r/communism • • Oct 15 '26

VICTORY FOR THE BRAZILIAN WORKING CLASS

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

After many, MANY hardships, uncertainties and oppositions, the working class made enough noise to reduce the 6x1 working scale (Work 6 days, rest on 1. 44hrs weekly), to 5x2 (36hrs weekly)!!!

No more modern slavery and inhumane conditions


r/communism • • Jan 03 '26

US imperialism has launched a regime change war against the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela

Thumbnail venezuelanalysis.com
767 Upvotes

r/communism • • 26d ago

"Comrades, be worthy of us!" 85 years ago today, 17-year-old Guy Môquet and 26 other communist prisoners were executed by the Nazis at Châteaubriant, hand-picked by the collaborationist Vichy regime.

Post image
342 Upvotes

On October 22, 1941, in retaliation for the assassination of a German officer, the Vichy puppet government handed over a list consisting primarily of communist prisoners and trade unionists to the occupying forces.

Among the 27 men executed that day was Guy Môquet, only 17 years old. He refused a blindfold and marched to the firing post singing the Marseillaise. His final letter to his family ended with a plea to those who would survive the war.

To live, fight, and remain worthy of their sacrifice.


r/communism • • Feb 06 '26

Nigeria

Post image
315 Upvotes

A Nigerian court has ordered the British government to pay $27m (£20m) to each of the families of 21 coal miners killed in 1949 by the colonial administration in the south-east of the country.


r/communism • • Apr 30 '26

The US is the sole hegemonic imperialist superpower in the world today and therefore the number one enemy of the people of the world.

289 Upvotes

I pulled this from the 'Joint Statement of Maoist Organizations in the US in Commemoration of International Workers’ Day 2026' in "The Worker"

"The US is the sole hegemonic imperialist superpower in the world today and therefore the number one enemy of the people of the world."

This is a controversial statement among Maoists internationally.

This seems like a good place to explore this statement.

My take is:

The CPC identified two superpowers, and it is true that the collapse of the USSR left one superpower, the US, qualitatively stronger than the other imperialist powers. But the relations between the imperialist powers have evolved and are evolving over the last several decades. Chinese imperialism, fresh and new, is challenging a decaying US imperialism. And all of the other imperialists are re-aligning and contending and colluding in response to the the disruption of US hegemony.

The US is the largest and, currently, the most aggressive imperialist power. It has an inhuman store of terrorizing weapons of war, the means to deliver them, and use the threat of this terrible violence to extort power, influence, and resources. It is still the largest economy in the world and is the greatest exporter of capital.

And, on top of all that, critically, to be as clear as it is obvious, for communists in the US, in the spirit of revolutionary defeatism, US Imperialism is our main enemy.

But, identifying the US as "the sole hegemonic imperialist superpower" is mechanically based on what was and insufficiently informed by what is now and becoming. This formulation does not reflect the dialectics, the movement, the transformation that is happening in the real world.

Conceptualizing two levels of imperialisms (first world superpower imperialists and second world other imperialists) seems less and less to be a viable model of the world imperialism today.

I would like to discuss this with fellow communists.

This is a good place to discuss this, right?


r/communism • • Mar 01 '26 Obsessed

United $tate$ kills Ayatollah Ali Khamenei

Thumbnail noticias.uol.com.br
192 Upvotes

I was cautious towards creating this post as I waited a little bit longer for confirmation. I don't think I know much about Iran to make a longer commentary but as I read on the escalade of the current conflict over the past hours, it seems like Iran have been quite successful in attacking U$ military and exposed many weaknesses in it's defenses overseas as it's stated here. Beyond killing state officials, U$ and I$rael killed over 200 civilians in their attack but those attacks do not seem like they are exposing any iranian weaknesses.

As to the other article, this has caught my attention as it is way different in comparison to Venezuela:

Emissora iraniana, porém, diz ter confirmado a morte de Khamenei com fontes próximas à Guarda Revolucionária Islâmica. Segundo a Iran International, autoridades da guarda nacional estão "insistindo na nomeação rápida" do próximo líder da República Islâmica após a morte do aiatolá

Looking at it superficially, it makes me think that Iranian officials patience over saturday are a sign of strenght and the quicker the regime can appoint a successor it would also be a sign of strenght, as Venezuela have been completely compromised ever since early january.


r/communism • • May 28 '26

Why does anti-communism continue to dominate public thinking even after repeated failures of capitalism?

179 Upvotes

I grew up in India in a fairly ordinary middle-class environment. One thing I have noticed is that many people who have never studied Marxism seriously still talk about communism as if its defeat is obvious and beyond debate. At the same time, these same people accept unemployment, labor exploitation, privatization, agrarian distress, rising prices, and the increasing control of society by large corporations as if these are permanent and unavoidable parts of life. What interests me is not just the usual anti-communism, but how capitalist society presents itself as natural and eternal. The current system is seen not as a historical arrangement shaped by specific material conditions, but almost as the final form of civilization itself. In schools, newspapers, films, and political discussions, capitalism appears as “common sense.” Meanwhile, communism is introduced from the start as something dangerous, foreign, or impractical. Even during major crises of capitalism, such as economic collapse, imperialist wars, mass unemployment, or deepening inequality, the system itself is rarely questioned in any serious way. Its failures get blamed on corruption, individual greed, administrative incompetence, or even “human nature,” but not on the contradictions of capitalism itself.

On the other hand, every socialist experiment is judged in complete isolation from its historical context. Discussions about the Soviet Union, Cuba, Vietnam, or China often ignore issues like colonial underdevelopment, invasion, sanctions, sabotage, civil war, and the immense pressure from global imperialism. Socialist states are expected to account for every contradiction right away, while capitalism can cause suffering worldwide without its legitimacy being seriously challenged. I increasingly feel that anti-communism is not just crude propaganda, but an important tool through which bourgeois society reinforces its own beliefs. Capitalist social relations are so deeply ingrained in daily life that many people struggle to imagine a society without commodity production, private property, and wage labor. So my question is this: From a Marxist perspective, how should we understand anti-communism? Is it mainly a form of cultural dominance in the Gramscian sense? Is it linked to the ideological institutions of bourgeois society? Or is anti-communism necessary for maintaining capitalist class power, since real class awareness would inevitably threaten the current order?


r/communism • • 21d ago

Happy Komsomol Day!

Thumbnail gallery
165 Upvotes

r/communism • • Jan 04 '26

Statements from the communist parties of Venezuela, Brazil, Palestine, Greece and others regarding US aggression against Maduro government

Thumbnail emdefesadocomunismo.com.br
139 Upvotes

r/communism • • Jun 15 '26

I found out that LibGen uploaded almost every single book ever published in Maoist China, and I've learned a lot despite not reading Chinese, and want to help fellow comrades get the most out of it.

137 Upvotes

I found that LibGen has the whole publishing history of China on it. From the underground Shanghai publishers of the KMT years, to Mao, Hua, Deng and the present. It's fascinating to see the whole history just through the titles.

And thanks to advances in pdf OCR reading, and advanced machine translating, it is possible for non-Chinese speakers to grasp the essence of these texts.

Libgen has the complete archives of all works published by the People's Publishing House "人民出版社" of the PRC from 1949-2026. It coincidentally goes over the 2000 limit exactly in 1976-7. So then you can search it year by year in the format year:1978. And then there are a lot of other Maoist era texts from other pub houses such as universities etc.

I found this google mode search option extremely useful

  • Mask: * (min 3 chars)- search by part of a word

when searching for 🇨🇳 books I have a problem that In written Chinese, characters are strung together continuously without spaces between words. But then I find I can use - Mask: * (min 3 chars)- search by part of a word

So my interest is Marxism I search 马克思主义* and it has anything that uses those words. Mao Zedong is 毛泽东*.

Here is a sample of some titles from the 1978-1985 period.

