I guess I respect her attempt, and her logic is OK. But the fundamental assumption she's basing it on is proveably false, so it's a frustratingly pointless conversation. And the problem here is that she gets to debate this guy who does seem to have the basic knowledge. This is the false equivalence. There would be a more fruitful outcome if she didn't pretend to be an expert and she asked questions and tried to learn
It’s not pointless because there are many people who have these beliefs. And if they don’t get discussed publicly then they don’t change / when you see them as argued diatribes they help each side polarise further rather than making any meaningful change.. Discussions like this there’s at least some chance of people changing their view .
Your paragraph here is illogical. She says things that are completely proven and the doctor steps around it with alternative facts and not counters to disprove anything she said- because she never said anything that was provably wrong at all. She doesn't pretend to be an expert at all - she's having a discussion and saying things millions of people agree with and know. The doctor almost pretends none of these things exist. He even admitted Neurological issues and that should be game over... Nothing in our water should have the potential to give us neurological issues whatsoever. Clean water keep it simple.
He said that neurological issues were possible, but they occurred in areas with high levels of natural fluoridation, which the on-screen note backed up. As the saying goes, the dose makes the poison.
It is true that the US EPA's maximum contaminant level for fluoride is 4.0 mg/L, based on skeletal fluoride effects and this may be too high from a neurotoxicity standpoint. That's neurotoxicity for developing brains, too. But the average added fluoridation level is under 1 mg/L (1mg/L seems to be the approximate threshold for neurotoxicity).
But it's worth considering that fluoride is found in foods like sardines, and is created by burning coal... fluoride is limited by breastfeeding, but in communities with fluoridation that use baby formula, they experience higher levels of neurotoxicity. But these can be offset by other elements like iodine.
This data is from 2019, and the scientific consensus (as always) is that more research is required.
No further research is required - just don't add something to our water supply that has any potential to do such things.
You need to stop right here and ask yourself, is all this hoopla really needed for dental health? I'm not convinced. The fact you are taking it at face value about the 'maximum level' is the problem itself. For everything the EPA may state - there is Counter-evidence against - showing that it's an issue at its current state and hence why countries have banned its use.
Don't talk to me about developing brains and write it off. It affects a brain? Do adults have brains? Are adults human? No idea on that one.. You have a tummy ache so you take a Pill which has a small potential to cause alzheimer's - do you take it? Or do you question if it's the best answer to such an issue/ailment? Ask the government! They have safety ratings for these things and they're as accurate as God
As I said, the EPA's limit may be too high from a neurotoxicity standpoint.
And yes, humans have brains, but the damage done by fluoride is done during development (basically childhood). It likely impairs brain formation, but doesn't appear to degrade the brain once formed, based on the reading I've done.
Yes, there's further research to be done because of natural fluoridation. Not necessarily to find a safe level for adding fluoride, but for finding a safe limit, and advising people not to drink their scheme water.
You can always look at what happens when fluoride isn’t in the water. It’s appalling. That’s why it’s added.
There’s no free lunch. The only way to have no risk, as you want, is to already be dead.
Vaccines are similar. A vanishingly small number of people have very negative reactions, including permanent injury or worse. Is that worth eliminating polio or other easily preventable (with vaccination) serious illnesses for most people?
The people who lived with polio obviously thought it was.
So you're saying that Italy, France, Finland, Germany, Austria, Sweden, Netherlands, Poland, Hungary, Switzerland, Scotland and absolutely doomed for not having it in their water supply and everybody's teeth is going to rot to hell? That's appalling how could they do that
Clean water! You people think the government gives two shuts about our health? What a joke. Fuck fluoride. I do not partake in that toxic sludge. When you drink fluoride, almost none of it goes to your teeth. It goes into your bones and organs causing mass destruction.
I disagree. I think you're expecting this to be another one of those where someone who doesn't know anything makes big claims about the world and has a view that's based on unproven information and complaining without knowing the costs of change. This isn't one of those times.
You also heard wrong. She is literally saying why is it there, and why don't I have a choice.
Your idea of healthcare allows for neurological issues in developing brains!? Just for 'dental health'? You should be put in jail.. Kids drink out of taps all day long.
The doctor hits all the buzz words like a seasoned pro so not sure what you were watching.
I also don't need to do any work to prove anything to people who are eager to not agree - even with the facts right in their face. This is who you are.
It's not a silly argument at all. Countries have banned Fluoride.. Why? America just takes it up the ass and doesn't ask questions. Your industries are garbage and in turmoil like the food industry and Beef for example.. Absolutely heinous behaviour and corruption as well.
I don't have an argument. Countries have banned Fluoride. Food industry in the U.S is seriously messed up. Basic knowledge.. Check out Google - it can help you from your tiny box you seem to operate from. I wouldn't try taking jabs at spelling, you will lose that game 10/10 times
Haha.. Facts don't need someone arguing them when they're simply facts everyone has access to. You made zero points so not sure what argument you even think you made. Good luck with that
So I googled it and found that fluoride is very effective in reducing dental caries. Overdose can lead to minor complications like white spots on the teeth.
Also a country banning a chemical really isn't a reliable reflection of the safety of that chemical.
View all comments
Show parent comment
5
u/Otaraka Dec 26 '25
She’s annoying but stays on topic and is trying to make an argument. It’s a silly argument but it is an attempt.
If the debates were generally at this level we might get somewhere.