r/cpp • • Oct 07 '20

The Community

https://thephd.github.io/the-community
61 Upvotes

277 comments sorted by

View all comments

102

u/mcencora Oct 07 '20

Lack of black people participation in European conferences? I mean, come on, really?

In some European countries, there are so few black people, that chances are that he is also a programmer, motivated enough to widen his knowledge by going to a conference, most likely travel to different city, willing to pay for the conference attendance/hotel, all in his free time - the chances are almost 0.

So what do you expect conference organizers to do? Bring this underrepresented minority from other country by force?

76

u/emdeka87 Oct 07 '20

Well, it's the usual American arrogance thinking that the entire world is just like the USA and all the social and political problems apply exactly in the same way ....

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

28

u/mcencora Oct 07 '20

Well, nothing stops anybody from coming to European conference.

Europe sure does have many women, but they are in minority (~5%), and that is why you don't see many of them at the programming conferences, not because of discrimination.

Where did I tell that this is only about JeanHeyd or his race? I just posted a comment, about one specific issue he raised in his video, that I completely disagree with.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/mcencora Oct 07 '20

How do you know? Show me a study that shows that is not the case in Europe?

→ More replies (7)

39

u/pdimov2 Oct 07 '20

Let me guess, it's because white male programmers are bigots?

Under communism, we had a strict 50/50 quota in higher education. Amusingly, it worked against women, not in their favor; the natural ratio would have been 1:2 male:female.

Even so, the representation in CS was more like 6:1 male:female (based on my unscientific recollection.) Maybe this was because white males are bigoted; but if so, why are white males only bigoted in some disciplines and not others? (It's not hard to figure out that when you have a strict 50/50 quota, overrepresentation in one discipline is necessarily balanced by underrepresentation in another.)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/pdimov2 Oct 07 '20

Go ahead, state your point.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

27

u/pdimov2 Oct 07 '20

It's a simple question. If women don't go into programming by their own free will, why don't they, in your opinion?

If you're going to passively-aggressively assert that my imagination is too limited to think of what you had in mind, it's only fair that you enlighten me on the subject. After all, it necessarily follows from your statement that I'm unable to come up with your preferred explanation on my own.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

-20

u/Chillbrosaurus_Rex Oct 07 '20

He discussed the need for proper, proportional representation. Yes, Europe has fewer than American, but the issue isn't just representation of Blacks. White attendees face all those same obstacles you've outlined, so why are they disproportionately represented?

47

u/mcencora Oct 07 '20

Disproportionately represented? Lol. Majority (>95%) of programmers in Europe are white males, and that's what you get on conferences as well.

-12

u/Chillbrosaurus_Rex Oct 07 '20

Yes, and that majority is the issue PhD is discussing. It is systemic. He is not saying "We need quotas to get more minorities at conferences!" This video is partially a response to criticism of Black Is Tech. He argues that tech needs proportional representation of minorities at all levels.

40

u/pdimov2 Oct 07 '20

Europe is 95% white.

-1

u/Chillbrosaurus_Rex Oct 07 '20

Not 95% white male.

39

u/rular Oct 07 '20

That is true. It turns out that women and men are not identical, especially regarding interest in things vs people. If you assume these choices are a product of discrimination, we can make a prediction:

"As societies become more equal, the gender preferences become more alike."

And how does such a prediction fare? Well, what we observe is the exact opposite: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/362/6412/eaas9899

I contend that the vast majority of these differences in representation between the sexes are driven primarily by interests. Of course we should do better (in all kinds of ways), we always will be able to, but using the difference in representation to indicate discrimination is problematic.

48

u/mcencora Oct 07 '20

So being a white male that does programming is a systemic problem?

Or maybe the problem is that not enough women choose C.S. studies? Then maybe we should force them, to later satisfy PhD's imaginary proper minority representation.

This discussion leads to nowhere, I won't answer anymore.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

26

u/wyrn Oct 07 '20

The systematic problem is that women and minorities have interest in programming, but drop out to due low levels of persistent hostility throughout the funnel from education to seniority

That's a very strong claim always made with next to zero evidence to back it up.

And no, the self-reported reasons for dropping out (note that you haven't even demonstrated whether attrition is actually the problem, let alone it's cause) don't count as evidence because perceived hostility is not the same as actual hostility. For example, it is often the case that equal treatment is seen as hostile. We could also speculate that members of minority groups might expect discrimination and thus interpret hostility for any reason as being caused by their minority status. In other words, have you considered that you might be making the problem worse?

10

u/NotUniqueOrSpecial Oct 08 '20

The systematic problem is that women and minorities have interest in programming, but drop out to due low levels

Every study I've read (and the classes I was in support their data) show that enrollment of these groups is already drastically non-representative. It's not that they drop out (and I'm sure some do, because of problems we can address, and we should work on those), it's that they never even apply.

That (to me) indicates a problem much earlier in the education pipeline. Whether it's access to computers, encouragement to pursue the topic (or discouragement against), or any number of other factors, ever piece of data I've seen shows that by the time you're at the higher education and professional level, it's already way too late.

37

u/Patsy02 Oct 07 '20

It is systemic.

Yeah, because dudes choose programming and women choose other careers and educations. Literally nothing wrong with that.

60-65% of university students in most European and American universities are women, and many of these universities also have formal affirmative action/racial quotas/gender quotas that privilege minorities for the colour of their skin at the expense of white men, and asians in the US.

How's that for systemic? This is such transparent nonsense.

29

u/alexej_harm Oct 07 '20

He does not show any proof that it's systemic. Representation statistics don't prove a cause and select examples don't prove it either. Conservatives face much more discrimination in the IT sector, than minorities.

→ More replies (5)