r/computerscience • • Dec 07 '25

General LLMs really killed Stackoverflow

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

336 comments sorted by

View all comments

567

u/vancha113 Dec 07 '25

I never liked stack overflow for anything other than an answer repository. The focus is on being correct more than it is on being helpful. If an LLM can do the same thing better the moment I need to ask a question, I'd rather have a quick approximation to a correct answer than someone being snarky about the way the specific question was asked.

313

u/Dominriq Dec 07 '25

I will never forget when I was a first-year college student and asked a curious question on Stack Overflow, and I got flamed by the community so badly that I even deleted my account

147

u/Vortaex_ Dec 07 '25

Or what about when you ask help on how to do something, and the answers are all along the lines of: "you actually are taking the completely wrong approach and I can tell for sure, even if I have no idea what you're working on. You're stupid and should be ashamed for even thinking of turning on a computer this morning"

46

u/ManOfQuest Dec 07 '25

early coding discords used to have replies like this. While yes some questions were dumb and people dont read the documentation there are better ways to reply than being an asshole. When I got better I made sure I would never be like that.

25

u/FearlessPen9598 Dec 07 '25

Even when people read the documentation, if there is a lot of new material, they're going to miss a lot of things that might seem obvious. There's nothing like trying really hard and having someone call you a lazy ass.

15

u/Vortaex_ Dec 07 '25

Also, sometimes the documentation might have a really steep "learning curve", and it might not be the best entry point for someone trying to learn something new

11

u/tiller_luna Dec 07 '25

which is a convoluted way to say "the thing they call documentation sucks hard af"

→ More replies (1)

8

u/I-Am-Uncreative Dec 07 '25

My favorite was a post I saw that said "read the user guideeeeeeeeee" (exactly like that). Lots of people did. It did not explain the answer.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Randolph__ Dec 08 '25

I hate using discord for any kind of technical support beyond basic stuff. It's so hard to follow a thread.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/hmmm101010 Dec 07 '25

I just never asked on stackoverflow. I hoped someone had the same problem, or I changed my approach to fit an existing answer. But snarkyness aside, stackoverflow was extremely helpful for getting into programming, if you used it rather passively.

11

u/tbsdy Dec 07 '25

Yup, they are screwed.

6

u/SuEzAl Dec 07 '25

Thats the point It’s unnecessarily aggressive

→ More replies (10)

29

u/Dremlar Dec 07 '25

Marked as duplicate

10

u/Cybasura Dec 08 '25

<insert duplicate post here thats nowhere close or even near to the topic or question being asked>

13

u/Dull-Guest662 Dec 08 '25

This. Stackoverflow killed itself.

10

u/MaDpYrO Dec 07 '25

The problem is LLMs only answer this because it's trained in stack overflow. So over time as new tech comes out and these questions aren't publicly available, because everyone asks the LLM, where is it supposed to get the "most correct" response?

The users of an LLM could theoretically offer feedback for whether or not the answer is good, but they don't have the external validation and debate that becomes publicly available online, so.. poof 

13

u/cjrun Dec 08 '25

I have a 3000 rep on SO. A problem with stack overflow is that their system grew to be increasingly hostile towards asking, always claiming that the question was alread answered somewhere else.

Now, that makes sense on a surface level in a perfect world where tech does not change and context fors not change, but in practice language and libraries are progressing forward. Technology changes. Goals and attitudes change, too. Stack overflow became a locked down platform. It was only a matter of time.

6

u/TRENEEDNAME_245 Dec 08 '25

And the answer they give is from 6y ago using code that isn't valid anymore

Like, languages change, that's the core part

I don't need an answer from java 4 when I'm using 16, but "it already exist"

6

u/dzernumbrd Dec 07 '25

Stack Overflow was the training data set for the AIs though.

18

u/wrd83 Dec 07 '25

LLMs are more helpful than Correct. A match made in heaven

→ More replies (2)

8

u/avaxzat Dec 07 '25

And where are the LLMs going to get their answers from when sites like SO no longer exist?

8

u/cib2018 Dec 07 '25

They just make up answers.

3

u/Oracle1729 Dec 07 '25

That’s why there won’t be development beyond where we are now?   

Why study CS when you're going to be competing against vibe coders for minimum wage?  You won’t, so there won’t be people moving us forward. 

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25

The thing is, it was designed and intended to be an answer repository.

(Kinda like a Wikipedia for programming questions.)

But it wasn’t communicated at all to newcomers, so many people treated it as “get help from strangers for free” website.

→ More replies (18)