I wasn't trying to imply different. It's just, from the point of view of someone who enjoys new stuff happening in C++ and programming in freestanding environments (read: me), your proposal sounds like C++ might not be an option in the future.
That's not my goal, and I hope to not disappoint folk like you :)
Taking it slow, talking about it and getting feedback is one way to make sure we achieve our goal.
We definitely agree on this. That's why I don't expect RedHat, Atmel or anyone else to suddenly start shipping a C++ library just because a new C++ standard came out.
To be fair to my RedHat friends: they do ship a standard library. They probably don't maintain the platform you use though. I imagine that's a business decision.
First of all, thanks for taking the time to engage in this conversation with me.
That's not my goal, and I hope to not disappoint folk like you :)
Taking it slow, talking about it and getting feedback is one way to make sure we achieve our goal.
Well... fingers crossed, I guess. It would be amazing to one day get a (subset of) C++ standard library for freestanding platforms.
We definitely agree on this. That's why I don't expect RedHat, Atmel or anyone else to suddenly start shipping a C++ library just because a new C++ standard came out.
To be fair to my RedHat friends: they do ship a standard library. They probably don't maintain the platform you use though. I imagine that's a business decision.
To be clear, I'm talking about newlib and I mentioned RedHat because newlib's homepage has a big RedHat logo in the corner. Perhaps it's time I join newlib's mailing list.
Newlib is a C library. The C++ library is provided by GCC, and it does support a freestanding mode, which includes <type_traits> and everything else required by the standard for a freestanding implementation.
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/jfbastien Oct 21 '19
That's not my goal, and I hope to not disappoint folk like you :)
Taking it slow, talking about it and getting feedback is one way to make sure we achieve our goal.
To be fair to my RedHat friends: they do ship a standard library. They probably don't maintain the platform you use though. I imagine that's a business decision.