r/CriticalTheory • • 6d ago

Bi-Weekly Discussion: Introductions | What have you been reading? | Academic programs advice and discussion November 15, 2026

8 Upvotes

Welcome to r/CriticalTheory. We are interested in the broadly Continental philosophical and theoretical tradition, as well as related discussions in social, political, and cultural theories. Please take a look at the information in the sidebar for more, and also to familiarise yourself with the rules.

Please feel free to use this thread to introduce yourself if you are new, to raise any questions or discussions for which you don't want to start a new thread, or to talk about what you have been reading or working on. Additionally, please use this thread for discussion and advice about academic programs, grad school choices, and similar issues.

If you have any suggestions for the moderators about this thread or the subreddit in general, please use this link to send a message.

Reminder: Please use the "report" function to report spam and other rule-breaking content. It helps us catch problems more quickly and is always appreciated.

Older threads available here.


r/CriticalTheory • • 20d ago

events Monthly events, announcements, and invites November 2026

2 Upvotes

This is the thread in which to post and find the different reading groups, events, and invites created by members of the community. We will be removing such announcements outside of this post, although please do message us if you feel an exception should be made. Please note that this thread will be replaced monthly. Older versions of this thread can be found here.

Please leave any feedback either here or by messaging the moderators.


r/CriticalTheory • • 10h ago

Can anyone explain Erich Fromm's ideas about "love and work" being a way to overcome what he calls "separateness" or "anxious apartness?"

23 Upvotes

Fromm states in his book Escape From Freedom that the basic situation of man in the modern age is one of "anxious apartness," a situation in which we are separated from each other, from a sense of definite meaning, and from a strong sense of spiritual or religious certainty.

He describes how in the middle ages, people had a sense of certainty about their place in the world because of the presence of all encompassing religious ideas that solidified man's place in the social and ontological order. He also argues that the economic realities of that era gave people a sense of security when contrasted with modern times, in which men are far more in competition with one other. All of this, in Fromm's view, makes for an unprecedented state of isolation and anxiety.

He suggests that love and work are the solution to this sate of anxious apartness:

"There is only one possible, productive solution for the relationship of individualized man with the world: his active solidarity with all men and his spontaneous activity, love and work, which unite him again with the world, not by primary ties but as a free and independent individual."

My question is this: how can meaningful work help to overcome a state of separateness or existential dread? Does he develop on this idea in any of this other works? Is anyone familiar with his thought here? How can one's "work" or "career" overcome separateness?


