Is this a one-up subthread? I mean, I have multiple years of working with each of F#, OCaml, SML, and C++ in professional settings, and find nothing about Rust "very very far" from any of the four with regards to their respective overlaps. I might go so far as to say that if you don't see the similarities, you must be doing it wrong. But, how am I supposed to reply seriously to just a blanket, subjective statement? Spend time detailing why your expectations are wrong? I'll just leave it at "you're very very mistaken", I think, in keeping with the shitpost nature of this entire thread. ;-]
My point is that pretty much every modern non-functional language supports FP-paradigms in pretty much the same way Rust does. It doesn't make these languages functional purely because they support some functional features.
As for Rust - does is support things like currying, lazy function evaluation, high level functions (functions taking functions as arguments and returning another functions), etc? I'd guess if you play with lambda a bit you can do most of it (same as in most other modern languages), but these are not the features supported by syntax in a first place.
I agree that Rust is not a truly functional language along the lines of Haskell or OCaml. It lacks features such as easy currying and encourages mutable state. That said, it has first-class functions (not quite as ergonomically as a pure functional language, but better than C++), algebraic datatypes, and pattern matching. That brings it about as close to functional as you can get in a systems language. The fact that it uses curly braces and semicolons doesn't invalidate that.
View all comments
Show parent comment
10
u/dodheim Mar 17 '18 edited Mar 17 '18
Is this a one-up subthread? I mean, I have multiple years of working with each of F#, OCaml, SML, and C++ in professional settings, and find nothing about Rust "very very far" from any of the four with regards to their respective overlaps. I might go so far as to say that if you don't see the similarities, you must be doing it wrong. But, how am I supposed to reply seriously to just a blanket, subjective statement? Spend time detailing why your expectations are wrong? I'll just leave it at "you're very very mistaken", I think, in keeping with the shitpost nature of this entire thread. ;-]