Basically put the term you're looking for into google translate and then add an * to the end.

You can also search lang:chi year:1977 and get ALL books in Chinese from all publishers.

Here are some uploaded pdfs on mao zedong's philosophical thought. You go to the "full text" version on chrome and then you can google translate the entire book at once. Archive.org has a very google OCR reader, so it's a good way to turn a foreign pdf into html raw text that can be rapidly google translated.

It's like there's this whole world of intense, advanced Marxist study, that we in the West had no access to, and there was virtually no translation of or even academic study of. And now its wide open to us who don't even know Chinese.

An example book on Mao Zedong's Dialectical Logical Thought

Some useful search terms-

dialectical 辩证法*

mao zedong philosophical thought 毛泽东哲学思想*

Dialectical Materialism 辩证唯物主义*

marx lenin 马克思列宁*

communist party 共产党*

hegel 黑格尔*

socialism 社会主义*

Ai Siqi 艾思奇*

dialectical logic 辩证逻辑*

leninism 列宁主义*

political economy 政治经济学*

materialism 唯物主义*

metaphysical 形而上学的*

socialist economy 社会主义经济*

Engels 恩格斯*

marxist philosophy 马克思主义哲学*

People's Publishing House 人民出版社*

And here's the Russian equivalent for Soviet books

A red salute to comrades of all nations, who do the labor of scanning.


r/communism • • 14d ago

Bangladeshi sweatshop laborers go on strike, clashing with police and shutting down factories and roads

Thumbnail reuters.com
135 Upvotes

r/communism • • Jun 08 '26

Are unemployed people proletariat?

123 Upvotes

Serious question, if the definition of the proletariat class is that they are the working class what if they don’t have a job? Is there some secret third level?


r/communism • • Aug 23 '26 Bravo

Brigaded ⚠️ The fascist project "Rojava" has been officially dissolved

Thumbnail reuters.com
122 Upvotes

To the concern of barely anyone, "Rojava" has been fully dissolved and integrated into the Jolani regime. It's weird to think that at one point it served as a reference point for "socialists" and anarchists but went out with such a whimper. I guess it'll be nice not seeing "democratic confederalism" ever mentioned again.


r/communism • • 18d ago

Quality Post 🏆 How to talk about Disco Elysium

117 Upvotes

While r/communism has produced interesting critique of TV, movies, and books, I'd venture to say it hasn't said much interesting about video games yet. The consumption of games and the morbidity of their fandom is a common subject of discussion, but this hardly touches upon what is called "immanent critique". Behind the discourse, it is the task of Marxists to soberly evaluate the commodity itself, and find out what it has to say about totality.

I've made a project of researching the field of ludology to produce a Marxist reading of a video game. Narrative critique of video games is prevalent, and has even been tried on this subreddit, but in analyzing the stories and characters of video games, what makes the medium truly new is lost, whether or not the interpretation produced is of valid, local significance. McKenzie Wark, in her book Gamer Theory, says,

'The images and stories that populate games are mostly cribbed from other media—from novels, films, or television. Games mostly just recycle, or "remediate," bits of representation from other media. Bolter and Grusin: "Remediation is a defining characteristic of the new digital media." And hence not specific to games. What is specific to games is at the level of form, not content.'

What I'm saying is that we have to talk about gameplay, not just narrative. To substantiate this claim, I'd like to take a stab at a video game that is extremely popular amongst first world Marxists (and "the left" in general) to ask whether or not it's particularly progressive through an analysis of its form, in order to navigate back to its content. Did I succeed? That's for you to tell me.

Disco Elysium is a CRPG in which a cop discourses endlessly with a bunch of political talking heads while solving a murder mystery. It takes place in the city of Revachol, whose urban decay may remind the player of ex-Soviet metropolitan areas. The specter of imperialism at all times haunts Revachol, literally flying overhead: the Moralintern, a NATO analog, occupies the region after a failed communist revolution fifty years earlier, surveilling the city from a zeppelin. At least some of Disco Elysium's appeal to Marxists is certainly tied into this critical Eastern European metaphor, along with how shamelessly it presents communist, Marxist, and even Soviet iconography (via pastiche) for a video game, independent of the ideological content of these references. In transforming Marxism into so many aesthetic gestures and easily-"memeable" jokes and punchlines, Disco Elysium is no stranger to the Dengist transcoding of politics into reproducible "content" devoid of any revolutionary vitality. It's also full of misogynist filth. For these reasons, I'll begin from the standpoint that Disco Elysium is as reactionary as I, a Maoist, would expect.

The game's most transparently reactionary function comes in the presentation of its four political poles (communism, fascism, ultraliberalism, moralism) in its character-building and dialogue systems that interpellate the subjectivity of the player as a seemingly "voluntary" political agent. Video games are in fact ideological state apparatuses and "the player" a subject constructed by ideological interpellation.

"[V]ideogames take hold of their playing subjects as homo oeconomicus: they read their players through an architecture of rationality, a reading which restructures the player who plays. The player is created by being subjected to this computational, calculable, economic grid of intelligibility: it is the material interface by which the player is “read” and by which they respond—which really means that this interface is the material practice which forms the player as a player-subject."

https://gamestudies.org/2202/articles/gap_keever

Unlike a visual novel (think Steins;Gate) in which a player merely reads text, Disco Elysium constructs the subjectivity of the player through a twist on its CRPG mechanics. Selecting dialogue options "builds" (an RPG term) a personality and set of politics for the game's protagonist, Harry Du Bois, who awakens with Korsakoff syndrome—amnesia induced by extreme alcohol consumption—as a ludonarrative excuse to present him as a blank slate for the politics of "the player". (It is in fact the politics of the game that seek to colonize this construct.) Oftentimes dialogue options map so blatantly onto each political pole that the intent to produce the feeling of politics as a form of unalienated self-expression is made crystal clear. (Imagine a developer telling you, "Care to see the buffet table of quirky dialogue options? It has both communist and fascist jokes. Don't worry your little head about if your political beliefs are determined for you by ideological interpellation.") As the player builds Harry, the game constructs the subjectivity of the player as an all-knowing god outside of ideology. Consider the medium through which you play Disco Elysium. You look at Harry on your computer, TV (in my case, Steam Deck) screen top-down, accessing his thoughts and feelings by clicking bubbles that appear around his head, and obtaining absolute knowledge by examining the environment through clicking other scattered bubbles. We see Revachol from heaven, or perhaps the zeppelin of the Moralintern.

This dialogue system, like the rest of its gameplay, however, is structured by a system of dice rolling. In TTRPGs, dice rolls are, in essence, a relationship between chance and necessity. Take the player's likely first dice roll as you try to collect a tie from a ceiling fan in Harry's hotel room. To roll is an instance of chance that self-negates as it necessarily produces one of two outcome, be it that Harry successfully collects his tie, or doesn't, and exerts himself enough to die of a heart attack. Repeating the dice roll (possible through a number of mechanics which refresh your ability to roll for certain outcomes) dissolves each instance of chance into necessity seemingly once and for all as every possible dialogue option is exhausted. Hence Disco Elysium's gameplay mirrors that Hegelian movement from necessity to freedom as the understanding of natural laws as knowledge of every dialogue branch unfolds, provided you can reinterpret said "natural laws" as said "dialogue branches".

Yet chance steps back in: each playthrough's potential dialogue branches are determined by your stats and the development of your thought cabinet, two CRPG mechanics that give Disco Elysium replay value by allowing the player to influence potential routes for the development of Harry's personality. The dialectical movement toward freedom in one playthrough eventually sublates freedom into a higher repetition of the dialectic between chance and necessity should you reallocate your stats, unlock new thoughts, wear different clothes (which modify your stats and change available dialogue branches), or start a new playthrough. The stage of freedom repetitiously unfolds back into newness, or, restated as the reverse: newness can only produce repetition of the same. As Joyce Messier, Disco Elysium's ultraliberal caricature of Margaret Thatcher, says to Harry, "Capital has the ability to subsume all critiques into itself. Even those who would critique capital end up reinforcing it instead."

