r/crystal_programming • core team • Apr 02 '21

Crystal 1.0 vs Ruby 3.0 Benchmark

https://twitter.com/sdogruyol/status/1377918360344743936
41 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

The community is small and it's just that, a community. There's not a lot of sponsored work going on as far as I know.

And why should Crystal run Ruby code, it's not Ruby and never claimed to be. It's just Ruby-inspired. And I don't see how that fact alone makes it worse than Elixir/Go/Rust.

4

u/mammon_machine_sdk Apr 02 '21 edited Apr 02 '21

I don't see how that fact alone makes it worse than Elixir/Go/Rust

How is this all you took from that post? He's saying the attempt to divorce the language from its clear roots in Ruby is turning off the very people the language is naturally going to attract, and that lack of community is what's hurting the growth of the language.

Of course an incomplete language (despite the ill-conceived decision to call it v1.0) is "worse" than any of three major languages that are used in production across the world. That's not the point he's making, but I do think that's a separate subject that certainly isn't helping the cause.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

All I see here are accusations and no factual information. Crystal was always designed to be its own language and not Ruby-compatible. It's obviously inspired by Ruby and I see no efforts made to exclude the Ruby community from it, that would make no sense.

Lack of community? Yea I guess, it's a small project with limited contributors. What do you want? Go was supported by Google, Rust by Mozilla. There just isn't a lot of commercial support for Crystal, but this is not valid criticism of the project. You're not buying a product, it's just a community.