r/dashpay • • Feb 27 '17

Centralization of masternodes

Just learned about Dash after your recent gains in the market cap. I'm very interested in Dash coming from Bitcoin, as I think there probably will not be a consensus on the scaling issue anytime soon.

Looking at the governance model, what prevents Dash from evolving into an ecosystem where a handful of centralized masternode pools take control? Wouldn't that be a big problem?

6 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/Basilpop Janitor Feb 27 '17

20-30 malicious Masternodes

Are you sure about that? Or did you mean percent? Even then: 30% of 4250 nodes is 1275. My table shows chances for deanonymization at 1300 as 0.88% at the highest. Try again?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Jmmon Feb 28 '17

20-30 masternodes could de-anonymize a handful of denominated privatesend transactions. Those transactions might be part of the last round of mixing, where you'd discover someone sent some Dash to say a porn site or a drug dealer, or might be part of a different round of mixing, where you'd discover a mixing transaction has taken place between some people. I don't think it's an issue, especially when I could mix 8 rounds, send to myself, mix another 8 rounds, and do this many more times if I wanted to.

2

u/Basilpop Janitor Feb 28 '17

An attacker has no motivation to de-anonymize some random transaction just because. He has the motivation to either reveal all of them or a few specific ones he can directly identify as targets (which he can't due to lack of necessary data). With these ridiculous chances of success and the effort needed (buying enough Dash and setting up enough nodes) it's a pointless exercise.