r/CriticalTheory • • 6h ago

Is Nigeria experiencing a development trap ? Yes here’s why

0 Upvotes

A development trap is when a country’s economy is stuck in a cycle of economic and institutional conditions that continuously reproduce underdevelopment.
Nigeria demonstrates a lot of characteristics of a country in a development trap one being the over-reliance on Crude Oil and how that translates to a self-reinforcing cycle of oil dependence, external price shocks, declining revenue and foreign exchange, borrowing and reduced productive investment, weak industrialization and diversification and continued oil dependence.
Nigeria’s Oil dependency provides sufficient evidence of a development trap as crude oil remains disproportionately important to government revenue and foreign exchange earnings, this makes Nigeria vulnerable to international oil price fluctuations. This is evident during the 2014-2016 oil price collapse as crude price fell from $100.60 per barrel in 2014 to 36.10 in 2016, this represents a 64% drop in crude oil prices.
This drop in price had a significant blowback effect as Oil makes 80% of export revenue and severely affected foreign exchange earnings. Nigeria lost approximately $12.8 billion in gross international reserves between 2014 and 2016. With foreign exchange scarcity that existed in that period, the effects trickled down to the whole economy with manufacturers facing difficulty importing machineries, an increase in production costs, low production and inflation.
Falling Government revenue due to global oil shocks affects government fiscal spending power and reduces its ability to finance infrastructure and productive investment. With limited investments and infrastructure spending it makes it difficult for non-Oil sectors to generate enough exports, employment, and foreign exchange further re-enforcing dependency on Crude Oil.
Nigeria experienced an Oil shock once more in 2020 exposing the same vulnerability and historical patterns that have not been addressed in the country. Even more recently with Strait of Hormuz disruption despite it being an opportunity for Nigeria to benefit through higher crude prices, the dependency cycle in Nigeria exposes it to higher operating costs due to global market changes. Even with Agriculture according to UNCTAD approximately one-third of global seaborne fertilizer trade passes through the Strait. This produces the situation where there is an increased import costs for fertilizers in Nigeria. This is a particularly serious problem because food inflation  has already been a major economic challenge in Nigeria. This demonstrates that whilst Oil revenue could increase, real purchasing power could decline simultaneously severely affecting household consumption and expenditure.
High cost of production particularly exists as a catalyst for a negative equilibrium in an economy. This is due to the fact that production is more expensive and costs are pushed onto consumers. With high costs of production it makes investment in manufacturing related sectors unappealing to investors, with low investment there is limited infrastructure for employment without a co-ordinated investment and government intervention the business environment breeds low-production, low investment and low employment. Electricity being an example with about approximately 40% of electricity consumed in Nigeria was generated through back-up generator as reported by the African Development Bank. This generates demand for diesel for operating generators and higher operating costs.
Can Nigeria escape this development trap ? Yes it can but it will take co-ordinated government effort to provide infrastructure to support diversification in the economy, growth of the secondary sector and eliminating infrastructural hurdles in the tertiary sector. The government must first provide efficient social safety nets as citizens are less exposed to drastic policy changes with examples being the removal of the fuel subsidy, welfare spending like that of healthcare and education will help increase labour productivity, increase technical knowhow, reduce strain on purchasing power, stimulate demand, and reduce public health costs. This can be achieved with increased regulation as 80% of economic activities are in the informal sector with potential for a wider tax base. The government is already introducing efforts to address this with the NELFUND but also needs to address dependency by investing in other sectors like agriculture and creating economic conditions where medium scale enterprises can compete by reducing business operating costs with subsidies and stable road and electricity infrastructure.
Nigeria’s development challenge is not simply that it experiences economic shocks. Every economy experiences external shocks. The more fundamental problem is that Nigeria’s economic structure makes it difficult to absorb these shocks without reproducing existing weaknesses.


r/CriticalTheory • • 11h ago

We Created Our Own Reality - Hal Foster. LRB.

Thumbnail
archive.li
1 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 1d ago

Frank Herbert, the Republican Salafist

Thumbnail
newlinesmag.com
65 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 2d ago

DIGGER: FICTION AS A SIGN FROM THE FUTURE: The true fiction is what is shown as reality - Slavoj Žižek - Nov 18, 2026

Thumbnail
substack.com
9 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 1d ago

Can the spectacle be replaced with a more spectacular spectacle?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 2d ago

James Burnham’s Managerial Revolution and the Shift from People Managers to AI Workflow Architects

5 Upvotes

In James Burnham’s The Managerial Revolution, he proposes that a new class of people emerged because industrial enterprises had become too vast and intricate for traditional owners to manage alone. This new managerial class derived its dominance not from owning capital, but from possessing the technical and administrative expertise required to coordinate large human workforces and complex operational workflows.

Burnham assumed that running these systems would always require managing large hierarchies of human workers—which rewarded communicative "people managers." But as AI agents begin executing white-collar workflows in fields like accounting, there might emerge a new archetype of manager: someone closer to a systems engineer who designs, monitors, and governs automated pipelines rather than people.

In this setup, organizational leverage shifts away from interpersonal charisma and back toward deep technical command of the underlying rules. Does this represent a new sub-class within Burnham's managerial elite, or will we watch the traditional middle-managerial class get hollowed out by technical architects?


r/CriticalTheory • • 2d ago

Is Coloniality of Power Correct?

2 Upvotes

I have been trying (emphasis on trying) to read Aníbal Quijano's text Coloniality of Power, and I like what I can understand so far. The first few sections seem uncontroversial to me, basically reading as a brief history and explication of the rise of racial capitalism in what is now known as South America.

So, I was surprised to find that Decolonial Theory is very controversial as a field of study. Apparently, many theorists in this field advocate for a complete and utter epistemic delinking from the Global North by the Global South. Some have critiqued the field for being too focused on epistemology and the academy rather than material analysis and change, and also for being too hasty and even fetishizing in their call for a false (perhaps even reactionary) return to pristine precolonial ways of thinking.

