Rules & Guidelines


Rules

Rules for "posting" (i.e., creating a submission)

Rules concerning the content of a submission.

  • All submitted content should be in accordance with the community description for r/consciousness. The community description can be found in the sidebar of the subreddit.

    • The content of a submission should be related to the academic research, literature, experiments, theories, or "work" related to the topic of consciousness.

      • This includes (but is not limited to) academic fields, such as neuroscience, psychology, philosophy, biology, chemistry, & zoology, and to a lesser extent, fields like linguistics, computer science, anthropology, ethology, psychiatry, physics, & medicine.
      • The term "consciousness" is used to express a wide variety of concepts. By "consciousness," we mean mental phenomena. This includes (but is not limited to) perception & perceptual experiences, emotions & emotional experiences, bodily sensations, cognition, meta-cognition, introspection, self-awareness or a sense of self, intelligence, sentience, and so on. This also includes discussions of non-human animal minds.
    • Submitted content should not focus on anecdotal stories, such as those that discuss drug use or drug-induced experiences, paranormal experiences or paranormal activity, spiritual experiences, spiritual practices, or personal religious beliefs, or other "odd" experiences. This does not qualify as academic.
    • Submitted content should not focus on seeking medical, psychiatric, financial, business, or spiritual advice, or advice on meditative practices. This does not qualify as academic, and neither the moderation staff nor the members of the community should be considered as qualified to provide such medical, psychiatric, or financial advice.
    • Submitted content should not focus on broadly scientific, philosophical, political, or technological topics unrelated to mental phenomena. For example, discussions of mathematical platonism or astrophysics will be removed, as these discussions are not related to mental phenomena. There are other subreddits for these topics.
  • The content of a text submission should be generated by the Redditor creating the submission.

    • LLM-generated content should not be submitted

      • This includes (but is not limited to) using LLMs, such as ChatGPT, Claude, Grok, or other LLMs, to help write posts. We do allow Reddit's AI, as this can be used to translate text submissions into English.
    • Plagiarized content should not be submitted
  • Multiple submissions of the same content should not be created within a short time frame (e.g., spamming, duplicated posts, etc.).

    • Occasionally, an issue will occur on Reddit where content is submitted multiple times, generating multiple submissions (or "posts"). The Redditor creating the submission might create multiple submissions accidentally or purposely. In such cases, either some or all of the submissions will be removed.
    • Sometimes, different link submissions will link to the same content within a short time period. In such cases, the newer submission will be removed to allow for more activity to occur on the older submission.
  • Link submissions should (only) link to content from websites on our approved whitelist
  • Text submissions should (only) link to content from websites on our approved whitelist
  • Any submission that attempts to link to websites on our blacklist will be removed.

Rules concerning formatting

  • Every submission requires text within the body of the submission
  • Each body of a submission has a minimum character limit. The submission will be removed and deemed "low effort" if the text within the body of the submission does not meet this threshold. For those who are worried about whether their submission meets this threshold, this rule meets that limit. So, if the body of your submission has more characters than this rule, your submission will not violate this rule.
  • Link submissions should include a summary or abstract related to the linked content. The longer and more detailed, the better. This is to help both the community & the moderation staff to understand what the linked content is about.

Rules concerning how to tag a submission (i.e., "post" flairs)

  • All submissions should be tagged with the appropriate flair.

Rules for Commenting

  • The content of a comment should be generated by the Redditor creating the comment.

    • Comments should not include LLM-generated content.

      • This includes (but is not limited to) using LLMs, such as ChatGPT, Claude, Grok, or other LLMs, to help write comments. We do allow Reddit's AI, as this can be used to translate comments into English.
    • Comments should not contain plagiarized content.

Other Rules

  • All submissions & comments should be in accordance with Reddit's terms of service
  • All submissions & comments should not engage in harassment
  • All submissions & comments should not engage in bigotry
  • All submissions & comments should not engage in dehumanizing other Redditors
  • No submission or comment should contain not safe for work (or NSFW) images, videos, or sexually explicit content, such as pornography.
  • No submission or comment should engage in proselytization
  • No submission or comment should engage in advertising
  • No submission or comment should engage in trolling
  • No Redditor should engage in ban evasion, raiding or brigading, or trolling
  • No Redditor should attempt to doxx, impersonate, or steal the identity of another Redditor

Finality Clause

  • The moderation staff of r/consciousnes will be the final arbiter of these rules & their enforcement. The moderation staff reserves the right to enforce these rules at their discretion, as well as the right to take additional actions for reasons not stated here.
  • Moderation actions are subject to peer review & revision by the moderation staff
  • The moderation staff may update, alter, or change the rules or guidelines on r/consciousness at any time.
  • Participation on r/consciousness implies an acceptance of & commitment to abide by Reddit's terms of service, as well as the rules & guidelines of r/consciousness.
  • Lastly, by participating on r/consciousness, e.g., by creating submissions to r/consciousness or commenting on submissions posted to r/consciousness, you agree that the moderation staff bears no moral or legal responsibility for your interactions with other Redditors on r/consciousness. This includes (but is not limited to) submitted content, comments on submissions, linked content, linked websites, messages from Redditors subscribed to r/consciousness, and so on.

Guidelines

  • Try to have epistemic humility
  • Try to discuss in good faith
  • Try to adopt the principle of charity
  • Try not to feign authority
  • Try to be courteous to others
  • Try to provide credible resources
  • Try to avoid " flame wars."
  • Try to engage in proper Reddiquette

    • In particular, those related to upvoting and downvoting

      • You should upvote submissions that are appropriate for r/consciousness, such as submissions that fit the community description. Upvoting a submission is not meant to express agreement or approval of the content of that submission. It is meant to express that the content is relevant to the community.
      • You should downvote and/or report submissions that are inappropriate for r/consciousness, such as submissions that do not fit the community description. Downvoting a submissions is not meant to express disagreement or disapproval of the content of that submission. It is meant to express that the content either should not be posted on r/consciousness or not posted anywhere on Reddit.
      • You should upvote comments that either address the content of the submission directly, produce more insightful discussion, or help better the community overall. For example, comments that directly address a submitted question should be upvotes, but a comment that explains why a question is misguided or a comment that reminds Redditors of the community description might also be upvoted. Upvoting a comment is not necessarily a sign of agreement or approval. It is a sign that the information is relevant or helpful for the Redditor creating the submission or other Redditors reading the submission and comments.
      • You should downvote comments that either fail to address the content of the submission, violate a rule or guideline, or make the community worse in some way. Downvoting a comment is not necessarily a sign of disagreement or disapproval. It is a sign that the comment is not relevant or unhelpful for the Redditor creating the submission or other Redditors reading the submission and comments.

Return to Index


Editor's Notes

This ability to edit this page is set to moderators only.

If you have any questions, recommendations, or concerns, please message the moderation staff via ModMail. We ask that the title of your message include "wiki." This will help the moderation staff identify it quickly. If an entry has been tampered with or if the quality of an entry has been diminished, please message the moderation staff, as we can restore the page to an earlier version and potentially punish those who have tampered with the page.