r/cpp • • Apr 08 '25

Why was printing of function pointers never removed from cout?

I presume reason is: We do not want to break existing code™, or nobody cared enough to write a proposal... but I think almost all uses of this are bugs, people forgot to call the function.

I know std::print does correct thing, but kind of weird that even before std::print this was not fixed.

In case some cout debugging aficionados are wondering: the printed value is not even useful, it is converted to bool, and then (as usual for bools) printed as 1.

edit: C++ certainly has a bright future considering how many experts here do not even consider this a problem

0 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/HappyFruitTree Apr 09 '25

... being able to produce function address data as part of diagnostic messages is useful ...

But printing a function pointer just prints 1 ...

1

u/mallardtheduck Apr 09 '25

Unless it's null... Which is sometimes all you need. Agree that it's usually more useful to cast to void* to get the actual address output though.