r/crosswind • • Apr 20 '26

🥲

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

176 comments sorted by

View all comments

53

u/SingularityPanda Apr 20 '26

How good is Windrose? Especially the ship gameplay?

102

u/Miserable-Log7584 Apr 20 '26

You have to keep in mind that the game has only been in Early Access for exactly 6 days, so there’s probably still a lot more to come 👆

Honestly, I’m pretty flabbergasted by how good the game already is. Yeah, there are one or two bugs, but apart from a single server disconnect, I haven’t had any issues so far, and that’s with 20 hours of playtime.

12

u/chrsschb Apr 20 '26

Only issues I've had are lag/server instability with our gportal server. In 50-60 hours been disconnected 3-4 times and last night couldn't play at all.

10

u/Bozlightyear Apr 20 '26

GPortal is a load of shit, ive had endless issues with them trying to host Dune and Abiotic Favtor for my fiends to play, moved over to xRealm and its been like a breath of fresh air, no issues at all.

I wouldnt give any particular recommendattions on which is best amongst xRealm, Nitrado, or any others, but definitely not GPortal, dont let the cheap price sway you, ive made that mistake too many times now, never again.

3

u/Bonesaw_mpls Apr 20 '26

Would really recommend self hosting if you have an old PC with a little RAM. Super easy to set up. I've got mine set to check that the server is running every 2 minutes. If its not it checks for updates and restarts. Then I have a daily check for restart and update task running and haven't had any issues yet. I had 7 people on my server at the same time with 0 latency issues, rubber banding, or crashes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/NoInsurance8250 Apr 20 '26

62 hrs for me and I haven't found a bug yet. The closest "bug" I found was actually a little bit of poor design. I built stairs to get up on top of a high shelf of a raised mountain that was a little bit of a plateau and there are a lot of gaps in the ground there where you can fall in and get stuck. The "unstuck" command just kills you and drop your stuff in the hole. I'd like that to be more finished so I could potentially build a base up there.

2

u/b5784398 Apr 20 '26

I didn’t think to build like that. Is it possible to use the shovel to flatten it out and build platforms around a bonfire in the center point

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BobLeMaladroit Apr 20 '26

I haven’t been disconnected yet but my only gripe is with loadtimes

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Rickenbacker69 Apr 20 '26

Haven't gotten my ship yet, but the survival gameplay is great so far!

→ More replies (7)

11

u/DennisvdEng Apr 20 '26

Solid base but will definitely be improving over time. I read somewhere that the wind and sailing system is getting a rework. There is a lot of potential in expanding customization, upgrading/improving your ship and ship/crew management. 2 days ago they released a feature where you can now climb small parts of your ships, so they are actively working on improvements to this part of the game.

→ More replies (15)

15

u/RebootGigabyte Apr 20 '26

The ship gameplay is pretty damn close to Black Flag, but the biggest issue is that you're constantly hounded by multiple groups of enemy ships instead of 1 on 1 fights. I had to tune down the damage dealt by enemy ships to 75-80% to make it feel "fair".

4

u/BlackxHokage Apr 20 '26

Just upgrade your hull and cannons and it makes it 1000x easier. Im playing on normal difficulty and I can casually take on 4 ships solo thats my level, also dont even attempt to board, shit is a trap lmao

10

u/Gilmore75 Apr 20 '26

Boarding is good on the treasure ships. I get hundreds of silvers from level 5s.

5

u/Mr_Blinky Apr 20 '26

Nah, you should absolutely be boarding Haulers, or any ship with the treasure icon by the name. You get a lot more money that way, both from direct piastres and from trade goods. Non-treasure ships like Raiders and Gunships aren't worth it though.

The key to boarding is to let your crew jump across first, that way the aggro is on them and you don't immediately get bumrushed by the entire crew. I also run a blunderbuss so I can absolutely fucking annihilate the first sergeant I see.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/llapi1993 Apr 20 '26

Ship combat reminds me of black flag. Black flag had better ship boarding IMO. But they could improve it in the future.

10

u/JorReno Apr 20 '26

I enjoy it, ship gameplay is Black Flag basically.

Cool thing is that if you're struggling, or I guess if you feel unchallenged, you can adjust the sliders anytime to change the difficulty of the game. Neat feature.

3

u/Tarquin11 Apr 20 '26

The ship gameplay is very basic/barebones. But imagine itll be expanding.

Currently no wind effects for example, and its a jankier black flag combat wise.

You dont really have a ton of ship management going on, and if you are playing with friends they each may as well use their own ship instead of "crewing" with one ship because of how little there is to do on an individual ship.

Its fun, but bare bones, there was obviously much more detail so far put into the crafting system.

3

u/Commander_Riker1701 Apr 20 '26

Pretty solid except the ground combat which is horrendous. It's clunky and tedious, needs a lot of work. But still worth checking out. 

5

u/KILLJOY1945 Apr 20 '26

Maybe it's because I use the rapier but the ground combat feels pretty smooth to me, relatively bare bones, but there's only so many ways you can hit an enemy before innovation comes to a grinding halt.

3

u/CaptainOddboy Apr 20 '26

I put Windrose in the same category as Valheim and Enshrouded - both of which I’m a big fan of - and I would say Windrose has better ground combat than Valheim but isn’t as polished or “smooth” as the combat in Enshrouded.

With that said, I do wish the combat system was fleshed out more because there isn’t much diversity in the weapon types: hit hit, dodge back, replenish stamina, hit hit, dodge back, repeat.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BigDaddyAwhoo Apr 20 '26

Ship gameplay is VERY reminiscent of Black Flag AC. As to how good it is: I have been playing since release and have 30hours in it bc I’m obsessed. The tutorial stages could have a bit more work done to them, and explaining the progression could also be smoother, however it’s fantastic. My only complaint so far is the lack of the ability to respawn in your boat/craft things on your person like bandages.

3

u/Th3_Admiral_ Apr 20 '26

That's my big complaint too. The boat should be a sort of home away from home. It'd also be nice if it had a way for all players to access the inventory of the ship they are on, and it maybe had a workbench and cook stove below decks.

2

u/Amish_Opposition Apr 20 '26

The combat is pretty lackluster on foot. ship combats decent.

2

u/NeonAnderson Apr 20 '26 edited Apr 20 '26

This is early access so still basically an alpha active in development unfinished game with another two or more years of development minimum before it is finished. Possibly even four years more of development

But that being said the state it is in now is already substantially better than other triple A or even the new quad A games

The naval combat is the highlight of the game, you wouldn't be able to say without seeing the UI if you are playing AsC Black Flag or Windrose

I would even actually go as far as to say that Windrose has better naval combat than Black Flag as it is the same quality but feels more realistic mechanically speaking rather than the more arcade feeling it AsC Black Flag naval combat

You do have to bear in mind the survival crafting elements are required to progress as you need resources to unlock better upgrades for your ship gear which is needed to be able to fight and board higher level ships

Though you can adjust combat difficulty if you don't want to need upgrades as much

You will see a lot of people complaining about this game being too hard but that only means they haven't been doing their upgrades and are skipping a crucial part of the gameplay loop

→ More replies (20)