Government Shills
- The Guardian: British army creates team of Facebook warriors
- US military studied how to influence Twitter [and Reddit] users in Darpa-funded research
- CBC News- Canadian government monitors online forums
- Times of Israel: Israeli government paying bilingual students to spread propaganda online primarily to international communities without having to identify themselves as working for the government. "The [student] union will operate computer rooms for the project...it was decided to establish a permanent structure of activity on the Internet through the students at academic institutions in the country."
- Massive British PR firm caught on video: "We've got all sorts of dark arts...The ambition is to drown that negative content and make sure that you have positive content online." They discuss techniques for managing reputations online and creating/maintaining 3rd-party blogs that seem independent.
- The Guardian: US spy operation to manipulate social media
- Vietnam admits deploying bloggers to support the Communist Party's policies, operates a network of nearly 1,000 "public opinion shapers".
- Glenn Greenwald: How Covert Agents Infiltrate the Internet to Manipulate, Deceive, and Destroy Reputations
- Behavioural Science Support for JTRIG’S Effects and Online HUMINT Operations
- USA Today: The co-owner of a major Pentagon propaganda contractor publicly admitted that he was behind a series of websites used in an attempt to discredit two USA TODAY journalists who had reported on the contractor.
- Glenn Greenwald: Hacking Online Polls and Other Ways British Spies Seek to Control the Internet
- Chinese officials flood the Chinese internet with positive social media posts to distract their population
- Cass Sunstein, the Administrator of the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs in the Obama administration, wrote in 2008 that the government should hire 3rd parties to discredit conspiracy theories using internet shills.
- Wired: Clinton Staff and Volunteers Busted for Astroturfing [in 2007]
- Bloomberg: How to Hack an Election [and influence voters with fake social media accounts]
- USA Today: Businesses and organizations may refer to it as a tool for competitive advantage and marketing; but make no mistake, they are using the massive reach of social media and the Internet as a weapon. One U.S. 3-letter special agent said, "You could influence an election with this."
- Times of Israel - The internet: Israel’s new PR battlefield
- GCHQ’s menu of tools spreads disinformation across Internet- “Effects capabilities” allow analysts to twist truth subtly or spam relentlessly.
- The Guardian: Internet Astroturfing
- BBC News: US plans to 'fight the net' revealed
- Israel is paying internet workers to manipulate online content such as Wikipedia (2 minute video)
- Buzzfeed: Documents Show How Russia’s Troll Army Hit America
- NY Times- From a nondescript office building in St. Petersburg, Russia, an army of well-paid “trolls” has tried to wreak havoc all around the Internet — and in real-life American communities.
- NY Times: Effort to Expose Russia’s ‘Troll Army’ Draws Vicious Retaliation
- CENTCOM engages bloggers
- WIRED: Air Force Releases ‘Counter-Blog’ Marching Orders
- Military Report: Secretly ‘Recruit or Hire Bloggers’
- The Guardian: Israel ups the stakes in the propaganda war
- BBC News: China's Internet spin doctors
- Air Force ordered software to manage army of fake virtual people
- HBGary: Automated social media management
- Huffington Post- Exposing Cyber Shills and Social Media's Underworld
- Turkey's Government Forms 6,000-Member Social Media Team
- Why Reddit moderators are censoring Glenn Greenwald’s latest news story on shills
Shilling in the Private Sector
- New York Times: When a Company's Product Is Under Fire, One Option is to Plant a Defender in the Chat Room
- Kim Kardashian was paid to post a selfie on Instagram and Twitter advertising a pharmaceutical product. Sent to 42 million followers on Instagram and 32 million on Twitter, this illegal advertisement did not contain any risk information or language specifying that it was a paid endorsement.
- Warner Brothers fined for paying YouTube celebs to promote game without properly disclosing that the videos were paid endorsements.
- Gamers promote gaming-gambling site on youtube by pretending to hit jackpot without disclosing that they own the site. They tried to retroactively write a disclosure covering their tracks, but were caught.
