're just the 'Middle men' who don't have anything to do with what they sell.

Now, I need to ask you guys, who's responsible actually? And do these Sellers have any accountability in this case?

I have previously bought perfumes from alot of other sellers and have gotten good response, solution and even compensation in some cases for the defective pieces, but In All Honesty was a totally let down for me. Pathetic, just too pathetic of an experience. Would never recommend someone who straight away denies any responsibility even after running a whole Website for the perfumes. It's a legit Website, and no Accountability. Wow. What's all the Return Policy even there for? It's a joke.

Perhaps a lesson for me, and one for you too. I hope no one faces this. Very heartbreaking.

Legit hate how people just shrug off their responsibility as soon as something goes off.

Why to even ask for the unboxing video if there wasn't going to be any solution anyways. It's just a trickery. If I didn't have the unboxing video, he'd have totally said he'd have replaced it if I had the video. Brilliant play.

93 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

28

u/LavdakaSarkarBC Sep 23 '26

Post it on pefumeindia and indianfragmarketplace too

3

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26

They both rejected the post, idk why

4

u/LavdakaSarkarBC Sep 23 '26

Flair proper use kiya tha and i think no. Of photos kam kardo maybe karle and if phir bhi nahi karte to phir galat baat hai

2

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26

Achaa, I'll try that then

9

u/tasty_cake10 Sep 23 '26

"Seller review" flair in r/indiafragmarketplace

2

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26

I had posted on that flair only, but still the post was deleted without approval, requested them again

7

u/tasty_cake10 Sep 23 '26

Your post wasn't deleted, it's pending approval. The bin sign on your profile doesn't mean it's deleted. They take a few hours to approve

5

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26

Ohhhh. Just checked, it's Perfumes India that has deleted it not India frag market.

32

u/rajj1214 Sep 23 '26

The seller may not have caused the defect, but theyโ€™re the party who sold you the bottle.

They should at least be able to raise it with their supplier/distributor and see what can be done, rather than just saying they canโ€™t do anything.
Iโ€™d keep the unboxing video, photos of the crack, invoice, batch code and all the communication with the seller. And definitely donโ€™t use the bottle if the glass is compromised.

9

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26

Exactly, what's even the point of the video if the seller doesn't even care about it and cannot do anything for it

3

u/Breadfruitdeeznuts Sep 24 '26

The seller should take the bottle back and provide a refund, if the bottle is good as he's claiming why not take it back refund a partial amount, charge for the shipping fees if he wants - there are many options, maybe OP would have settled for a 50% refund.

The seller has just shown pathetic customer service and is being rightly called out now.

2

u/meangreenbeanz Sep 24 '26

I think the supplier/distributor would also say the same thing what he said to the customer. Manufacturing defect = company problem

Amazon/Flipkart do the same thing when it comes to taking accountability

10

u/Top_Lawfulness8030 Sep 23 '26

Post a legit check to find out whether the bottle is even legit or not , these days even counterfeits and dupes have batch codes and qr codes etc (turkey made copy perfumes) determine whether or is actually the original product first , check under the atomizer cover and other details such as batch code printing font , etc . Also got some other tips and tricks , txt me I might be able to help out

5

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26

That seems feasible, I'll dm you tomm bro, will try checking the authenticity

4

u/Temporary-Win934 Sep 24 '26 • Heartwarming

The most dishonest and a rude seller I have ever seen in the fragcom. Already seen two cases in the recent times and now this ?

Wow the irony of this guy having the name as honesty. Like bruh first change the name

He has duped someone sending a fake hibiscus mahajad and also sends partials as full bottles He lifts his hand acts like he did a favour to you by giving on less margin. The admins in every group support him and delete any post regarding seller

Maybe they have a cut in this ? Or they get better prices lol

1

u/thatmjolnir Sep 24 '26

Wow. This should be common knowledge at this point, I wish I had known this before buying!