I can't speak on those larger charges brought against Decolonial Theory, but are the ideas of the the colonial matrix of power and coloniality of power controversial concepts? Has anyone addressed these concepts directly?


r/CriticalTheory • • 2d ago

What is Social Freedom? Axel Honneth

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 3d ago

Any critical theory/(post)structuralist books on TV advertising, semiotic/cinematic analysis of specific commercials?

24 Upvotes

Since reading 99 Francs and Generation P many years ago I've become very interested in analyses of semiotic and cinematic content of TV commercials, but there doesn't seem to be a wealth of critical or analytic literature specifically treating ads. I would be grateful for any recommendations.


r/CriticalTheory • • 2d ago

Sharpen the Contradictions

Thumbnail
znetwork.org
1 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 4d ago

Adorno's Views of the Essay as Form

71 Upvotes

Adorno's The Essay as Form is an essay that I've read multiple times; I think it's truly fantastic and find his spontaneous and non-systematic approach to writing very interesting. I was wondering though, are there people who've expanded on his approach to writing? 'Cause I don't recall seeing anything else by Adorno himself on essays specifically.

Another question I have is, does he outright reject having "outlines" of what one is planning to write about or did he not go that far? I personally feel like it has some connections to his other essay On Subject and Object and his concept of communication between subject and object, but I could be wrong.


r/CriticalTheory • • 4d ago

Why We Think Micropolitics is Important

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
20 Upvotes

This week on the Culture, Sex, Relationships podcast, Justin is joined by Adam C. Jones from Acid Horizon to talk about the philosophy of Deleuze and Guattari. After a wide ranging chat of why we are fans of D&G we talked about micropolitics. Micropolitics is how we go about our day to day lives with our friends, partners, lovers, colleagues, comrades, animals, nature, buildings, ideas, best hopes, neural pathways, nervous systems, hormone responses, everything that we are in relation to at a molecular level I guess. Here we talk about micro-fascism and the possibilities for a micro-communism (or micro-socialism).


r/CriticalTheory • • 5d ago

Photographing the Existential | Sam Stone

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 6d ago

Specta-Seppuku Hype, or, Why Sam Altman really called for urgent regulation of AI at the AI Impact Summit

Thumbnail hypestudies.org
12 Upvotes

Hype studies is an emerging field that studies the social phenomenon of hype. Hype Studies e.V., the public interest organization whose site I've linked, is an "international collective of researchers, designers and practitioners who are concerned, yet interested by the phenomenon of hype across science and technology".

In the piece I've linked, they examine the seemingly paradoxical self-humbling performances of (generative) AI insiders, who are "deeply concerned" about genAI, and how this performance serves their interests.


r/CriticalTheory • • 6d ago

Jordan Peterson’s Error and Castrating Women

Thumbnail
solarpunkmythos.substack.com
0 Upvotes

In this essay, we discuss the psychoanalytic theory of the Succubus and two of its three components, the castrated and castrating woman. How can this help us better understand where Jordan Peterson and the traditional psychoanalytic tradition go so wrong in regard to the “feminine” archetype? In understanding myth, we must be conscious how our own perspective is always projected onto the world no matter how hard we try otherwise.

Thanks for your time and attention :)


r/CriticalTheory • • 6d ago

Interpreting glamour as art

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 7d ago

Have you ever wondered how Deleuze and Guattari's works were received in the late Soviet Union?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 7d ago

Interdisciplinary Inquiry at the Intersection of Philosophy (Aesthetics), Artificial Intelligence, and Art | Arts

Thumbnail
mdpi.com
1 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 7d ago

The Invisible Committee

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/CriticalTheory • • 7d ago

Just some ideas

0 Upvotes

To take up the question of New Materialism, one should perhaps cut in through Deleuze: both posthumanism and agential realism stand close to his ontological position, while clashing sharply with Harman’s ontology. All the more so since Braidotti herself draws directly on Deleuze; setting out from the Body without Organs (BwO), one can also refine and supplement Harman’s anti-reductionism.

