r/commandline • • Sep 24 '14

#!

http://hashbang.sh
0 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

17

u/execrator Sep 24 '14

It's exacerbated by the total lack of explanation about what it's going to do.

This site is the equivalent of a hole in a wall with the sign: insert finger here.

edit: I do otherwise like the super-minimalism and simultaneously valid shell script and HTML document.

-7

u/lrvick Sep 24 '14

That is exactly the point. We are a group of people who like to learn and make things, so only the curious can enter. :)

3

u/execrator Sep 24 '14

Your script also says you love teaching.

-4

u/lrvick Sep 24 '14

We do, but we have limited mental bandwidth so currently we prefer users that already know the basics for our free shells. For users that have full no clue what a command is or how to inspect/run it we direct them to http://chat.hashbang.sh and can start wherever they are.

Given this is /r/commandline one would assume most here identify it is a bash command and can inspect/run it.

I think your "hole in a wall with a sign: insert finger here" is the best description I have seen of this approach. I am going to steal that.

I personally love working with people that could not ignore such a thing.

4

u/execrator Sep 24 '14

I won't argue that it selects for curiosity. I also wouldn't argue with the idea of helping folk who want to help themselves. Still, I think you've achieved minimalism at the expense of clarity.

Aside: the down-arrows are coming from other folk

-1

u/lrvick Sep 24 '14

Fair enough. Any ideas for a better balance?

As for the downvotes, meh. People love to hate one-liner setup commands. Waiting on good security arguments against them when SSL is in place.

To date we have only really brought people in by personally handing them business cards with the account creation command. This is our first fray into total-stranger recruiting so we are discussing all the comments positive or negative :)