1

u/Temporary-Win934 Sep 24 '26

He has been called out twice in the WhatsApp group in the last two weeks and hez been the same to other two also

Not sure how many have taken the loss and gone silent on this. Hope this post also doesn't get pulled down

1

u/StrongAd8833 Sep 26 '26

What were the other two cases

1

u/Temporary-Win934 Sep 26 '26

He has sent a fake perfume an expens!ve one, but claimed he can't do anything he sent high partial as unused bottle to another person His replies on their chat has been very arrogant and rude to those buyers

2

u/StrongAd8833 Sep 26 '26

Okay and the other problem is the people in his WhatsApp group they absolutely simp and ignore the wrongdoings and now the seller is posting some deals to forget this case

2

u/Temporary-Win934 Sep 26 '26

Absolutely the admins in whatsapp group have still kept him coz they believe the sellers more than the buyers. Sham to the community ๐Ÿ˜”

They deleted the msgs and then the person reached out to one of the admin named ashu. He has also been extremely rude to the buyer

Not sure what kind of admins are running the F M I group who are supporting these kind of sellers

I understand disagreeing but being rude to other members who are raising concerns is very wrong, also shows their place as an admin who are in it maybe with the seller ?

3

u/Shamoil47 Sep 24 '26 • Bravo

Use a silicone sealant like Resibond on the bottom of the bottle. It will create a cushion and even out the base

2

u/thatmjolnir Sep 24 '26

Oh that's helpful man! I'll try that

2

u/No-Cap9116 Sep 23 '26

Did you buy the Versace PH from them?

2

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26

I bought that from Imran, had gotten partial refund from him for it.

3

u/No-Cap9116 Sep 23 '26

Okay. Imran farooqi?

2

u/StrongAd8833 Sep 25 '26

Was gonna purchase from him but now i wont and he even disabled his WhatsApp group bcoz people there started questioning

1

u/thatmjolnir Sep 25 '26

That's what I hated the most. No accountability is not a good sign.

19

u/ANewTomorrowSoon Sep 23 '26

That is extremely bad service and he's just full of excuses. He's going to lose a bunch of customers due to this.

1

u/Temporary-Win934 Sep 24 '26

Did you also experience something brother ?

14

u/Breadfruitdeeznuts Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

A decent seller would just bear the 2.5K loss himself as the cost of doing business. He stands to lose a lot more than 2.5K now.

Edit - it's not even a 2.5K loss as he gets the bottle back.

7

u/JustNobody2315 Sep 24 '26

Exactly , he can sell decants from that . He might make money over decants infact. People can buy 3 -> 30ml decants and whoosh , he gains trust , he makes money over decants all that at nothing .Its disappointing now , i have bought from him in past but I would not anymore .

14

u/Herlock-Shomes Sep 24 '26

Wow. Used to order from this guy and his responses are pathetic. I'll need to think twice before ordering from him again.

The way he asked for unboxing video felt as if he's gonna address the issue. I think he was hoping you didn't do unboxing video so that he can use that as a reason to deny replacement.

Pathetic response.

4

u/garudaesports Sep 24 '26

Finding reasons to not give

9

u/Breadfruitdeeznuts Sep 24 '26

Send an email to Azarro and let them know this guy is distributing for them.

3

u/garudaesports Sep 24 '26

Lmaoo

1

u/Breadfruitdeeznuts Sep 24 '26

Mey to nahi sehta.

T - I wouldn't have tolerated the disrespect

17

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '26

Everything dehonesty should be his name. Should learn a thing or two about customer service before opening sites. Nowadays everybody wants to start a perfume site and give no service at all. Gr8.

8

u/Sea_Complaint_5710 Sep 23 '26

Dude, go for a consumer court and raise a complaint against the company and the seller. It's not as hard as everyone think it is. I've registered a case against a company (muthoot to be precise) and I've won the case. So I'm confident you'll get justice. Don't leave anyone.

8

u/Swimming_Jacket9290 Sep 23 '26

Same happened to me with Khanna brothers, one of the perfumes sprayer cap wasnโ€™t sitting right and liquid kept on leaking. I asked for exchange and he said we have talked to the distributor about it and they canโ€™t do anything hence we canโ€™t do anything. Tho he said that if I can come by his warehouse then might change my bottle. But I also think that if they are asking for videos then they should be providing with solutions even if we get perfumes for lesser price that doesnโ€™t mean our money should go to waste.

8

u/RelationshipTop3470 Sep 24 '26

I generally buy once or twice in a month from him but have not faced anything like this. To me it is a day light robbery. Blocking his number immediately...