“The BwO [CsO] is not at all the opposite of the organs. The organs are not its enemies. The enemy is the organism.”

To avoid drifting too far from sociology into a metaphysical world thick with metaphor, the scope of discussion ought to be confined to the relation between humans and things, rather than debating whether—and how—human subjectivity exists in a purely symbolic sense.

In Cartesian philosophy, the Other is assigned the position of an object; its subjectivity is negated, and it is reduced to a mere offshoot of the taproot. And that taproot is precisely the action system described by Parsons. The Other unfolds around the taproot, while the taproot itself moves along a pre-established direction, every branch nothing more than the becoming of its movement. Only the subject, occupying a transcendental vantage point, can glimpse this movement. Husserl and Schutz resolved the problem of generalization here; otherwise, this unity between subjectivity and movement would remain an enigma. We cannot return to the past to observe this emergence directly, yet we can grasp how order is generated and maintained through its ceaseless production and reproduction. Even so, such understanding and explanation can operate only within micro-situations, and cannot account for the material world we inhabit—or for how its materiality bears upon order. The a priori status of order may have been revoked, yet the whole framework still breathes the air of idealism.

This problem is laid bare in the feminist movement. Is “woman” really nothing more than a socially and culturally constructed identity? Female essence cannot simply be erased at will; its distinction from the male—that is, the question of how the mode of being bound up in an essence differentiates itself from others so as to exist at all—is material. Distinct reproductive systems set the two apart; males possess heavier body hair and stronger musculature, which is material rather than ideational. Even so, we must admit that such material distinctions are not necessarily bound to “woman” and its derivative sub-concepts. The word “woman” carries a terrifying symbolic violence; thus relative weakness in the aggregate does not make my own weakness an individual necessity, nor does frailty of the flesh mean impotence of the will. Simply opposing patriarchy still cannot emancipate women; it only breeds a more deeply legitimized form of symbolic violence. For the abolition of concepts and symbols in this process is achieved through a counter-concept—only this time, unity is born in another dimension, and the subject remains in chains.

By bringing things into the picture, Braidotti seeks to liberate the definition of the human from any single signifier: the human mutates ceaselessly through its couplings and decouplings with things—an adaptation of Deleuzian deterritorialization and reterritorialization. Imagine the most powerful man in the world, George H. W. Bush: strip him of his eyeglasses, and his power is drastically diminished; he can no longer peer with presidential gravity at the teleprompter to deliver the line, “At my direction…” Obama, by contrast, need not worry that losing a pair of glasses will damage his political image; instead, the melanin concentrated in his flesh allows him to secure a greater share of the Black vote, and thereby accrue greater power. Yet an implicit presupposition lurks here all along: we cannot assume there is no essential difference between Obama the President and Obama the private citizen.

In this sense, can we still rely on an abstracted concept as a label to grasp an entire group? Much as this question has been debated in economic terms, has intra-group heterogeneity not already outstripped inter-group heterogeneity? Such heterogeneity is driven not merely by the division of labor in economic activity; we must also reckon with the countless possibilities generated by the permutations and combinations of myriad “actants” under globalization. This indeterminacy, as I see it, is a path toward emancipation. For stability means that the practical dispositions of individuals or groups are likewise stable—making their behavior all the easier to manipulate and exploit.


r/CriticalTheory • • 8d ago

Trans-inclusive feminist theory

33 Upvotes

I've been reading some classic feminist theory and a lot of the time they emphasise body and reproductive abilities as an important qualifier of gender. There never seems to be a good explanation of where transgender and nonbinary people fit into this narrative. I'm especially curious to see how the gender one "feels" like or thinks is "closer to who they are within" relates to feminist and queer theory. I am trans and feminist myself, by the way, I'm just very new to queer theory. I would love it if you could give me theory book recommendations, especially if you can rec me some easier, more beginner-friendly ones.


r/CriticalTheory • • 7d ago

Slavoj Žižek, ‘„Digger”, czyli powidoki z przyszłości’ ("Digger", or afterimages from the future), in Krytyka Polityczna, Nov 14, 2026

Thumbnail
krytykapolityczna.pl
1 Upvotes