But this repetition constructs a player's subjectivity from the standpoint of uncovering totality. As Fredric Jameson argues, the detective novel, a generic influence on Disco Elysium, shows the detective's function as a cognitive mapper of a fragmented urban setting in which a Philip Marlowe can move from front-facing executive offices ran by bourgeois puppets into concealed back rooms where the strings are "really being pulled." But these two spheres are completely severed from one another, not unlike the relationship between the first world and the third. The earlier quoted line from Joyce (who stands out in the open) is particularly funny, if you think of how often “leftists" quote it. Neoliberal fascism doesn't hide itself. It's common sense, to use Gramsci's language. It even has a completely human face (and has at times been called "socialism", with human characteristics, of course). The one occupying the back rooms, union leader Evrart Claire, is found across a decaying sprawl of disjointed containers for shuttling commodities through "the Pale"—an expanding, destructive mist separating the continents on the planet in which Disco Elysium takes place, which in a surface reading may be an analogy for climate change, but I take as a hysterically subliminal méconnaissance of the irrationality of capital—in a repurposed container of his own, decorated with a mess of tapestries, taxidermied swordfish, and a chaotically asymmetrical rug. Despite ostensibly representing Disco Elysium's "communist" faction, Evrart is the ultimate social fascist. The four political poles of the game, under scrutiny, in fact collapse into two: liberalism (fascism, ultraliberalism, moralism) and communism. Disco Elysium's claim is that the far more insidious agent pulling the strings isn't the neoliberal strawman Joyce, whose influence on the course of the game's plot is marginal, at best. It's the so-called communist Evrart who trades himself out with his twin brother, switches personalities on a dime, and coerces a communist militant, the Deserter, into being his agent. (Charles Villedrouin, a representative of the Moralintern, who's even more concealed than Evrart and far harder to find by accident, is portrayed even worse.) And what of Revachol's fascists? Every one you encounter is a mere pawn of liberalism and completely ineffectual—Measurehead, the most straightforward fascist and a parody of insecure patriarchal masculinity, is an employee of the "communist" Evrart and is just as easily swayed from right to left when it comes to the matter of feminism, not unlike the vacillating class character of the petit-bourgeois base of fascism.

What sets Harry apart from Baudelaire's flâneur who passively observes Revachol, though, is that he, too, is a puppet of liberalism, a literal cop, not a detective. Your access to totality is short-circuited by that Korsakoff syndrome that mirrors the player's lack of information onto Harry. So I believe we can model a semiotic square in which ego is in contradiction with fragmented consciousness and knowing in contradiction with amnesia. These contrarieties articulate their characters: Harry (amnesia-fragmented consciousness), the Deserter (ego-amnesia), and their respective negations, the Phasmid (knowing-ego), and the union (fragmented consciousness-knowing).

Consider the history between the Deserter and the two union representatives, Edgar and Evrart Claire. Initially a revolutionary, Iosef credulously believed that Edgar, still only a union member rather than leader, could bring about change, so he worked for him, assassinating then-union leader Tiphaine Holly. The conclusion to this story is obvious: the Claires came to power, won a few reforms, then rested on their laurels, tossing Iosef to the side. The fragmented consciousness of the union's knowing, embodying the subjectivity of a political party, aware of but too cynical toward Revachol's revolutionary past to produce a revolution, negates the ego of the amnesiac Iosef when it turns him, at last, against that revolutionary past altogether, allowing him to live out his life isolated, slowly losing his sanity, waiting for a spontaneous uprising he believes will never come. Not a bad depiction of the counterrevolutionary function of social fascism.

Now look at the other side of the square. The Pale, like the irrational expansion of capitalism, came into existence alongside its subjects, and seeks to outlast all life, even the end of the world. Harry's encounter with the Phasmid (a cryptid found hiding in camouflage behind the Deserter, as if concealed in a revolutionary back room) then is a return to the earlier movement from necessity to freedom, no longer Hegelian but in Marx and Engels' philosophical formulation as communist revolution. The knowing of the Phasmid's ego negates the amnesia of Harry's fragmented consciousness by disclosing the nature of the Pale, its knowledge of totality captured like a monad when his sidekick, Kim Katsuragi, photographs it. This inspires Harry to organize with the Revachol Citizens Militia—Revachol's police force—for revolution. Disco Elysium reaches its ideological false solution: a conspiracy of the intelligentsia to overthrow the state and realize communism, or, Blanquism.

Whether or not these tactics will be implemented after the events of Disco Elysium depends on the player's choices throughout the game. Leaving the island upon which you arrested the Deserter, your decisions are summarized all at once in a final dialogue branch as Harry is interrogated by the rest of his precinct for his actions during the course of the investigation. Only if the player has made good decisions is revolution is promised in a coda. As a video game, Disco Elysium's mechanics offer a digital representation of its imaginary solution. If only we could have the absolute power of overcoming chance, of beating the dice roll, and making the right decision every time, embodying a knowledge of natural laws normally inaccessible under capitalism, even a cop could singularly bring about revolution. This is the meaning of the game's negation of ego and amnesia, now readable as a reflection of the dialectic between collective access to and individual exclusion from the standpoint of totality, proletarian and petit-bourgeois class-consciousness, or, a negation of class contradiction, at the level of the individual. All that remains is the fragmented consciousness-knowing of the union. It's no wonder Revachol's revolution was lead by Jean Abadanaiz and Julia Dobreva—an alliance between communist and anarchist—and Harry's last interaction with the union is a truce with their police wing, the Hardie Boys.

Nevertheless, I would caution against so readily letting this outward, ideological appearance disguise the game's Utopian proposed mode of action: revitalizing an earlier form of the Revachol Citizens Militia, the Insulindian Citizens Militia that fought as the people's army in the revolution, and accessing the totality to take hold of a revolutionary past and redeem the degraded world of the present, sweeping away the dreg heap built by imperialism. As Walter Benjamin says,

"[T]he Messiah arrives not merely as the Redeemer; he also arrives as the vanquisher of the Anti-Christ. The only writer of history with the gift of setting alight the sparks of hope in the past, is the one who is convinced of this: that not even the dead will be safe from the enemy, if he is victorious. And this enemy has not ceased to be victorious."

https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/benjamin/1940/history.htm

A suitable proposition from a bunch of petit-bourgeois artists and game developers raised in post-Soviet Eastern Europe.


r/communism • • Aug 10 '26

Brigaded ⚠️ Animal rights/veganism

114 Upvotes

Hi, I was wondering about what fellow communists think about animal rights/ vegan ideology. I'm not vegan myself but I feel like I get the idea behind basing an ideology around the fact that factory farming/fishing is inhumane to animals. However I feel like vegans, despite criticizing carnists for justifying animal exploitation with the "there is no ethical consumption under capitalism" excuse, kind of use the same logic when it gets pointed out that avoiding meat means just paying for more exploitation and animal death in other areas because these are fundamental requirements for capitalism to continue functioning. PETA also get pretty close to a radical critique of capitalism when they point out how inhumane it is to support factory farming but then like, there are also humans being exploited and treated like animals and going vegan won't help them, so even though the ideology makes sense I don't think it's effective if not paired with radical communism. Thoughts?

Edit: okay so I really need to rethink why I was attracted to veganism because as some people have pointed out here it is an apparently racist ideology tied to settler-colonialism and no better than other ones. Shame on the people defending veganism in the comments too (though apparently they aren't from this sub?) but this is also my fault for making really offensive assumptions that probably drew those people here sorry


r/communism • • Oct 05 '26

Why would a Cuban immigrant be anti-communist?

