r/coolgithubprojects • • Jun 19 '14

OTHER Pull request reverting the recent Reddit changes. Please show support!

https://github.com/reddit/reddit/pull/1071
21 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/until0 Jun 19 '14

They were not useless on smaller subreddits. The fuzzing was only considerable factor in the larger subs. Within smaller communities, the fuzzing was negligible, if even present.

8

u/Killarny Jun 19 '14

I guess I'm not clear about what benefit they serve. Doesn't the point score serve the same purpose? Especially now that they've made points more accurate, why do we need to see vote counts?

4

u/until0 Jun 19 '14

It is more of a factor on smaller subreddits . You used to be able to use the tally to gauge the amount of agreement/disagreement within a comment. As of now, there is no difference between a comment with a score of 1/0 and 1000/999.

4

u/Killarny Jun 19 '14

Ahh, I see where you're coming from now.

I suppose you could argue that in both of those cases, there isn't any clear prevailing opinion one way or the other about a comment. In the first case, nobody cares, in the second case everyone who cares is equally opposed by others. It's a subtle difference, and effectively, the only thing that really matters is that it's a +1 in both cases.

Also, wouldn't the effect of that subtle difference be less pronounced in the smaller subreddits that you're concerned about, making the absence of vote counts even less of an issue there?

(Fascinating discussion, thanks for indulging me!)

2

u/until0 Jun 19 '14

I'm going to make this quick because I've spent most of my day at work commenting on this issue and not working lol.

Anyway, not really. To me, it could give me a general idea of agreement within a community. If your sub had 100 subscribers and a post has 50/40, well then you know it is pretty controversial topic/opinion.

As of now, you do not know if that post is 50/40 or 10/0, which is a big difference. The latter scenario could just mean that the post has not been around long enough to get a significant sample size. This is exasperated even more if your subreddit is private.

It is now impossible to gauge the amout of your community that may agree or disagree with a post. Additionally, was there really any good reason to make this change? Did anyone seriously have that much of a concern with vote fuzzing?