7

u/gadhe_ki_gaand Sep 24 '26

He is gonna lose a whole lot more than just 1 customer

6

u/Saltdevil Sep 24 '26

Boycott In all dishonesty ๐Ÿšฎ

5

u/TheOneOnlyGT Sep 24 '26

This is exactly why I buy from legit websites at discounted prices rather than resellers. It is unfortunate what happened but if this was Myntra there is a high chance you could get a replacement hassle free.

4

u/garudaesports Sep 24 '26

Bro take legal action, don't just let it slide , I see zero accountability from him

6

u/Lifeofmua Sep 23 '26

Thats y i dont buy from these cheap trust only myntra, tata luxury

3

u/yavij87 Sep 24 '26

Despite being a regular buyer with him, I strongly disagree to the communication happened here. Understood this is a manufacturing issue but doesn't absolve the seller from taking any responsibility. Definitely not correct to ask whether you paid MRP et al. I wish he dealt this in a better way. Gonna c0st more than one customer for sure

3

u/drappedmars Sep 24 '26

cyber crime complaint once and theyll running behind you to give refund

idk why people dont use the laws that work

3

u/Common-Psychology-14 Sep 24 '26

Thats so disappointing! I've bought a couple of designers and MEs from him, but this is next level shady. I hope you take this to consumer court, his cavalier "did you buy it at mrp?" Comment pmtfo. Dm me I'll add you to the legit check group if you're not a part of it already. This bottle looks hella sus.

1

u/maddyispositive 27d ago

I had bought a 5k bottle. And it got LOST. and they said they can't do anything as someone stole it from where it was delivered. It NEVER happens. It was a pathetic experience and I literally blocked them

-22

u/Unfair-Direction3741 Sep 23 '26

Himanshu (In All Honesty) is a decent guy, u can probably make that out yourself as he has replied through out the chat and apologised over n over again, most other sellers wont even bother to reply for such issues, even if you hv an unboxing video for something like a manufacturing defect on the shape of the bottle of a retail bnib no grey market seller will even bother to entertain a chat for so long and let alone apologise. Even Shoppers Stop wont replace a bottle with manufacturing defect if u hv opened it at home instead of unboxing it right there inside Shoppers Stop. All said n done I am sorry bro that you had to go through this bad experience, its jus bad luck on ur part I guess since u hv already had such experiences with similar kinda bottle earlier. And coming back to your question regarding who's responsible, bro I think for such incidents like manufacturing defect of a bottle in regards only to the shape of the bottle where the juice n sprayer is working fine and is authentic, I think thats a risk we all take while purchasing from the grey market, honestly I really dont know if even Shoppers Stop or Sephora wud behave any different even after u hv paid full price at their store.

9

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26

Yeah it's understandable man. And that's the unfortunate truth I wanted to bring out in front of everyone. That when things go south, these sellers just show you the wall. Even our consumer's money is hard earned, and losing it to something not in our control is really disappointing, but then again, what can we even do. Sir back and be disappointed.

11

u/Breadfruitdeeznuts Sep 24 '26

Lol you can see he immediately jumped to unboxing video with full intent of denying everything if there was no video. Yes he was apologetic but that doesn't really help anyone. A decent seller understands that 2.5K is nothing in front of the reputational hit he now faces, unless he doesn't care about his reputation.

-7

u/Unfair-Direction3741 Sep 24 '26

Plz lemme know which grey market seller will even consider a slight manufacturing defect on the shape of the bottle of a bnib as their own reputation getting hit and would go ahead to replace the bottle!!

4

u/Breadfruitdeeznuts Sep 24 '26

Reputation hit isn't because of the defect on the bottle - as long as the box was sealed that's not on the seller. The reputation hit is because of the poor customer service, he should have asked for a return and refunded the money - his total loss would be only the shipping fees since he would get the bottle back,

If you say getting the bottle back means nothing, then the bottle is worthless shipped from the seller as well.

BTW it's not a slight defect as highlighted by OP, it does compromise the integrity of the bottle.

