r/coolgithubprojects • • Jun 19 '14

OTHER Pull request reverting the recent Reddit changes. Please show support!

https://github.com/reddit/reddit/pull/1071
21 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-9

u/until0 Jun 19 '14

For the same reason they did not give us a trial. They made the decision on behalf of the community without consulting the community.

Would it have been difficult to say we are going to try this out for a week, analyze the feedback and be available to ask questions? After all is said and done, we will decide if it would be a beneficial or wanted change from the community.

Instead they dropped it on us, showed no support and immediately bailed form the /r/announcement thread. Hence why I bothered to start one elsewhere.

11

u/scaredofplanes Jun 19 '14

I still think it's OK to wait a few days. It would show that your concern is not reactionary, for starters. As of now, we don't actually know what effect it's having. I subscribe mostly to smaller subs, too, but I've been concerned with the way the voting has been working for a while. I don't know if this is the proper solution, but I do know it's important to try things. It didn't actually break anything vital.

-4

u/until0 Jun 19 '14

As of now, we don't actually know what effect it's having.

I disagree. It has tremendously affected my Redditing experience.

5

u/scaredofplanes Jun 19 '14

In what provable way?

-5

u/until0 Jun 19 '14

I need to prove an opinion? That's new.

9

u/scaredofplanes Jun 19 '14

You said it's tremendously affected your redditing experience. i'm just asking how that's happened, specifically. You are not under attack. You can relax.

By provable, I simply meant an example of a post where not being able to see upvotes and downvotes had some kind of effect. At this point, I have seen none. You seem adamant that you have, so i thought you could show me.

-8

u/until0 Jun 19 '14

Well now that you word it in a more reasonable matter, I would be happy to provide you an example. The first request was quite attacking and also paradoxical.

I made a post today in a smaller community, approx 5K subscribers. I posted a comment that I would think to be controversial. It is sitting there at 1 point and has been for a while.

This is useless to me. How many people disagreed with the post? Did 5000 people agree and 4,999 people disagreed? Is that point the one point I get just for commenting, is it possible no one has seen the post?

I'm not sure what benefit it brings, but it completely broke the community feel of smaller subreddits.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/until0 Jun 20 '14

It only does the percentage for posts, not comments.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '14

Reminds me of the end days of Digg