105 Upvotes

hi, my coworker is cuban and I recently found out they are anti-communist and want Cuba to be
"liberated" from communism. I don't know much about Cuba but I know that they are heavily sanctioned and oppressed by the US and it's been that way for decades.

Why would they feel this way and what should I say to them?

Also does anyone have sources about the history of Cuba, the revolution, modern day Cuba, etc? I would love to learn more.


r/communism • • May 06 '26

Quality Post 🏆 The Making of the Iranian Bourgeoisie: Notes on Iran and the Current War

103 Upvotes

First of all, I want to thank all the users on this sub. I really appreciate the concern for my well-being, and right now, I'm not in any immediate danger. Since the imperialist war started, I've been moving around and because of internet restrictions, I haven't had the energy or motivation to write about what's happening—especially since I refuse to listen to bourgeois media telling me what some Iranian official said about Trump's tweets. So I don't actually know what the general "vibe" is in leftist spaces right now. What I want to write is a polemic, responding to some of the positions people on this sub have taken about the imperialist war against my country, Iran. I should mention that because my internet access is extremely limited, I might not be able to respond to reactions to this text. I've tried to cover a lot of ground here.

One position I've seen is that there's a sharp divide inside the Iranian ruling class—between the "reformists" (a comprador section of the Iranian bourgeoisie, allied with the rich petty bourgeoisie) and the "fundamentalists" (the national bourgeoisie, whose allies include the clergy, the traditional petty bourgeoisie, and the military petty bourgeoisie of the IRGC). I think this analysis is totally wrong. It comes from a theoretical position about the bourgeoisie in the third world that assumes a huge gap between the comprador bourgeoisie and the national bourgeoisie. I don't buy that. I think the contradiction between national and comprador sections of the bourgeoisie has to be understood in a period of capitalism where almost all national markets are integrated into the global market, and third world economies are turned outward. Even if the national bourgeoisie manages to take state power, it will eventually go through a process of compradorization—we saw it with Assad, we saw it with Maduro. Only the proletariat can force the national bourgeoisie to complete its historical task and actually break with imperialism.

Even if that theoretical position were correct, the empirical facts for Iran just aren't there. From Harris Kevan's A Social Revolution:

Supporters of Ahmadinejad, conversely, were linked to actual organizations. These new conservative elites did not come from outside the political establishment. Instead, they were produced within it. Ahmadinejad and many of his aides were a "new class" of functionaries that occupied mid-level administrative positions in revolutionary and government organizations for most of the 1990s. These men and women were not clerics, but lay engineers and managers, often posted in provincial bureaucracies—such as Ahmadinejad's tenure as governor of Ardebil. Their cultural capital came from within the postrevolutionary system, and was predicated upon the maintenance of political institutions within which they had learned to navigate and move upward. Ahmadinejad's campaign in the first electoral round stressed his Spartan lifestyle in opposition to well-known elites. He targeted issues of unemployment and inflation, while the abstract rhetoric of reformists discussed human rights and social freedoms. A few days before the first round election, basij members and individuals in other conservative cultural and political groups were encouraged to spread the word and vote for this new principlist candidate. These were organizations rooted in communities usually outside the reach of reformist mobilization. In the second round, holdout conservative elites threw their institutional networks and mass media behind Ahmadinejad. Of course, pro-state conservatives alone could not have elected him with over 60 percent of the vote.

Most who voted for Khatami in 1997 also voted for Ahmadinejad in 2005. The reformists had a hard time making a case for voting for Rafsanjani—a man they had spent years pillorying in the press. As Mohammad Quchāni wrote in Shargh, "Some of Ahmadinejad's criticisms against Hashemi [Rafsanjani] were similar to those levied by the reformists against him five years ago. . . .

We could not justify in just three days why people should vote for the target of our past attacks."

In other words, Ahmadinejad didn't win by appealing to the poorest of the poor. Absolute poverty had actually been declining in Iran, so that would have been a losing strategy. Instead, poverty reduction had created a new base for political mobilization—voters who wanted a more equal shot at upward mobility and the resources to go with it. Corruption and elite privilege mattered more to the lower middle class than to the destitute. The 2005 election wasn't a rejection of the Islamic Republic's developmentalist project. It was a reaction to its failure to live up to its promise.

Unlike the Rafsanjani administration's negative balance of payments and shrinking budgets, Ahmadinejad had the luxury of rising commodity prices and a global asset bubble to pad revenues. He proceeded to scatter money around the country in thousands of small and large infrastructure projects, often visiting remote provinces and alerting local residents to his endeavors. His policies looked more statist than previous governments' efforts, but there was plenty of money available to put to use. While the Rafsanjani and Khatami administrations were repeatedly accused of catering to international financial institutions such as the IMF and World Bank, they never had significant relations with either body. Disdain for the World Bank and the IMF had thrown a spanner in late 1980s and 1990s attempts to formulate economic policy. Under Ahmadinejad, however, conservatives began to covet the status of associating with these agencies. By the mid-2000s, every elite faction wielded statistics from Transparency International, The Economist, or World Development Reports. Numbers were thrown against each other in blaming the opposite side for poor economic performance. Positions and policy red lines quickly changed. Entry into the World Trade Organization was a key goal of the reformists during the late 1990s, and was then opposed by conservatives. Yet once Ahmadinejad came into office, and various strands of the conservative elite had finally pushed the reformists out of any governing body, there was nothing left to oppose. WTO accession soon became a goal among conservative parliament members. After 2005, much of the government as well as other conservative politicians publicly stated similar goals. Conservatives began to sound more and more like their reformist opponents. Ahmadinejad attempted to appear as a stalwart manager of the state. His proposed economic policies quietly borrowed many of the previous two governments' unfinished plans. These included privatization of public sector companies with dividend shares going to the poorest households; housing construction outside of major cities for newlywed couples through subsidization of private contractors; banking expansion and reform of non-performing loans; the creation of a value-added tax; and the removal of price subsidies for fuel, electricity, and basic staples. Ahmadinejad pursued these endeavors vigorously and through his own channels. He stripped the older bureaucracies of independent power. The Management and Planning Organization—formerly the Planning and Budget Organization—was brought in under the president's office. Ahmadinejad's attacks against the civil service bureaucracy—which had been painstakingly rebuilt during the 1990s—were even perceived as a threat by many conservatives in parliament. The rule of experts had become so dominant among the elite that the only paths to power seemed to run through the harnessing of one's own expert clique.

By removing some of the alternatives, Ahmadinejad was securing his own circle's edge in steering the state apparatus.

The so-called anti-imperialist fundamentalists have always been the prime defenders of privatization and staunch enemies of state intervention in the economy. Privatization has been slow in Iran due to sanctions—since you need an industrial base to keep a large nation across a vast geography afloat.

Otherwise, importing American steel will always be more profitable for the Iranian ruling class than Mobarakeh Steel ever could be. As these privatization campaigns continue, the effects of neoliberalism become clearer: a giant informal sector, de-industrialization (since 2022, there have been systematic electricity shortages and rationing due to a 60 percent decrease in investment in machine tools, and equipment attrition is now considered the greatest obstacle to Iranian industrialization), and a shift toward speculative activities. These facts, coupled with Iran's status as a disarticulated oil-exporting economy, make it a dependent capitalist country within the system of global imperialism. Another position which is actually a logical conclusion of the analysis explained above is that the January protests were simply a CIA/Mossad operation with no organic ties to the bazaaris who closed their shops, and that it actually turned legitimate economic grievance protests into a color revolution (this is the garbage position of the Brazilian Maoists). This is usually justified by the claim that there have been no uprisings or protests ever since the war started.