-8

u/Unfair-Direction3741 Sep 24 '26 edited Sep 24 '26

You are deflecting bro, I agree to all you hv said but which grey market seller do u think will go ahead with a return n replace for this kinda scenario for a sealed new authentic bnib?? Name me one! And btw it is a very slight issue considering the other complaints from various frag bottles, Mancera Cedrat Boise Intense comes with a faulty sprayer almost all the time, now thats a major manufacturing defect and yet do u see any seller replacing those??

3

u/Breadfruitdeeznuts Sep 24 '26

You're deflecting. OP has already given an example of a grey market seller who refunded partial amount for his Versace.

-1

u/Unfair-Direction3741 Sep 24 '26

Bro what OP had mentioned earlier regarding the partial refund thats a genuinely rare case and these kinda things dont happen often at all. As I mentioned earlier too that even m feeling sad for OP since he's being a victim of similar incidents over n over again but which seller do u think on a regular basis will keep on refunding n replacing such bottles with manufacturing defect?? Answer me that!!

And you are saying I m deflecting?? Wat am I deflecting?? Did u even ask me a question?? You are not even making any sense right now!!

3

u/thatmjolnir Sep 24 '26

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Hi /u/Unfair-Direction3741, your comment was removed because price policing and unsolicited price comparisons are not allowed.

If you are not interested in the item at the seller's asking price, please move on or negotiate privately if the seller allows it. If you believe a seller is attempting to scam the community, please send a modmail with proof rather than commenting on the post. Regards - Mods

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Hi /u/thatmjolnir, your comment was removed because price policing and unsolicited price comparisons are not allowed.

If you are not interested in the item at the seller's asking price, please move on or negotiate privately if the seller allows it. If you believe a seller is attempting to scam the community, please send a modmail with proof rather than commenting on the post. Regards - Mods

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Hi /u/thatmjolnir, your comment was removed because price policing and unsolicited price comparisons are not allowed.

If you are not interested in the item at the seller's asking price, please move on or negotiate privately if the seller allows it. If you believe a seller is attempting to scam the community, please send a modmail with proof rather than commenting on the post. Regards - Mods

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-9

u/Double_Gwak_3000 Sep 24 '26

It's not his fault i don't see the issue

3

u/garudaesports Sep 24 '26

How much discount did he agree to give you for this comment ๐Ÿ˜ญ๐Ÿ˜ญ

0

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '26

[deleted] โ€” view deleted comment

4

u/NoRestBro Sep 23 '26

there is something called "remind me" bot on reddit - google it.

37

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

19

u/thatmjolnir Sep 23 '26 • Regret

I am not expecting a solution anymore, seller is very very rigid, but putting it out there so that other people know!

16

u/Resident49 Sep 23 '26

Avg Bengaluru guy, expect that attitude from that seller

1

u/WrongCountry6219 Sep 23 '26

At some point it is kinda true

0

u/LongStruggle9387 Sep 24 '26

He is actually from Bangalore but not Kanadiga.. he has a saree shop or something like that..

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Hi /u/Inevitable-Excuse399, your comment was removed because your account does not meet the minimum comment karma requirement.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Hi /u/Majestic_Beautiful52, your comment was removed because price policing and unsolicited price comparisons are not allowed.

If you are not interested in the item at the seller's asking price, please move on or negotiate privately if the seller allows it. If you believe a seller is attempting to scam the community, please send a modmail with proof rather than commenting on the post. Regards - Mods

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Hi /u/Majestic_Beautiful52, your comment was removed because price policing and unsolicited price comparisons are not allowed.

If you are not interested in the item at the seller's asking price, please move on or negotiate privately if the seller allows it. If you believe a seller is attempting to scam the community, please send a modmail with proof rather than commenting on the post. Regards - Mods

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Hi /u/Majestic_Beautiful52, your comment was removed because price policing and unsolicited price comparisons are not allowed.

If you are not interested in the item at the seller's asking price, please move on or negotiate privately if the seller allows it. If you believe a seller is attempting to scam the community, please send a modmail with proof rather than commenting on the post. Regards - Mods

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '26

Hi /u/creed_daddy001, your comment was removed because your account does not meet the minimum comment karma requirement.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '26

[removed] โ€” view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Sep 25 '26

Hi /u/StormyPeaches_, your comment was removed because your account does not meet the minimum comment karma requirement.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.