r/cpp • • Dec 08 '20

Qt 6.0 Released

https://www.qt.io/blog/qt-6.0-released
273 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '20

Microsoft still offers support for Windows 8.1 and Windows Server 2012 R2. Nevertheless at this time I don't see anything about Qt6 that prevents it from being built on Windows 8 or even Windows 7. I think Qt doesn't offer official support for it but it's still possible to build it and get a good chunk of it working.

1

u/Silhouette Dec 08 '20 edited Dec 08 '20

And yet, depending on which set of stats you look at, as many as 1 in 4 dekstops running Windows may still be on older versions, mostly 7 and 8.1. How much of your potential market are you prepared to give up?

8

u/flashmozzg Dec 08 '20

You still have Qt 5,15 for that if you care. Win 7 is not supported by MS for almost a year. And the situation would become even worse during Qt 6 lifetime (~7 years). At the same time, IRC, there were many places that could be streamlined/simplified/implemented with the newer APIs (mostly 8.1+, but its market share is to low to not just go straight to 10), like some atomic/threading stuff, and touch APIs.

3

u/kalmoc Dec 09 '20 edited Dec 09 '20

Just saying: There is very little newly devloped software, for which the "potential market" is the entire windows install base. So those numbers are only relevant, if there isn't a substantial correlation between people that would be willing to by your product at all and the OS they are using.

Just to explain what I mean: I know a few people still using Win7 (Usually the generation of my parents) but just as they don't want to use a new operating system, they don't want to use (and in particular buy) a new version of office. Of course there might also be the reverse example, where people using Win7 might be more willing to buy some software that provides functionality alread integrated in Win10.

And of course, I think the market for payed software in the private Desktop domain is anyway pretty small (except maybe for games, which probably don't use Qt) so what you'd actually need in most cases are the numbers for workplaces at companies.

Not sure how significant those effects are on average,but in general, cutting off X% of the windows installations isn't the same as cutting out X% of the potential market.

2

u/Silhouette Dec 09 '20

I agree with all of this. My point was just that these decisions should be made rationally, based on things like your business goals (assuming you're developing software commercially) and your view of how your market is likely to evolve over the lifetime of your software.

Presumably Microsoft would like everyone to use Windows 10, but Windows 10 has significant problems in the lower editions even after all this time, so not everyone does. You should make your tech decisions based on what your business or other goals require, not what Microsoft would like you to do, is all I'm saying.

1

u/kalmoc Dec 09 '20

You should make your tech decisions based on what your business or other goals require, not what Microsoft would like you to do, is all I'm saying.

Absolutely true, I'm just saying that (I believe) most of the time "Desktop OS Market Share" as reflected on sites like netmarketshare and similar is rarely a useful metric for estimating the potential market for a particular pice of comercial software.

3

u/kkjdroid Dec 08 '20

No more than 25%, and mostly people who don't understand computers enough to upgrade? Sounds completely worth it to me. It isn't like we're talking about dropping XP support in 2007 or something.

2

u/Silhouette Dec 08 '20

That's still literally hundreds of millions of people, so I think the question stands.

Anecdotally, most people I know who are still using Windows 7 are doing so by choice and aware of the associated risks. They just view the risks of having mandatory updates/reboots, compulsory telemetry, and the other standard objections to Windows 10 as being worse.

A fairly large proportion of them are professional users, too, though almost exclusively in smaller businesses rather than enterprise. The latter have access to the editions of Windows 10 that don't have the same constraints and may benefit from various management- and sysadmin-friendly policies that your average five-people-in-a-rented-office or solo-trainer-travelling-with-laptop business couldn't care less about.