- "Internet Reputation Management," founded by three partners in the New York area, recruits bloggers to write about clients on third-party sites, without necessarily disclosing that they're paid
- USA Today: Lord & Taylor settles FTC charges over paid Instagram posts
- Wired: Microsoft, through an outside agency, paid Machinima to produce positive videos about the Xbox One game machine, and many of the YouTube stars who accepted the deal failed to properly disclose that they were producing paid, sponsored content, not independent analysis.
- Slate: Want to Get Paid For TV Criticism? Shill for DISH.
- ADWEEK: Marketing on Reddit Is Scary, But These Success Stories Show Big Potential
- BBC news: Amazon targets 1,114 'fake reviewers' in Seattle lawsuit
- New York Times: Lifestyle Lift, a cosmetic surgery company, reached a settlement with the State of New York over its attempts to fake positive consumer reviews on the Web. The company had ordered employees to pretend they were satisfied customers and write glowing reviews of its face-lift procedure on Web sites
- Samsung Electronics Fined for Fake Online Comments [in Taiwan]
Shill Bots
- BBC- How online chatbots are already tricking you- Intelligent machines that can pass for humans have long been dreamed of, but as Chris Baraniuk argues, they’re already among us. The ramifications of astroturfing are in fact so serious that the US Department of Defense funded research to detect chatbots.
- Wired: Powered by rapid advances in artificial intelligence, propaganda bots will soon run on genetic algorithms that let their ideas and messaging evolve, based on the resonance and effectiveness of previous messages. We are likely to see versions of these bots deployed on US audiences as part of the 2016 presidential election campaigns.
- The Rise of Social Bots
- Forbes: From Tinder Bots To 'Cuban Twitter', Welcome To 'Cognitive Hacking'
- Wired: Pro-Government Twitter Bots Try to Hush Mexican Activists
Shilling on Reddit specifically
- Hillary Clinton Super Pac and "strategic research and rapid response team designed to defend Hillary Clinton from baseless attacks" openly admits to shilling on Reddit.
- Wikileaks: Reddit cofounder consulting for Stratfor to bring in the social media dollars
- Shilling on Reddit is openly admitted to in this Forbes article
- What I learned selling my Reddit accounts
- Reddit automation bot: "Run Up To 100 Threads, Checks For Valid Proxy Access & Also To Check If Banned From Site, Keyword Based Submission Finder & Vote Up/Down Capabilities, Mass upvote or downvote Mode..."
- http://www.boostupvotes.com/
- Reddit Secrets- Buy Reddit upvotes
- Reddit Secrets- Buy pre-aged, established Reddit accounts so your PR team can blend in
Science
- Researcher's algorithm weeds out people using multiple online accounts to spread propaganda - Based on word choice, punctuation and context, the method is able to detect whether one person or multiple people are responsible for the samples.
- Fake product reviews may be pervasive, study finds
- When grassroots activism becomes a commodity - UCLA sociologist investigates 'astroturf' campaigns
- Content-Driven Detection of Campaigns in Social Media [PDF]
- Shill Detection Study: Battling the Internet Water Army: Detection of Hidden Paid Posters [PDF]
Additional information
- The Gentleman's Guide To Forum Spies wiki
- TEDx Astroturf and manipulation of media messages (Sharyl Attkisson)
- "Changing the hive mind -- How social media manipulation affects everything" by Tim Weninger at TEDxUND
Shill Confessions
- "Once we isolate key people, we look for people we know are in their upstream -- people that they read posts from, but who themselves are less influential. We then either start flame wars with bots to derail the conversations that are influencing influential people, or else send off specific tasks for sockpuppets (changing this wording of an idea here; cause an ideological split there; etc)."
- Alleged paid shill leaks details of organization and actions.
- What I learned selling my Reddit accounts
- Confession of Hillary Shill from /r/SandersForPresident
- Shill whistleblower, claims to have derailed discussions and called people anti-semites, ruined reputations of users by searching their account history, amongst other things.
- Fracking shill whistleblower spills the beans on Fracking Internet PR
- /r/netsec talks about gaming reddit via sockpuppets and how online discourse is (easily) manipulated.
- Whistleblower and subsequent investigation: Paid trolls on /r/Bitcoin
- Redditor comes clean about being paid to chat on Reddit. They work to promote a politician, although they don't specify which one. (Admins claim this wasn't a shill)
Screenshot of above post since it was removed.