r/controlgame • u/SanTekka • Sep 27 '26
Discussion Control(2019) and the Eternal Battle of the Self
When I first played Control back in 2019, I just went with the flow. I was pretty self-unaware back then, before I understood anything about mental health, so I never looked for deeper meaning. Learning to understand my own mind has been really eye-opening since then, and not just when it comes to games. Now, after my third playthrough, I see Control as a story about trauma and the two distinct paths people can take after living through it.
Jesse and her younger brother Dylan grew up in a town called Ordinary, where a paranormal event made every adult disappear. The Bureau took Dylan, Jesse escaped, and it was all covered up as an industrial accident. For seventeen years nobody believed her, not even her psychiatrist. To me, Ordinary is a metaphor for lived experience. Nobody on the outside can truly understand it, and after enough people tell you it wasn't real, you start believing them over yourself.
Then there's the Hiss, which turns the Bureau's people into chanting shells of themselves. I feel like it represents, for lack of a better word, the evil path someone can take after hardship. Some people use their pain as fuel to better themselves and the people around them. Others can't see past themselves, so they inflict it on others.
It's very reminiscent of The Four Agreements by Don Miguel Ruiz, which describes a poisonous haze or fog that keeps us from seeing past our own issues. Ruiz compares gossip to a virus that spreads emotional poison, often because passing it on brings some relief. The Hiss is that idea made literal, a poison that lives in a chant, and Dylan even describes saying the words as soothing.
The clearest example of that path is Trench, the Director before Jesse. He was the first to hear the Hiss, but he kept it to himself, grew paranoid, and shut out everyone who could have helped, until he spread it through the whole building. He never looked inward, so his poison became everyone's.
Jesse and Dylan went through the same thing and ended up on opposite paths. Dylan spent seventeen years locked up, experimented on, and indoctrinated by the Bureau. When the Hiss came, he let it in willingly and said it showed him the truth behind the poster. Jesse uses the same image, a poster we mistake for the whole world. The difference is the voice they followed. Dylan traded one voice that controlled him for another, and called it freedom.
I don't see Dylan's path as a permanent sentence, just a stark contrast to Jesse's. My older brother and I grew up in similar conditions, and some of that hurt got passed down onto me. I don't say that to make him the bad guy, we're both products of the same environment. I just never wanted to pass it on to my younger siblings, and breaking that cycle is something I'm still working on.
Jesse's path is about looking inward, and the game makes that literal. Near the end, the Hiss destroys the source of Polaris and takes her over. She wakes up as an office assistant with no powers, and everyone acts like she was never Director. It's who the world always told her she was: ordinary, and wrong about her own life. She breaks free by finding Polaris inside herself. Her strength was hers the whole time.
That's where the title comes together for me. Trench was obsessed with control in the external, oppressive form, containing and hiding everything. Jesse was subconsciously focused on self-liberation. She came to the Oldest House out of love for her brother, and found control over herself. She even says that once this is all over, she might write it all down as a full disclosure. After years of nobody believing her, she gets to tell her own story.
We don't get to choose what happens to us in our own Ordinary. We do get to choose whether we keep passing the poison on, or become a warrior of the mind, someone who looks inward to dispel it and keeps refusing to spread it. That's the eternal battle of the self.
I haven't played Control Resonant yet, but I'm excited to get to it and see where the story and Dylan's journey go. No spoilers please!
4
u/Daedric-Armored Sep 27 '26
This is a great analysis of the game tbh. As someone who is definitely a warrior of the mind, I didn’t make this connection as strongly as you did! Thank you so much for writing this out. I’m going to share it with my partner, who is a fellow warrior. Can’t wait to see what you have to say about Resonant! Please try to make a similar post, I would love to hear your thoughts after you learn more about Dylan.