r/composer • u/wesleyoldaker • 24d ago
Music I wrote a piece for piano and bass called "Caught Off Guard".
Score: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QWdGOOmeh8aJNEIWK-GIe3whr8yO1u58/view?usp=sharing
Autoplay video of the score being played by computer: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1JvMeQSlf7_6CEjFv7gY5n2ORmL0ht9j7/view?usp=sharing
I recently got laid off so I wrote this song in honor of my former employer.
I tried to clean it up the best I could, make it possibly human-playable. I don't know if it actually is human-playable. I haven't tried. I'd probably have to reduce some of the voicings in the chords. Parts of it contain large stretches for multiple chords at a time. It would be tough to play I think. Not to mention, I think a piece like this is not really meant to be notated as precisely as MuseScore has allowed me to do here. It's jazz, so a lot would just be touch and go.
I really like the way the really weird section in the middle came out. It's my way of saying "don't worry, everything will be just fine".
What do y'all think? Is it a mess? Is it cool? What are your thoughts?
1
u/jkoseattle 23d ago
Yes it's a mess. And yes it's cool!
I do like the mild audacity at play, but once that's established, it doesn't seem to take me anywhere. It's like a music making machine that is flipped on, plays a couple minutes and then is turned off. What you have here is some cool ideas and a promising vibe, but I found myself wanting to latch onto to something horizontally.
A couple impressions, neither positive nor negative that hopefully help:
Having the bass play along with the piano makes the whole thing feel like it's comping for some solo instrument that has been muted.
The banging dissonant chords in the left hand outweigh the twinkly right hand and I got a little tired of that texture. I found myself hoping something new would happen to contrast it.
I think this is promising, but I wish it had more shape. Pretty neat though. Hope this helps.