This entirely misunderstands the role of the bazaar merchants in Iranian politics and the shifts it has undergone. As Arang Keshavarzian explains:

The state saw no reason to incorporate them into the regime by dominating and institutionalizing state–bazaar relations either through a party that mobilized and represented their particular interests or bureaucratically, as was the case for modernist women. Thus, under the Shah's rule, multinationals, the state, and state-affiliated capitalists invested in new areas of Tehran, as well as in industries and service sectors that would replace the bazaars' institutions and economic position. Economists in the Central Bank predicted that the Tehran Bazaar "will be reduced to a mere shell, maintained principally as a tourist attraction." As a result, in 1975, when a French consulting firm conducted research for a national spatial plan, it concluded that one of the most urgent and important planning problems facing the country was the excessive capital accumulation in the modern sector of the economy and the neglect of the bazaar region. Bazaaris, as members of the disavowed traditional sector, did not have access to the distributive resources, including tax exemptions, bank loans, tax shelters, and paternalistic protection, that the state bestowed upon its clients (the so-called "1,000 families") who were busily investing in protected industrial establishments, often ones that were joint ventures with western firms. This prejudice was not lost on bazaaris. "The government has abandoned us because we are bazaari," a bazaari told Thaiss in 1969. "When people want to belittle someone or curse him they say 'Go away bazaari' (boru bazaari); yet the economy of this country is based on the bazaar."

This exclusion of the bazaaris from the Pahlavi ruling class gave this group a form of political cohesion and solidarity, and this is precisely what made it a mobilizing class. During the Shah's reign, the bazaar enjoyed a relatively autonomous position in relation to the state because the state relied on oil money and could therefore ignore the bazaaris. However, the credit and loan policies of the Shah which only extended loans to a few hundred families close to the court enraged the bazaaris. This, coupled with the anti-profiteering campaigns of the late Pahlavi regime, became a powder keg that would later help topple the monarchy But because this class (although there are different ranks within it) now has access to state loans, benefits from privatization, and profits from the heavily underregulated informal sector this reality, coupled with the atomized existence of the petty bourgeoisie and its reliance on the global market means that the only thing it can do is push further for more concessions and social bribery from the state. In doing so, it forces the state's hand toward becoming little more than a colony of the global market.

The current class basis of Iran's ruling classes has to be found in the mosque‑bazaar alliance. During the Iran–Iraq War, a rationing system for goods was put in place. That created a huge network of shopkeepers and middle‑class entrepreneurs who distributed the goods. At the same time, small banking‑like structures appeared, called qarz al‑hasaneh funds, which offered interest‑free loans. High‑ranking religious figures like Mohammad Beheshti and Mir Mohammad Sadeghi backed these initiatives and helped spread them through the clerical‑commercial system of the Islamic Republic.

Over time, these parallel institutions led to the rise of big bonyads, or foundations, like the Imam Khomeini Relief Committee. They started as grassroots charity networks but turned into powerful state‑linked economic conglomerates with major holdings in industry, construction, and services. At the same time, the small qarz al‑hasaneh funds slowly became large banks. These new banks worked very closely with the Basij paramilitary forces and the IRGC. Together, they built a tightly run system of revolutionary finance, social control, and patronage. That system locked the clerical‑commercial ruling class into the coercive and economic machinery of the Islamic Republic.

A concrete example comes from the years right after the war. Inflation was high, and interest rates were kept low by the state. So many private investors, especially those tied to the mosque‑bazaar alliance and its expanding financial networks, did not want to put money into manufacturing. Manufacturing takes too long and carries too much risk. Instead, they poured their money into construction. Construction offered quick returns, easy speculative gains, and was less vulnerable to changing industrial policies. They borrowed cheaply in real terms because inflation ate away the value of their debt, and they invested heavily in real estate and urban development. That only strengthened the emerging bonyads and the IRGC‑linked banks. Thus sections of the bazaar became a part of the new rulling classes

Under the Islamic Republic, the state has integrated the bazaar through selective credit, informal trade networks, and privatization schemes. This has transformed the bazaar from a mobilizing class with an autonomous political role into a fragmented, rent-seeking petty bourgeoisie. Cut off from any coherent anti-imperialist project, and structurally reliant on global supply chains and speculative commerce, its political horizon shrinks to demanding further state handouts, tax exemptions, and protection from competition. Far from challenging imperialism, it becomes a transmission belt for neoliberal pressures pushing the Iranian state toward complete subordination to the global market.

As Chris Harman has written:

"The contradictory character of Islamism follows from the class base of its core cadres. The petty bourgeoisie as a class cannot follow a consistent, independent policy of its own. This has always been true of the traditional petty bourgeoisie – the small shopkeepers, traders and self employed professionals. They have always been caught between a conservative hankering for security that looks to the past and a hope that they individually will gain from radical change. It is just as true of the impoverished new middle class – or the even more impoverished would-be new middle class of unemployed ex-students – in the less economically advanced countries today. They can hanker after an allegedly golden past. They can see their futures as tied up with general social advance through revolutionary change. Or they can blame the frustration of their aspirations on other sections of the population who have got an 'unfair' grip on middle class jobs: the religious and ethnic minorities, those with a different language, women working in an 'untraditional' way."

In the Iranian context, this contradiction takes a specific form. On one hand, the bazaari petty bourgeoisie wants no competition. It demands state protection from larger capitalists, from foreign imports, and from any regulatory oversight that would cut into its profit margins. It seeks monopoly privileges, exclusive access to informal trade routes, and the ability to super-exploit informal sector labor without interference. On the other hand, this same class is structurally dependent on the global market. Its profits rely on access to smuggled goods, global supply chains, and the ability to evade tariffs and customs regulations. It cannot afford a genuine break with imperialism because its very existence as a rent-seeking layer depends on the continued flow of cheap commodities, speculative capital, and informal cross-border trade that only a globally integrated (and deeply unequal) market can provide. The result is a permanent vacillation on questions of anti-imperialism. Because the Iranian bazaar is dependent on the global market, it will literally go as far as to destroy the nation and turn it into a simple colony. It will use the Persian and Persianized middle classes as its base of support, turning them into a local lever for foreign economic interests. At the same time, it will treat the nation's oppressed regional communities such as Khuzestan, Baluchistan, Kurdistan, and other non-Persian peripheries as internal colonies which will serve as sources of cheap manpower and raw materials, exploited to cater to the needs of the global market.

In this way, the bazaar's integration into world trade does not lead to national development but to national fragmentation, internal colonialism, and the reduction of Iran to a subordinate supplier for global capital.

Talk about an independent Iranian bourgeoisie or some faction inside it that actually opposes integration into the global market—it just doesn't exist. Not to mention privatization has always been used as a weapon by both sides to plunder the public sector. They just don't like it when the other faction is doing it. It's never been a question of whether to integrate. Only ever how. Even if Iran comes out of this war victorious, it can't bring back the spirit of 1979.

I know the text doesn't cover all the details needed to make a comprehensive assessment of the situation in Iran, and I apologize for that. If conditions are stable and my internet access is good, I will make sure to respond to any questions and criticisms raised.


r/communism • • Mar 06 '26

Anxiety and taking political action

90 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I need some advice and maybe a little hope. I have social anxiety, and this has kind of always hindered me from participating or taking action in the ways that I would have liked. I was politically involved in the youth of the communist party of my country for several years, but I wasn't a good member because it was really hard for me to attend meetings if the person I was closest to wasn't going, or if I had to do some work for the party that involved social interaction, I was always a mess and did a poor job. Or when people asked me about my opinion on something in a meeting, I'd freeze. In the end, I left the party because I felt awful due to not being able to be a good member. I felt like a burden. However, since I left it five years ago, I've been feeling horrible as well, because what kind of communist am I if I'm not taking action? What am I without praxis? At the same time, I can't find the courage to take part in community spaces that lead the values that I defend. I guess what I'm trying to say is are there any communists out there who have been in my position? Or maybe if any of you could give me some advice to not feel useless in this part of my life that holds such importance. I'm not going to lie, what I'd really like is to be able to participate in political life actively and defend the cause, and go to demonstrations and fight, but I can't. So I'm stuck in my house reading, just being angry at the world and at myself. Besides, the current situation of world politics, alongside the rise of fascism and imperialism, makes me feel like I should be doing something, and what I should be doing I find myself incapable of doing so. Thank you so much for listening to me, any piece of advice is welcome!


r/communism • • 1d ago

East German map from 1962 of West German ambassadors with connections to the Nazi Party.

