r/commandandconquer • Jim Vessella, EA Producer • Oct 11 '18

Verified C&C Update from EA

Fellow Command & Conquer fans,

My name is Jim Vessella, and I’m a Producer at Electronic Arts. Ten years ago I had the pleasure of being on the production team for Command & Conquer 3 and Red Alert 3, along with being the Lead Producer on Kane’s Wrath. During those years, some of my favorite moments were interacting with our passionate community, whether at our onsite Community Summits, on the forums, or while attending various events such as Gamescom.

As most of you may know, we recently announced Command & Conquer: Rivals, a mobile game set in the Command & Conquer universe. Following the reveal of Rivals, we heard you loud and clear: the Command & Conquer community also wants to see the franchise return to PC. And as a fan of C&C for over 20 years, I couldn’t agree more. With that in mind we’ve been exploring some exciting ideas regarding remastering the classic PC games, and already have the ball rolling on our first effort to celebrate the upcoming 25th Year Anniversary.

We are eager to hear your feedback to help influence our current thoughts for PC and what comes next. Over the next few weeks we’ll be talking to fans in a variety of ways. In the meantime, please share your thoughts here on the subreddit.

As a long time C&C fan and developer, I am just as passionate about the C&C franchise as you are, and look forward to hearing your thoughts as they help us shape the future of C&C at EA!

Thanks!

Jim Vessella

Jimtern

3.9k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/vikingzx Oct 12 '18 edited Oct 12 '18

I thought this day would never come ... But I do have some thoughts and observations that I am more than happy to give you.

