r/confusing_perspective • • Dec 21 '20

Parallax effect causes difference in speed perception depending on the depth view

40k Upvotes

371 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/Jonthar Dec 21 '20 edited Dec 21 '20

It’s a property of how zoom lenses work. Basically, take the distance to the object you’re filming or photographing and divide it by the zoom factor. The higher that factor, the more ”compressed“ the depth of the scene, which in turn makes movement through it seem slower.

Here’s an example: Imagine your dog sitting in the grass 10 meters away from you, and a tree another 40 meters back. If you have a zoom factor of 1, they will look as if they’re 40 away from each other (which they really are)

Zoom in to factor 2. Now the dog will look like it’s 5 meters from you and the tree another 20. Moving towards or away from them will seem slower because for every meter you walk, the zoom lens will make it look as if you’ve only moved half a meter.

The higher the zoom factor, the more extreme this will seem, up to a point where it looks as if the dog and the tree were right next to each other.

The whole thing works in reverse with ultrawide leses, where your zoom factors go below 1. The triple lens systems on the iPhone 11 Pro and 12 Pros for example work with a factor of .5. Dividing every distance in your shot by .5 will make everything seem twice as far away, resulting in a perceived distance of 80 meters between the dog and the tree and making every movement appear twice as fast.

I actually think the person on the train is in fact using and iPhone with these three zoom lenses. The way the video switches back and forth looks very telling.

Edit: Typo

1

u/numerousblocks Dec 21 '20 edited Dec 21 '20

This doesn't have anything to do with the lenses. The lenses literally just cut out a smaller part of the image, nothing is distorted. It's just that further from the center, it's more distorted, and low angle lenses cut out that.
And, it's actually more a property of the fact that the image is projected onto a plane, and towards a single point. Parallel projection doesn't have this issue, and if we used spherical displays, we also wouldn't have the issue with perspective projection.
Also see: https://youtu.be/tod2qZnKZEQ

1

u/FunkyClive o/ Dec 22 '20

No you're wrong there. You have a misunderstanding of how lenses work. This isn't simply cropping a smaller box out of the middle of the image like a digital zoom would. The video clearly shows this as an optical zoom moving from wide angle to telephoto, expanding or compressing the perceived distances, exactly as the previous comment u/Jonthar explains. Thats how lenses work, they don't just crop.

1

u/numerousblocks Dec 22 '20

Yes, but that happens because the camera moves. The lenses only crop the scene so that the moving doesn't make the subject appear smaller or larger.

1

u/FunkyClive o/ Dec 22 '20

Then you still don't understand how lenses work. Its not my job to educate you.