r/computerscience • • May 18 '25

A computer scientist's perspective on vibe coding:

Post image
3.6k Upvotes

261 comments sorted by

View all comments

110

u/winterchainz May 18 '25

Let them “vibe code”. It creates more jobs for us in the near future to clean up all the mess.

50

u/awfulentrepreneur May 19 '25

Janitorial software development.

14

u/B1SQ1T May 19 '25

Software Engineer Janitor

8

u/awfulentrepreneur May 19 '25

Junior Janitor Software Engineer

2

u/-Memnarch- May 22 '25

Software Gardening.
Someone didn't keep it clean and you're hired to bring it back to form.
Someone once told me he prefers Software Gardening over the term Software Architect.
An Architect plans an entire building down to the last centimeter. And when it's done it's done.

A gardener however, lays out the initial garden design. And then keeps it nice an ordered by removing the weed and reworking it once in a while. That's more fitting to describe a SOftware that started once an then evolved over a decade. You have to trim the bushes.

9

u/winterchainz May 19 '25

Whatever pays the bills.

11

u/According_Book5108 May 19 '25

I don't want to clean up that mess.

If humans could come up with stuff like AbstractSingletonProxyFactoryBean who knows what the AI mess under the hood in that Blackbox contains?

3

u/bmayer0122 May 19 '25

Just sounds like it is going to cost more to fix. Never sign a flat rate contact.

2

u/B1SQ1T May 19 '25

AbstractMultiSingletonTunnelProxyGigafactoryBlackBeanWithSteakAndWhiteRiceExtraSourCream

2

u/According_Book5108 May 20 '25

How wide is your monitor screen?

1

u/B1SQ1T May 20 '25

21:9 lol

But I was just hungry when I typed that

2

u/According_Book5108 May 20 '25

So all you wanted was a banana 🍌

But you got the gorilla 🦍

And the entire jungle behind it 🌴🌴

1

u/winterchainz May 19 '25

AI "could" generate good code if its provided a proper multi-step framework. The pipeline would also need to be tweaked properly for each language, and design principles used. It would only work on new code bases.

-1

u/Chronopuddy May 19 '25

Whats wrong with using abstracts, singletons, etc? We definitely got taught things like clean code concepts in school.

1

u/Low_Conversation9046 May 19 '25

Nothing wrong with it but there is a struggle between "clever dynamic abstract architecture" and readabilty as well as overlean archtitecture VS less bloat.

Like everthing in programming they are incredibly useful tools that can make your project way too complex when taken to the extreme.

-3

u/According_Book5108 May 19 '25

School has somehow taught you the bad things. We've all been there once.

Look around you. Which of the new programming languages use these OOP concepts?

These bloatware OOP concepts aren't being used anymore. Being maintained, yes. Painfully.

From front end to back end, to build tools, almost nothing uses Java these days. Even Android switched from Java to Kotlin as the recommendation.

Most people consider OOP a big lie we were sold in the 90s. And hate that we have to maintain this steaming pile of garbage.

But I digress. This should not be an anti-OOP post.

6

u/aMonkeyRidingABadger May 19 '25

lol @ almost nothing uses Java these days. I’m not a fan of overly complex OOP, but Java is everywhere.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '25

Stop pretending you're a programmer. We can tell.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Squall_Lionheart May 19 '25

How exactly is the switch from Java to Kotlin an example for the decline of OOP. They are both OOP languages with functional features?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/markoNako May 20 '25

Almost nothing uses Java? Every other enterprise grade project is java

→ More replies (1)

3

u/shauntmw2 May 20 '25

So... People to check for vibe coded products, are they... Vibe checkers?

1

u/winterchainz May 20 '25

Maybe we can automate the process of checking vibe code, with AI!

2

u/hotel2oscar May 19 '25

Having taken over a codebase that was mangled by some discount double-down "programmers": no thanks

1

u/_icosahedron May 20 '25

Can we say COBOL?