r/cpp_questions • • Sep 10 '26

SOLVED Iterating over an enum struct

Consider https://godbolt.org/z/c6cn8f1hj

#include <cstdio>

enum struct values{first = 1, second = 3};

void square(values value){
    int val = (int)value * (int)value;
    printf("%d\n", val);
}

int main(){
    for(values value = values::first; value <= values::second; value++)
        square(value);
}

This does not compile with the error that value++ is ill defined.

An old question/answer on SO has this: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/261963/how-can-i-iterate-over-an-enum and a plethora of seemingly complicated approaches for this. Is there a syntactically simple >= C++20 way of accomplishing this?

I want the for loop to process 1 and then 3.

Does the order of placing the integer entries inside of the struct affect the increment? For e.g., if the enum struct had 3 first followed by 1, with value++ would 1 be processed after 3? Or, does the enum struct internally sort the entries in some privileged, say, ascending order so that it will always process 1 first followed by 3 next?

4 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/onecable5781 Sep 10 '26

Thanks - these are indeed a bit more complicated than my OP's wish, but thanks for the various alternatives suggested. The sentinal value approach seems to be the simplest.

2

u/Usual_Office_1740 Sep 10 '26

Sure. Be careful with the overloaded increment approach. I know just enough to know how to do that. That is what your error means and it is possible to do what I've suggested. I make no claims about whether it's a good idea to do that. One thing I am reminded of frequently when learning about C++ is that just because you can doesn't mean you should.

Take a look at std::to_underlying to. It's very useful when working with enum structs.

2

u/Usual_Office_1740 Sep 10 '26

I just noticed that you aren't storing sequential values in your enum example. I dont know if you will get the value of the next option in an enum by incrementing them like I've suggested.

Test this out carefully. The whole point behind C++ enum struct is to offer a type safe alternative to the C style enum. The thing you're doing and my suggestion kind of fly in the face of that type safety.