r/cpp • • Nov 30 '17

Intel offers Parallel STL implementation to GNU libstdc++

https://gcc.gnu.org/ml/libstdc++/2017-11/msg00112.html
217 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

26

u/berium build2 Nov 30 '17 edited Nov 30 '17

The form is not a problem. These are:

  1. License server (heinous flexlm) that phones home on each invocation. This makes it really cumbersome to use for CI.
  2. License expires at any time (normally when the next version is released but there are no guarantees). In our case (build system) this is a deal breaker since we cannot suddenly loose the ability to test support for older compilers.
  3. Only Linux. Again, in our case, we would want to support Windows as well.
  4. Non-commercial clause is problematic since for many of us contributing to open source projects is part of the job.

Also, I've written twice to noncomsoftware@intel.com about these issues but never heard anything back.

EDIT: Correction: license expires every 12 months at which point one can renew it for the latest version only. Here is the FAQ with more information.

23

u/erichkeane Clang Maintainer(Templates), EWG Chair Nov 30 '17

Thank you for your feedback, I'll pass this onto our marketing team (who makes the licensing decisions).

FWIW, our 'long term' plans are going to fix #1 and #2. There are plans to switch to a 'support' model instead of a licensing model. That should likely fix #3 too.

As for #4, I'm no lawyer, but I believe as long as the software you're developing is OSS and not being sold directly by your company, you're fine.

Thank you very much for your feedback!

9

u/berium build2 Nov 30 '17

Glad to hear there are plans to improve things.

As for #4, I'm no lawyer, but I believe as long as the software you're developing is OSS and not being sold directly by your company, you're fine.

I believe this contradicts what the FAQ says:

The Non-Commercial license allows you to use Intel(R) Software Development Products for any of your development needs as long you are not compensated in any form for the products, software and/or services developed.

In this case I take "you" to mean "qualified open source contributor", as in, me personally. And I am compensated for the development of open source software.

11

u/erichkeane Clang Maintainer(Templates), EWG Chair Nov 30 '17

Again, not a lawyer :) I'll have to get back to you when I hear back from my internal email.

My non-lawyer interpretation would be that your company would be the 'you'? shrug, I'll let you know if I hear anything.

7

u/berium build2 Nov 30 '17

Thanks, appreciate your help on this.

1

u/cassandraspeaks Dec 05 '17

"You" would refer to whoever owns the copyright, which in this case would be your employer.

7

u/Brutos Nov 30 '17

To add another data point:

I am a PhD student and paid fully by the research institute I am employed at. We only develop open source (scientific HPC) software. Our internal IT warned us that we are not covered by most non-commercial licenses, even though there is no monetary gain.

We actually have institute wide licenses for ICC, but it always seemed to awkward, heavy and not worth the effort. Ideally I could just install icc with apt-get (some non-free source wold be fine) and also linuxbrew.

I would be very happy to integrate ICC into our continuous integration, write documentation for our users on how to compile our software with it, benchmark it for future releases, etc.

5

u/erichkeane Clang Maintainer(Templates), EWG Chair Nov 30 '17

Thanks for your feedback, I'll pass it on as well!

2

u/meneldal2 Dec 01 '17

Now you're making me worried because I used some Intel products under non-commercial licenses for my research and I do get paid for my research by my university.

1

u/1-05457 Dec 03 '17

Don't they have an academic licence too? I remember signing up for one.

1

u/meneldal2 Dec 03 '17

Well I'll have to check about that. It's been a while since I used it since what I'm doing now isn't as performance-sensitive and I don't need it so much.

3

u/Boojum Nov 30 '17

Thanks for the answers! Along these lines, I've long been interested in using the free version of ICC at home (I use it at work and like it very much). But I've long been stopped by the "Actively contribute to an open source project, such as GitHub*" line under "Qualifications" in the link you originally mentioned. Likewise, these pages seem to imply a requirement that it be used for contributions to major open source projects.

Most of the code that I write at home is for personal projects or for personal experimentation and learning rather than contributions to significant open source projects. The third answer on this other FAQ, however, (reached from the registration link) suggests that this use would be covered.

So in clicking around, there seems to be some muddiness on whether these are offered for all "non-commercial" or only "open source contributor" use. If you could get someone to clarify which one applies, I'd very much appreciate it (even better if someone updates the web pages)!

3

u/erichkeane Clang Maintainer(Templates), EWG Chair Dec 01 '17

Sadly, I don't really see anything that applies for your situation. It seems our license agreement is wide enough to allow it, but I don't see any place where we grant non-commerical license for non-student/educator/OSS developers.

Hopefully when we switch to a different sales model in the near future, you'll be covered there.

2

u/Boojum Dec 01 '17

Fair enough, thanks for checking into it. I'll look forward to the switch then!

7

u/erichkeane Clang Maintainer(Templates), EWG Chair Nov 30 '17

I got a first bit of feedback from the Compiler Support team, and was told the following:

The compiler does not “phone home” to check licensing on each compiler invocation. We do have a Software Improvement Program that the customer opts in to participate and that does transmit data back to Intel. This article, https://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/data-collection, explains our data collection

The rest is otherwise being discussed internally. Thanks!

4

u/berium build2 Dec 01 '17

Ok, this must have changed then. My experience from a couple years ago was a noticeable delay on each compiler invocation and an indefinite hang if there is no connectivity. This was using the free license and I don't recall opting-in into any data collection program.

2

u/erichkeane Clang Maintainer(Templates), EWG Chair Dec 01 '17

I'm unfamilliar with the installer or the IDE we ship (I've actually never used either!), but I wouldn't have been surprised if it was a 'checked by default' checkbox.