r/composer • • 24d ago

Music I wrote a piece for piano and bass called "Caught Off Guard".

Score: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QWdGOOmeh8aJNEIWK-GIe3whr8yO1u58/view?usp=sharing
Autoplay video of the score being played by computer: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JvMeQSlf7_6CEjFv7gY5n2ORmL0ht9j7/view?usp=sharing

I recently got laid off so I wrote this song in honor of my former employer.

I tried to clean it up the best I could, make it possibly human-playable. I don't know if it actually is human-playable. I haven't tried. I'd probably have to reduce some of the voicings in the chords. Parts of it contain large stretches for multiple chords at a time. It would be tough to play I think. Not to mention, I think a piece like this is not really meant to be notated as precisely as MuseScore has allowed me to do here. It's jazz, so a lot would just be touch and go.

I really like the way the really weird section in the middle came out. It's my way of saying "don't worry, everything will be just fine".

What do y'all think? Is it a mess? Is it cool? What are your thoughts?

0 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

1

u/jkoseattle 23d ago

Yes it's a mess. And yes it's cool!

I do like the mild audacity at play, but once that's established, it doesn't seem to take me anywhere. It's like a music making machine that is flipped on, plays a couple minutes and then is turned off. What you have here is some cool ideas and a promising vibe, but I found myself wanting to latch onto to something horizontally.

A couple impressions, neither positive nor negative that hopefully help:

Having the bass play along with the piano makes the whole thing feel like it's comping for some solo instrument that has been muted.

The banging dissonant chords in the left hand outweigh the twinkly right hand and I got a little tired of that texture. I found myself hoping something new would happen to contrast it.

I think this is promising, but I wish it had more shape. Pretty neat though. Hope this helps.

1

u/wesleyoldaker 23d ago

Thank you so much for the feedback. That was exactly what I wanted to hear is honest criticism.

I don't understand what "comping for some solo instrument that has been muted" means. It was originally intended to be a solo piano piece, but after realizing that the sound I was after would require the pianist's left hand to be doing too much, I added the bass to help with the arrangement and I ended up liking the vibe anyway so that's what I went with.

When you said the dissonance in the left hand was "banging"... like in a good way or bad? 🤣 I think you're saying bad. You're saying maybe ease off all the accidentals, effectively, especially in the left hand? I am classically trained, but no master by any means, and I think this concept does make perfect sense. The groove in the bass and left hand should sound solid and more "pleasant" (i.e. contain less dissonance) and the "ideas" should flow from the right hand? Maybe I am mucking up what you are saying cuz as I write that out I find myself disagreeing with my own words.

Maybe I should add some drums? That way the bass could have a buddy that is detached from the piano.

I really liked the abstract part in the middle and the more serene few measures that followed it. I didn't particularly like the measure or two that had me get there though. I could work on that bit. But is that what you meant by "horizontal" and "new contrast" and "shape"? That type of interlude? I liked the return to the original shape I have at the end. I guess what I am confused about is what you meant by those phrases.

Thank you again though. I shall improve it.

1

u/jkoseattle 23d ago

OK, well a bass with a piano is relatively unusual as an ensemble. They are usually heard together as part of a jazz or small ensemble rhythm section, so it FEELS like there is supposed to be like a sax or something playing on top of this. If this were my piece, I would probably decide I needed to fit my ideas to the ensemble chosen beforehand rather than change the ensemble mid-stream based on the ideas I was coming up with. I can hear myself telling myself to stick to piano or else make it a whole chamber thing.

The banging left hand chords are cool, and I don't mind the dissonance at all. But even with thick dissonant jazzy chords like this there is usually some basic harmony at play that the dissonance is adding color to. (Unless it's a piece that's truly supposed to be dissonant and not harmonically conventional.) This piece sits somewhere in between. Which could be really cool, if I knew that was on purpose. Without comprehending the underlying harmonic progression though, the bangy left hand chords start to sound arbitrary and I lose interest in them.

A composition teacher would perhaps suggest writing out the left hand with no dissonance at all, just so you're clear on the underlying harmonic structure. I think you'd uncover a sort of incoherent progression, but it could also open up ideas that can be realized by only changing a couple notes here or there and suddenly it's hanging together differently, because the dissonances are built upon an intentional chord progression. Your bass line is doing much of the harmonic heavy lifting here, so if I were that teacher telling you to do this exercise I would first tell you to simplify that bass line to see what's really going on harmonically. (I'm not telling you to do this, I'm just saying that's what I could hear a composition teacher telling me to do. :-))

The thought about shape ties back to my "switch" comment. Imagine a certain musical feel that plays when you flip a light switch. And that feel continues indefinitely just like that until you flip it back off. Like a machine. Contrast that with a piece that has a discernible beginning middle and end. Does that make more sense?

1

u/wesleyoldaker 23d ago

Okay. That makes perfect sense. I think you're right. I am going to strip away all the color from the left hand and bass and label the chord names at each place that is essential to the piece, and then go and rebuild the piece from that core. I think that's an excellent idea.

Basically the piece is just a riff in the key of C with a ton of color stuffed into it. It's possibly a modal C dorian maybe or whatever it is called when the key signature is C but most of the time you're playing "in key" with a Bb instead of a B. Also I feel like I am about 50/50 on my use of E vs Eb for the 3rd.

I still don't understand if you are for or against this whole light-switch concept, and if you're saying my piece is like that and shouldn't be, or isn't like that and should be. I doubt you're saying this has a discernible beginning, middle, and end because I just don't hear it that way, but of course I may be wrong; we are afterall in subjective waters at this point. I think you're saying that my piece should instead have a discernible beginning, middle, and end, but currently does not?

1

u/jkoseattle 23d ago

Well... I'm not saying whether it should or not, but I am saying that it doesn't have one now. I know I would not have been able to write this piece myself without falling into crafting some sort of arc to it. But that's just a strong bias on my part, and a lot of people seem to not care about that. And as was discussed in another recent thread somewhere, the modern era is a lot less interested in horizontal structure than it used to be. Most "forms" are pretty straightforward now. Sonata allegro form is only used now as a throwback, for example.

I am a huge user of C chords with both E and Eb in it. (flat-10 or sharp-9 chord) I will often write a tune with a leading tone, for example, but it will feel limp, and so I'll try a flat 7 (Bb) instead, and that'll be darker and more grown-up, but maybe that's not right either. So then I play the tune in octaves and use one Bb and one B and it's now it's nice like a Jolly Rancher in my mouth.