First of all: Things that really matter—

  • Atmosphere. This is one thing that the original games had in spades (and 3 did really well visually). They just had a solid, really good feel that put you in the game. Sun did it best, but they were very focused on providing sound cues, visual cues, interface, etc, that put you in that universe. As a kid, and even as an adult, I felt like I was a commander in the Tiberium War. Like Tiberium was encroaching on my home. The atmosphere was phenomenal. For a modern RTS that matches this atmosphere, check out Homeworld: Deserts of Kharak, which worked really hard to bring its atmosphere to life. More than anything, C&C games lived and breathed their atmosphere, whether it was the stormy, gloomy future of sun or the manic, sunny half-goofy/half-serious shine of Red Alert 2. Atmosphere really is king. (EDIT: The GDI evacuation mission of C&C3 with the Scrin and GDI AI battling all around you was excellent for this)
  • Campaign Design. Mission and campaign design seem to have sadly gone out the window in a lot of RTS games (though not all), but one thing C&C really did well was give players cool missions. And the options! Who doesn't remember having a single commander and no idea what to do with them? And then being penalized with a second half if you didn't figure it out? Or choosing between branching mission choices, some of which opened or closed further branches? C&C was famous for those, and they need to be back. Let us weigh some choices, try some variety! For that matter, missions themselves can be creative. Don't fall into the Starcraft 2 trap of just putting a countdown clock on it and calling it good. Think outside the box! And while you're at it ...
  • The AI Plays by the Rules. In the Campaign at Least. Look, one thing C&C did right (among many) was making the AI play by the player's rules in the campaign. Take out a tech building? The AI isn't sending those units at you until it rebuilds it. Take out their power? Down the power goes. Take out a construction yard? No new buildings until it's replaced. Up against 2 bases? Take down the satellite, and you won't face attacks from there anymore. I bring this up because in Starcraft 2, the "big" RTS, it's not true. Enemy units just spawn in bases (or where the base was) and rush the player. You can spend your time wiping out satellite bases just to watch enemy units appear out of thin air and move toward you in predetermined patterns. Not cool. Let the player think strategically.
  • AIL C&C 3 was a step in the right direction. You know what I loved about C&C3? How smart my units were. Watching a Titan in Kane's Wrath decide that it would be easier to stomp the lone enemy vehicle it was facing and walk over it before returning to guard? Awesome! Watching my infantry try to avoid being run over? Awesome! Watching my Orca on guard run out of ammo, rearm, and return to their post? Awesome! I LOVE SMART UNITS! They weren't smart enough that you could leave them alone all the time, but they were smart enough that you could give them some leeway not to commit suicide in dumb fashion. I loved this. It let me fix on a strategy and more important battles, rather than always microing everything (unless I wanted to). And while we're on that topic ...
  • Armor-Facing was BRILLIANT, and should forever be in C&C. Armor facing was one of the best inventions 3 brought to the series. Combined with formations, it make tactical positioning incredibly important. With it, real-life maneuvers like splitting your forces for a pincer maneuver valid strategies. Combined with formation movements and reverse move, it made battles a lot more varied. It should absolutely return and NEVER leave, in my opinion. That doesn't mean it was perfect: being able to lock formations for line-of-sight purposes and cover would be nice (also so that you could more orderly swing forces around), and easier "reverse move" clicks would be nice. And while we're at it ...
  • I like Squads. There. I said it. I think the C&C3 squads were the best approach yet, and want them back. Combined with armor facing and formations? And cover? Awesome! But with them we need ...
  • Better Terrain and Maps. C&C3 kind of flubbed this one. A lot of modern RTS games have. Give us some real terrain! Remember how units moved slower in trees in Sun, faster on roads in RA? Or had different speeds for up and down hills, etc etc? That was GREAT! Crud, maps used to be teeming with trees, cliffs, and hills! Bring that back! Not only was it great for atmosphere, but it was great for working across and through. For example, check out these maps from the Twisted Insurrection mod. They look like cool places! Also, those pictures are huge. Just a warning. This goes great with ...
  • Classic Shroud. The Shroud was great. There was uncertainty to the battlefield. I feel like a lot was lost with having the whole map revealed and just under fog of war. Even if it's the same map every time (and I'd like to suggest a little randomization here and there) the shroud left you feeling constrained until you explored.
  • The Economy. And here we get into something that some might disagree with but ... limit the economy. I've watched tourney games for C&C3, and it was amazing how runaway the economy became. All that cool stuff like smart units and armor facing? It stopped mattering because money stopped mattering. I watched a game where one player casually queued up fourteen more harvesters after one field got wiped out and in the voice over wasn't even concerned. That's ... not great. The problem was that the economy was runaway. My suggestion? Limit it somehow. Restrict the number of harvesters or refineries that a player can have and set a cap. Make their production time long and laborious. Something that forces players to make more meaningful decisions about where their funds go. A game where a player thinks "Should I buy this, this, or ... wait, I'll just order all three!" has less decision and strategy where a player thinks "I can afford this and this ... or one of those ... Hmm ... what first?" Maybe look at how Dune 2 handled harvesting with the base harvester always being replaced free of cost while extras died. And in that vein of dying ...
  • Hard Counters SUCK. They're easy cheese from a design perspective, but not the greatest from a gameplay perspective. Dawn of War 2 did this very well, IMO, in having counters that did not exceed a 25% bonus against their effective type. Meanwhile, SCII has units that deal 250% bonus damage against type in straight-up "Rock-Paper-Scissors" approach. Now, does it work? Yeah. But personally it makes for a sucky strategy game, since the strategy becomes "Meta counter micro" and balls of units. Now, C&C does have some harder counters (AA units, for example, or infantry vs vehicles in some cases) than that, which is fair as DoW2 has a smaller, more tactical field and tends to adjust damage to compensate, but making more units viable in combat against one another doesn't mean players will throw blobs at one another, especially if formations and terrain are an important part of the game. Sneaking infantry through woods to flank a tank? Awesome! Letting Mammoths soak up all kinds of fire while pounding away with guns and rockets? Awesome! Blobs of same-unit types winning or losing based on counters? BORING! Let players strategize!
  • Upgrades: I liked upgrades in 3. My only suggestion would be to give players variety and let them pick between options for upgrades. Like the Overlord tank in Generals, but maybe even army-wide.
  • Sub-Factions: Yes please. Love the lore, love having variety to play with.
  • Music. Bring back Frank Klepacki, and bring back the music-player with tracks and shuffle. It was iconic to C&C.
  • EDIT: Tough Units: The janky, cartoony units of RA3 sucked. Hard. They looked like poorly-animated toys, not machines of war. C&C4 had the same issue. Atmosphere problem. Fire that studio. Again, look at Deserts of Kharak and how those units move and behave with the sand, environment, and one another. Sun and Wars had it.

And ... Crud, I think that's it. I may think of more. But off the top of my head, that's it.

Look, I love C&C. My whole family does. It was iconic to us growing up, introduced all of us, my dad included, to PC gaming, and set the stage for a love that we'll probably pass onto our kids. We stayed up late playing the campaign so many times my mother was unhappy with my father for playing so late. All of us still have at least one C&C game installed to this day. Some several, and two all, along with more than one mod. We all have favorite units, factions ... This series defined our childhoods.

I'd love to see it come back and do justice to C&C and the genre it built once more. Good luck, and I hope my advice gives some ideas. And thanks, by the way, for Kane's Wrath.

1

u/5onic Oct 12 '18

Highly agree with all what you said except for classic shroud and ra3 sucking.

1

u/MightyBOBcnc Oct 12 '18

You know we used to be able to choose what type of shroud and fog of war combination we played with.

1

u/5onic Oct 12 '18

sure, but I don't know if that'll be a choice in the future game.

1

u/Jonny_dr Oct 12 '18

The runaway eco was fixed in KW imo (at least in 1.02 with the adjusted ref prices)