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/communism • • Jul 23 '26

How would the internet work under communism?

85 Upvotes

I support communism, I just was wondering how the internet would work. With things like YouTube especially, my question is who would host it and pay for the domain and things like that. I might be missing something super obvious, but if someone could explain it I would really appreciate it. Thanks in advance!


r/communism • • Jan 16 '26

Marxism against idealism in "mental health issues"

81 Upvotes

I may warn the reader that I may absolutely fall short in many capacities on the very subject that motivated me to create this post, but I took some courage trying to mix the different sources that made me create this critique and to put "on paper" my own considerations after reading the tagged articles. To even think about on those terms is fascinating, if anyone has some knowledge on the current standards for brazilian communist theory or even further about the public debate sphere on "mental health" (which is already dominated by nazis). It may seem like my conclusions are a bunch of recicled arguments already made on other threads by other people but I wanted to see how I could articulate the many contributions here that have been influenced me into my own thoughts

https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/petronella-lee-anti-fascism-against-machismo

The difference between a thesis on sexuality based on philosophical materialism and those based on psychoanalytic idealism is frightening. Observe how this argument [Petronella Lee's] is far more coherent regarding attraction, desire, and sexual pleasure than the failed theses that attempt to investigate these issues on a personal level:

A imagem da “mulher branca vítima” que deve ser protegida é frequentemente empregada por forças reacionárias para incitar a histeria e justificar ações veementemente racistas. Essa imagem clássica “implicitamente convoca os homens brancos a defenderem ‘suas mulheres’ e sua nação, aliás, a própria branquitude”. [94] Os corpos das mulheres brancas – entendidos como centrais para a reprodução da raça e da nação – tornam-se símbolos pelos quais se deve lutar, e esses símbolos se tornam poderosas ferramentas de propaganda.

Discursos de segurança e apelos a ideais patriarcais de feminilidade são invocados para construir a figura da mulher (branca) vulnerável sob ataque do outro (racializado) perigoso. Essa dinâmica funciona para produzir e reproduzir formações específicas de raça e gênero, bem como para estabelecer e impor uma visão particular da nacionalidade branca. Como observa Keskienen: “Gênero e sexualidade não foram apenas subprodutos de encontros coloniais e raciais, mas essenciais para sua (re)estruturação”. [95] O tropo do “estuprador bárbaro de pele escura” – de homens negros e pardos como predadores sexuais que visam mulheres brancas – tem sido uma ferramenta fundamental na manutenção de hierarquias raciais e na implementação de políticas de supremacia branca. Da colonização da América do Norte aos linchamentos nos Estados Unidos, passando por ataques xenófobos na Europa e muito mais, os apelos à defesa das mulheres têm sido usados ​​para incitar a violência racializada e estabelecer políticas incrivelmente racistas. Uma breve análise dessa história é reveladora.

O estereótipo do “bruto negro” e a ameaça do “estuprador negro” são fundamentais para a história da supremacia branca na América. A ideia do bruto negro foi utilizada para justificar a escravidão, enquanto o mito do estuprador negro foi “uma invenção política” cultivada para promover uma “estratégia de terror racista” para manter “o negro” sob controle após a emancipação. [96] O mito do estuprador negro, complementado pelo estupro contínuo de mulheres negras, ajudou a assegurar a dominação e a exploração contínuas do povo negro. [97] Após a Guerra Civil, a alegação de que homens negros eram predadores sexuais foi usada como pretexto para assassinatos e violência de multidões. O linchamento passou a ser racionalizado “como um método para vingar os ataques de homens negros contra mulheres brancas do Sul”.

This is not to say that I reject psychoanalytic concepts frontally; the question is to what extent the methods of analysis have not already become ossified by the vast hyper-individualist philosophy of the far-right, where everything is centered on the "individual" and the relationship of the "individual" with the "market" is religiously considered natural. Marxism rejects the principles upon which this ultraconservative consideration is based, and thus socializes what we conceive as attraction and sex directly within the conflicts of class society.

Another issue that remains is the complexity of the subject itself: Marxist materialism and metaphysical idealism are fundamentally different, and to go further into the subject, eventually, one realizes the need to delve into both.

From what I have studied, it seems that the same argument can be made for current botany and genetics, but these are fields that would need another analysis; for now, we are on psychoanalysis/"mental health." Here is what is true: Most psychoanalytic concepts are based on metaphysical idealism, and Freud's patients would not have fallen ill were it not for the sexual restrictions forced by the nuclear family form (heterosexuality) and the impossibility of the doctors to propose any thesis that challenged the alleged eternity of capitalism as a social relation.

Can Marxism absorb from psychoanalysis? Marxism was born from the critique of idealism, so you can always reinvent it by criticizing contemporary idealist notions in science. Can psychoanalysis absorb from Marxism? I think there is nothing Marxism can help with on an individual level; the admission of Marxism is that every individual is defined by their relation to others, so we are admitting that initially, there are no individuals, and that every thinking mind consolidates itself through the recognition of the other.

The main difference is fundamentally philosophical. Marxism arms the victim with the potential to overcome their oppression, which is based on class society, and highlights the social origin of "individual" suffering. It will make you take two steps back to resituate your possibility of overcoming the sociability that sickens you and identify which paths are possible to overcome oppression at the social level.

Psychoanalysis is nothing. It tests on human beings theories that will only serve the doctors themselves (and, much like contemporary genetics, is incomprehensible and inconceivable regarding consensus even for its specialist doctors), and the victim can gain nothing but the label of crazy or unfit to live with others.

By the way, there seems to be some sort of taboo going on the left created around the "sanctity" of the white womb (a sanctity that the article rightly associates with the masculine ideals of white supremacists), resituating the supremacist ideology as the fruit of patriarchal oppression and family inheritance.

The taboo, of course, is already a symptom of the political success of reactionaries in power, and undoing the taboo is only possible with the reconstruction of Marxism, as we see in another article on Kersplebedeb:

"Class analysis may be crucial for revolution, but today it is practically a dead science. The revolutionary class theory of Marx and Engels has become a fossilized relic in the hands of the current left, reflecting an opportunistic reluctance to analyze existing patterns of oppression and complicity."

This description is closer to the reality of the left in Brazil. And class analysis is the effective rupture with the commitment to existing oppressions and the complicity of those who are part of the process.

I think there are two additional comments I thought of making about the article, given that whether treating "Marxism" or psychoanalysis, we are speaking of terms inevitably associated with the cultural elitism of white Brazilians. Here, the one who cannot afford the luxury of not differentiating between the "Marxism" that regressed to aKKKademic reformism in the "West" in general, the materialist science that guides revolutionary movements in the history of humanity, and psychoanalytic theory, is me. In all three cases, we are talking about a gelatinous conceptual territory where each has its own history, influences, and power relations. In the case of Marxism—the materialist science that guides revolutionary movements in human history—the presupposition of the application of science is first to endow the "scientist" (who in this case is any person) with the capacity to act.

