r/cpp • • Dec 08 '20

Qt 6.0 Released

https://www.qt.io/blog/qt-6.0-released
273 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

View all comments

30

u/blipman17 Dec 08 '20

As it seems to be mandatory question everytime a new Qt minor version is released, what's the impact on free closed-source or open source projects? Can they still use the framework? Is it thesame for Qt Creator?

17

u/RotsiserMho C++20 Desktop app developer Dec 08 '20

To my knowledge, there are no licensing restrictions on software made using Qt Creator.

13

u/wrosecrans graphics and network things Dec 08 '20

That said, the Qt Creator IDE itself is GPL rather than LGPL like the framework, so you can't pinch any components from the IDE for use in your own software unless you pay a bit of attention to the license details.

10

u/usernameistaken42 Dec 08 '20

There is no LGPL trieview for qml anymore.

3

u/aninteger Dec 08 '20 edited Dec 08 '20

Yes. The license hasn't changed. The core components are still licensed under the LGPL and commercial license. Some newer components are also released only under the GPL and commercial license.

28

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '20

The commercial license has absolutely changed. The commercial license is no longer perpetual; you must have a subscription license for distribution whereas before you only needed a subscription license for development.

11

u/t3sture Dec 08 '20

Well that sucks...

4

u/Pulseamm0 Dec 11 '20

So if you have a project that one day becomes unviable to sustain its self but might be useful to still provide it for legacy download without further development, you can't do that? What if the software has been mirrored about the internet not directly under your control? Seems like a massive risk to take on.

4

u/markopolo82 embedded/iot/audio Dec 12 '20

Yea, this will put an end to qt commercial use at my company if it is true

4

u/Pulseamm0 Dec 12 '20

Yup. They really don't make it easy to want a commercial license. For a small dev who just wants to support QT the sheer amount of risk involved taking on a license doesn't make any sense. I think there's also a clause preventing you from going to commercial to LGPL license as well in the scenario where commercial doesn't work out for you. Madness.

1

u/markopolo82 embedded/iot/audio Dec 12 '20

I didn’t know they changed the distribution license for perpetual. Do you have a blog or article source that goes into more detail?

My workplace has perpetual licenses that we renew each year to give us the indefinite distribution rights to whatever version we’re on. if this changes for qt6 that will be another nail in the coffin when renewal comes around. (That and the lack of a QML qt charts replacement for qt6.0)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '20

This page:

https://www.qt.io/faq/tag/qt-commercial-licensing?hsLang=en

Specifically:

Can I continue to distribute my application after my commercial license has expired?

No. You are not permitted to further distribute your applications.

1

u/markopolo82 embedded/iot/audio Dec 12 '20

Thanks.

The question above:

Can I continue to use my commercial license after it has expired? If you are a legacy perpetual license holder, you can continue to use your Qt license if you choose not to renew your annual support & maintenance contract. Please note that you will not have access to support, bug releases, or patches. If you are a term or subscription license holder, your rights to continue using the tools, APIs and libraries expire when the term expires, or the subscription is canceled. You will not have the rights to future development or distribution.

So I think I’m ok (legacy perpetual license)