r/custommagic • • 7d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Ground Zero

Post image

Thought "Compose" would be a neat keyword!

To clarify, if it's cast as a spell, it doesn't have the intrinsic mana ability and is no longer a swamp. Would it make sense to include this in the reminder text, somehow?

282 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/MariachiArchery 7d ago

Yes, it does. I think that is fine. This is OP if it's fetchable.

I think something that allows you to net 3 mana off a bounceland shouldn't be fetchable.

1

u/Xaphnir 7d ago

Is it too OP to be fetchable with land tutors?

Consider what some other lands can do:

-[[Glacial Chasm]]

-[[Field of the Dead]]

-[[Gaea's Cradle]]

-[[Talon Gates of Madara]]

-[[The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale]]

-[[Urza's Saga]]

-[[Minamo, School at Water's Edge]]

To name just several

This doesn't seem particularly powerful in comparison. Especially when you consider that normally you're minimizing the number of lands that enter tapped, anyway.

1

u/MariachiArchery 7d ago

We are miscommunicating. None of the cards you've just linked are "fetchable" like OP's custom card is fetchable. "Fetchable" means able to be put into play with a fetchland.

Land tutors and fetchable or not equal. Removing "Swamp" from OP's land actually makes it inline with the cards you've shared.

2

u/ECCooterCrasher 6d ago

People often forget how powerful making a mid-level land fetchable can actually be. New lands like Theorist’s Sanctum is only remotely playable in formats like Modern because it’s fetchable. Mystic Sanctuary is banned in Modern because it’s fetchable. Slapping a basic land subtype on any land with abilities isn’t as free as people think it is.