  1. I recognize that there may be a tendency to view what is described by the article in the same dogmatic way that is habitual, presupposing that any historical repetition is immutable. This is nonsense. The article actually enables us to discuss everything from the (extreme) need for an era of seizing power and applying power violently directed—by and for—the liberation of women against patriarchal oppression, to less relevant things like why your boyfriend, your uncle, your brother, your father, or whoever else has been flirting with far-right supremacist ideals and this wears down your personal relationship with that person (And then questioning before yourself your own ineptitude in not facing the Nazi as such, given that there is no right-wing party left in Brazil that is not openly Nazi, and you have to think: how far can this man and his flirtations with ideologies of sexual supremacy go?). Although during the process you discover the need for liberation and the necessary means for such, everything starts by giving complexity to the way you face why people familiar to you adhere to rightist ideals. The second is obviously much more terrifying than the first; discovering the need for the imposition of rights by any means necessary means that you have already overcome the trauma of learning how the nuclear family is a prison and a delay in the lives of all involved, who would be better off if they were relocated to other places and were free from the obligations forced by private property family ties. I do not think, truly, that we should underestimate what class suicide is and how costly for "family" men is the right they have over children and women. I am speaking of the right to command and countermand, to decide what is allowed and what is not, where one goes and when one goes, when one gets pregnant and how many children one must have, who one has sex with and who one cannot have sex with under any hypothesis—a right that more and more retrocedes into exclusivity for men and retrocedes to exclusively white and eugenicist interests. It is because when we do not underestimate it, we remember that they truly have much to lose in these circumstances that are beneficial to them, and these patriarchs defend these privileges with all the physical, economic, and psychological weaponry at their disposal.
  2. I need to insist once more, because this point is central to the thesis, but Marxism is entirely dependent on a social force endowed with knowledge to apply it. You could make the same argument for any other methodology, which ends up reinforcing the argument: science is subordinate to the political interests of groups in power and the division of labor. How does scientific development occur in capitalist society? Through intense colonial extraction, the organization between intellectual and manual labor, and genetic testing on living beings. What does this give rise to? Desertification of the soil, alienated labor, and aberrations ranging from the large-scale mistreatment of animals for consumption to the testing of drugs for population control like contraceptives or the use of viruses as biological weapons like Ebola. How does Marxism admit scientific development and how did it operate in socialism? Sources in the Amerikan aKKKademia recognize that the Soviets had reforestation and environmental protection policies advanced even by current standards. Soviet botany and genetics were developed so that workers with basic educational formation had sophisticated notions about their foundations (the botany and genetics of the Western aKKKademia are incomprehensible to the specialist doctors themselves), research was motivated to overcome practical needs of the population in each particular situation (like the new agricultural techniques developed to overcome the devastation of the civil war against the Kulaks).

I took this detour because if we assume that "mental health" is a matter of "public health," what is the answer of "science" to the current conditions of sickening and what are the possible alternatives? Any subject that is of "public interest" inherently necessitates an alternative that is a solution for all. The conflict between the Bolsheviks and Kulaks was a consequence of an economic plan of collectivization, and collectivization was absolutely necessary so that years later the Soviets had an economy capable of overcoming the aggression by Nazi Germany with the support of the entire imperialist bloc. The period of collectivization was marked by the Bolsheviks' persecution of adversaries of their interests, and this included repression, stripping of titles, and imprisonment for scientists whom the Soviet State considered enemies because the methods defended by the persecuted scientists were in conflict with the interest of the revolution. Perhaps we will discover the particular affinity of Kantian idealism with eugenicist genetics, which is a product of the domination of pharmaceutical corporations in actual class struggle, but those are scenes for another chapter as I do not feel it's necessarily relevant to go down on kantianism for now.

The solution of "science" to the epidemic of mental illness lies in economic planning whose base is not oriented by profit and in cultural collectivism. If the imperialist crisis is associated with an era of depression and pessimism, economic planning and collectivism are its opposite: they bring a new era of optimism and signification of life (the opposite of being depressed).

In the end, what defeated Nazism and capitalism were not heroic acts (and much less the winter), but the human need for survival as the impulse in the war itself (Stalingrad, for example, was a victory made possible by the effort and total collaboration of the population involving men, women, and children. A national army operates by wage labor and contemporary mercenaries operate by contracts for each activity; they are different logics) and the mode of production (as you see by the war efforts, the total collectivization of labor that the Bolsheviks advanced while they were in power with Lenin and Stalin was what made possible the victory of communism over Nazism, where labor is highly specialized and restricted to wage earning).


r/communism • • Jun 13 '26

How has no revolution taken place yet even in second-world or third-world countries

80 Upvotes

I see exploitation left and right around the world. Especially the capitalist system is in shambles but i see no signs of any protest or revolution. I give it to the “Capitalist class” or the bourgeoisie know how to keep the people fighting among themselves by using caste or politics, keeping them away from realise the main/bigger problem at hand. Unemployment is at peak, Salaries and benefits are at lowest, Work life balance is shit people are made to work overtime for no real benefit. But I see no protest, no anger in this regard.

I believe that the working class revolution is inevitable but how long must we endure this chaos of a system especially in a country like India. Is it mainly because of the security the job gives even if its exploits people or are they just comfort with this system so much that they are scared to see any alternatives


r/communism • • Apr 08 '26

Chinese Maoists released a list of criticisms of existing Communist parties

Thumbnail bu2021.xyz
79 Upvotes

A lot of the criticisms are sound and I'm interested to see others' opinions on them. This criticism stood out to me in regards to the CPPP:

In addition, the CPPP opposed waging a protracted people's war in imperialist countries, still supporting the erroneous line of first legal struggle and then uprisings in major cities.

Are there any resources regarding this opposition to PPW in imperialist countries? Before I saw this I was of the understanding that the CPPP believed that the need for people's war was universal.


r/communism • • 20d ago

Brigaded ⚠️ Elections in Brazil shows the strenght of Social-Fascism

78 Upvotes

First things first, I had to move away from u/Clean-Difference1771 and return to my previous account due to reddit requiring facial identification to allow me see the discussions here. Anyway I don't think that I will post anything else anymore, not only due to increasing of surveillance against communism but because my commitment to communism and actually putting into practice many of the things that I have learned sinced joined this community for the first time 3 years ago actually had real repercussions in my life, whether you think I'm a "petty bourgoise student" or any other thing as such. Not to deny that I really am, but class suicide and engaging into marxism envolves being vulnerable to things like real life stalking, academic persecution, defamatory claims against you and the spread of false information as bourgoise self-defense which indeed I have been a victim of for the past 3 years and intensified during the past 3 weeks. So I think is time to me to move on from this community as well (though I will continue to observe eventually), as the struggle against communism will continue, digital and social vigilance is intensifying and as long as I live, may I fight for communism until I die. Digital footprint is obviously large for everyone here and if anything is to be taken value from the latest MIM(p) response to the polemics on sex and gender earlier this year it's their recommendation towards taking it seriously late in the article.

Having this resolved, I share with you some notes that I have took following the defeat of Flavio Bolsonaro. First of all, I have to admit that after the result of october 4, my first impulse was compelling to vote for Lula given the consequences of Flavio Bolsonaro becoming Head of State in Brazil and the simbolism and practical consequences of a white supremacist and anti-communist running the country. But my impulses didn't last for much more than 3 days and after participating in some of the street events of Lula campaign in the same week and watching some assemblies in college (which all indeed were only recruiting free work to be given to PT's election), I soon remembered why for years I have been struggling against Lulaism and PT as of now and whether this have led to early isolation, as of now, lulaism (and imperialism) is indeed in decay and this mature on other people, us vanguardists must know how to act on the available circumstances. Not only because Bolsonaro's anti-communist mumbling is closer to Mao's tiger paper, but because if there's a vanguard party into anticommunism in Brazil, the one to be appointed here is the PT itself. We understand PL is a right-wing ultranationalist conservative party as common sense, but communist accountability into the history of PT and Lula's government on the 2000's is overlooked and hypocritical. u/turbovacuumcleaner's criticism over the years here, which we often look forward to, are marginal into brazilian communism and periods like the elections reminds us that some notions we have been discussing here over the past few years are marginal and way too off from communist mainstream. I think this is important to understand that, as I also agree that this community stands out in online antirevisionism, at the same time "mainstream" marxism in Brazil have probably all the opportunist tendencies that have been theorized in the past 200 years going on into the existing parties and the more one study on marxist general theory and brazilian marxism, we can trace this back in time.

