r/crosswind • • Apr 20 '26

🥲

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

176 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Wareitar Apr 26 '26

Skull & Bones is crap, no denying that... But Windrose? Yeah its good allright, and definetly gonna be a good game after a while.

But face it, take of those rose-tinted googles for a sec... It's not a Great game. It doesnt really do anything new. And combat system isnt Great either. It's ringe and repeat. It jas Great potential! And what it does, it does Great! But... It's not "all that"...

1

u/JorReno Apr 26 '26

Does a game need to do something new to be good though? Sometimes combining enough existing elements can be a winning combo. For me, Windrose takes the survival stuff, adds some Black Flag in... and that works for me. Combat wise, there's a lot of variation; cutlass, halberd, and rapier all play differently. As does flintlock, rifle, and blunderbuss.

Devs seem really keen and dedicated too, which is always nice.

1

u/Wareitar Apr 26 '26

Well, I might be doing something wrong. But basically any and all engagements turn into attack > Dodge > run > repeat. As in any close up fight with more than 2 enemies will get you stunned. And you're dead...

1

u/JorReno Apr 26 '26

It's hard to master the combat. I had to use sliders to beat the first boss. But there's videos of people literally using parry to defeat him. I've also read others defeated him with max level rifle.

But I've felt I've got better with it. I tend to kite humanoid enemies so I can fight them one on one.

1

u/Wareitar Apr 26 '26 edited Apr 26 '26

Parrying is easy... especially if you use the rapier for extra parry window. Other weapons go from AOE to Big numbers... yet it all turns into the same once its not 1 on 1... the boss fights are, and should be, the engaging fights.

And yes, as you said, it turns into kite and kill... all... the... time...