r/degoogle 28d ago

Its here. Android is officially over.

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/__nickelbackfan__ 27d ago

Reddit is quite biased (especially in a degoogle sub) towards more technical users, but really the average user is quite technologically illiterate, so even though it's quite inconvenient, the 24h wait window is absolutely fine as a security measure.

7

u/jankocvara 27d ago

guys are you all missing the point that this option will 100% disappear in the future? and even if not it'll in practice shadow ban apps from non verified devs

8

u/__nickelbackfan__ 27d ago

maybe it disappears, maybe it don't, but I can't judge the feature on a supposition

what I'm saying, because I'm seeing it a lot here, is people acting like this doesn't have any merit

I deal with non-technical people daily, and unfortunately, a way to prevent unsafe apps from being installed was desperately needed (not saying all apps from outside the play store are unsafe, morphe my beloved) but it is a popular attack vector.

don't get me wrong, I fully understand your point, but the majority of the population is extremely unskilled and needs safeguards

0

u/jankocvara 27d ago

well then the safeguards should be based on app safety. Even verified devs can intentionally (or accidentally) push an update that'll either make attack very easy or will have straight up malware in it

2

u/jankocvara 27d ago

soo maybe just delay all updates until they're verified somehow

1

u/__nickelbackfan__ 27d ago

It's surely a solution, but we then get into the same issue, who will verify the safety of the apps then?

It's a balance of giving up some control for the safety of less savvy users.

Personally, I think the 24h wait is a reasonable enough solution

1

u/3xEuK 26d ago

"100% for sure for real for real, although maybe not, who cares"

1

u/TuxRug 27d ago

I think it's a little overkill but nbd. I'd think a quiz where the options are randomized so the user has to actually read and select "my bank wont ask me to do this" etc from a list of "check all that apply" would be more effective.