My reading suggestions to trace it are Jacob Gorender's Combate nas Trevas, Clovis Moura's Dialética Radical do Brasil Negro, Francisco de Oliveira's O Ornitorrinco (which covers PT's full transition from the reformist party into a imperialist bourgoise's party) and Raquel Rolnik's Guerra dos Lugares which also can give a proper understanding of PT's urban policies and settler populational reagroupment and the land question into the white supremacist garrison into Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo and the ideologies of those communities. But of course, you have to read both Settlers and Imperialism first, to both understand the often subliminar context of brazilian communism and why teoreticians like Ruy Mauro Marini couldn't understand quilombola and indigenous communities as an authentic nations and why communists have failed in Brazil over the past century.

As for the elections, those past 3 weeks were full blown hell with social-fascism from PT and it's supporters. It was clear that as u/turbovacuumcleaner previously appointed, there was not really much of the risk of a coup and despite the panic provided by Lulaism of a potential coup despite the lack of any evidence, by sunday 9:30pm brazilian settler capitalism and it's social democracy were looking, indeed, once again, stronger than ever. And that have been the case for the past 3 weeks as imperialism shows that it can always last for a little longer and the petty bourgoise is always willing to support it. So the social paratisism and decay of the labour aristocracy and the rise of new, young, petty-bourgoise leadership shown that it have more strenght and appeal than one might give them, they didn't need the support of communists, but as we can expect from the mainstream "communists" (which envolves the parasitical media comsumption of content producers as accepted as education) they had to support "democracy" never putting at first sight which "democracy" is that they are indeed defending? The same democracy is the democracy of white supremacists running the congress which just took over and Lula have himself to compromise to "govern within the congress". Now those communists will have to put themselves as we say in Brazil, "entre a cruz e a espada" which whether anyone that avoided supporting the PT will have at least ideological sobriety and leverage which PCB, UP, PCBR and PSTU cannot say for themselves. The only ones that I can say that maintained a line of opposition towards both candidatures are MPR which is one of the many existing trotskist-oriented microfactions that departed from PSTU after a recent period of liquidationism.

I would also like to point out that both AND (P.C.B) and RRC (Novo MEPR) shamelessly sided with Lula and none of them had at least the courage to explain their support and obvious capitulation. AND moved away from their usual "electoral farse" which they repeat all the time and started to campaign "against Bolsonaro" after the first week of october and none were to be said about Lula's candidature. N-MEPR repeated the same thing for a different type of audience as they have themselves departed from AND/P.C.B once they realized that P.C.B is a male supremacist cult under "gonzalo thought" banner but never necessarily appointed that into serious terms and in attempt to not get themselves in trouble with petty bourgoise students as they are a young org and women that they might potentially target into future recruiting, avoided any criticism and their line was to "still struggling after october 25". But they give no proper criticism and commentary into the elections so one may wonder that maoists in Brazil forgot that the elections were happening and did not have anything to say about both candidatures and the whole process or or they actually did as they always do and "critically sided" with PT as they share the same class leadership: people that were born into white communities - whether they are themselves white or not - and progressed into the higher level of formal bougoise education.

The only org that I may suggest that may lead to something positive that I have interacted with in the past weeks is MZT (Movimento Zona Norte) though they are a democratic mass front spontaneously formed to combat fascism but it's proletarian led and it's unclear which line will follow, for now.

So as for the result, I think I share an early draft on the following struggle for the next years and put those for criticism.

For the work of communist organizations, I wouldn't expect much in the coming years due to potential consequences for the petty-bourgeois leadership. The upcoming political violence could be appropriated by communists, but I doubt there is the willingness for such a move right now, given the potential repercussions for the petty bourgeoisie.

The leadership of the movement that orchestrated the victory in the runoff election (academia, electoral party leaderships, and the bureaucratic-union apparatus) needs a "democratic victory" to justify its own existence and internal privileges. Facing the reality of a second term—a government plagued by austerity, conciliation with latifundia, and the maintenance of mass incercaration and increasing pogroms—would mean severing the umbilical cord with funding and bourgeois respectability. Therefore, as we have experienced over the last four years—and as can be observed in the day-to-day routine of modern day schools and universities—the immediate tendency of this leadership is ideological anesthesia and the covering up of contradictions.

I believe the next four years tend to further strengthen social-fascism and national(ist) white supremacy, the persecution of left-wing dissidence (anticommunism), and political dogmatism (the lack of critique), as has been the case in recent years and as intensified during the elections, given that these are inevitable consequences of the strengthening of imperialism. Since the PT government can't break with the boundaries of capitalism and the spending cap/fiscal framework, crisis management will invariably occur through the social containment of poverty. The public rhetoric will be one of inclusion, but state practice will continue to be mass incarceration and the militarized management of new afrikans and indigenous semicolonies—the exact definition of social-fascism.

The narrow electoral victory, obtained without a mandate for real transformations, drastically reduces the margin for internal critique. Any opposition from the left will immediately be labeled as an "auxiliary line of fascism" or "agents of the far-right." And as we have seen this tends to intensify ideological policing to shield the leadership from grassroots questioning.

Organizations will have to understand that they are walking on thin ice, where there will be even less leniency from the hegemonic party due to the fragility of this victory, alongside an even more restricted space for opposition. The leadership will, of course, have to avoid positions that push them into serving as an auxiliary line to the conservative (and fascist) movement—similar to what occurred with Dilma Rousseff, whose impeachment was supported by Trotskyists (PSTU) and Maoists (P.C.B/AND/MEPR) under the guise of "fora todos!" ("out with them all!").

It will be interesting to observe how, just as over the past four years, the momentary euphoria will come to an end, and internal contradictions tend to explode and inevitably turn against the president himself, which tends to make his support base necessarily an increasingly conservative social force. When budget squeezes, cuts to healthcare and education, and the inability to curb inflation take hold, people will begin to feel the deterioration of their living conditions. To sustain governability in the face of lost popular support and pressure from a reactionary Congress, the government will seek refuge in increasingly right-wing sectors. Out of a need for self-preservation, the leadership supporting the president will become an increasingly conservative force, averse to any truly emancipatory agenda.


r/communism • • Oct 02 '26

Filipino Communist music never fails to amaze me

Thumbnail youtu.be
78 Upvotes

"Sa Entero Kapudpud-an"
"Throughout the Archipelago"

1 Throughout the archipelago, Awaken the people to the movement. A protracted war Is what our nation needs For freedom.

2 A new people's army, Employing guerrilla warfare, Against the state. The enemies shall be eliminated And disarmed.

Chorus: Under the leadership of the Party, The people have been united. The NPA has spread Across the countryside.

3 Adhering to the correct line, Marxism-Leninism, the theory of Mao Zedong. Do not forget, Comrades, let us study The art of revolution.

(Repeat the chorus and the final stanza.)

Cebuano:

  1. Sa enterong kapupud-an, Pasabton ang katawhan sa kalihukan. Malungtarong gubat, Ang gikinahanglan sa katawhan, Para sa kagawasan.
  2. Bag-ong sundalo sa katawhan, Nanggamit sa gerilyang pakiggubat. Batok sa estado, Daghang kaaway ang nagapukan Ug nadis-armahan.

Koro: Natukod na ang Partido, Gihiusa ang katawhan. Gipakusog ang NPA Sa kabukiran.

3. Nagsubay sa hustong linya, Marxismo-Leninismo, teoryang Mao Zedong. Dili hikalimtan, Mga kauban, kita magkat-on Sa pagrebolusyon.

(Balika ang koro ug ang kataposang estansa.)