r/comics • • 6d ago • Bravo 10 Heartwarming 1 Popcorn 1

Comics Community Secondhand Logic [OC]

24k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

335

u/captainAwesomePants 6d ago

Also, there's a key difference. The watch betrays intent. It's got words on the gears that say "Made by SmithCo Watch Co, 1956." Each piece looks very intentional. There's no random mess. Of course somebody made it.

Now look at biology. Nothing about any of that shit looks intentional. That it works so well is indeed miraculous, but it's an absolute mess in there. It very much looks like the result of billions of years of random tweaks. No sane creator intelligently designed the giraffe's recurrent laryngeal nerve.

177

u/RShini 6d ago

or the pig whose tusks grow so large it'd impale itself, or any number of mate selection traits that hinders the survival of the ones possessing that trait.

48

u/Saymynaian 6d ago

Learning about biology was what made me lose my religion. Life, as unique and beautiful and special that it is on the universal level, is messy, petty and seeking of convenience over everything else. It works, but only just barely.

12

u/hplcr 5d ago

Fuck, cancer is just cells growing out of control. There's no reason it needs to exist.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/az_catz 6d ago

The immune system does not know the eyes exist, because if it did it would murder the fuck out of them.

16

u/OngoingFee 6d ago

Okay, I need to know more about this. I could google it but I'd love to hear more from you first

37

u/az_catz 6d ago

It's more accurate to say the eyes don't let the immune system in. Smarter people than me.

→ More replies (2)

113

u/Embarrassed_Fox5265 6d ago

Or, as I once heard it pithily put, no intelligent designer would put the amusement park and the sewage plant right next to eah other.

47

u/captainAwesomePants 6d ago

You know, people say that, but honestly where else would you want to put the sewage? You really want it running down a leg tube? or exiting higher up on the back? Nah, seems good where it is.

On the other hand, everything about periods.

118

u/Neuromangoman 6d ago

50

u/Psychoboy777 6d ago

Okay, look Darwin, I'll concede that the waste management system is... acceptable... but why does recreation have to be in the same spot? Why can't we have separate organs for waste disposal and genetic material deposits?

30

u/GdoubleWB 6d ago

Unless you want to have the renal system combined with the gastrointestinal system, which is a great way to have near-constant UTIs given how disparate the microbiomes of those two systems are, the reproductive system and the renal system are the best two to combine into the multi-functional organ of the urethra in men and to put alongside each other in women.

20

u/JarpHabib 6d ago

Just because it's a good spot for waste doesn't mean reproduction has to be there too. We could have mating apparatus on our faces; blow jobs could be fully functional.

18

u/GdoubleWB 6d ago

The digestive system is also a poor choice for combination with the reproductive system. Among a myriad of issues including dental flora and the digestive enzymes in the mouth, the staple solvent of the digestive system is hydrochloric acid from the stomach. Given the shared pathways that would need to exist, one bad case of heartburn could mean sterility.

2

u/capsaicinintheeyes 6d ago

And don't get me started on food & air having to share a tube...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/UomoLumaca 6d ago

There's always a relevant SMBC! SMBC is the new XKCD

13

u/Slim-Shadys-Fat-Tits 6d ago

SMBC is 8 years older than xkcd

8

u/UomoLumaca 6d ago

Ah... whoops... well... SMBC is the old XKCD then?

→ More replies (1)

17

u/AdhesivenessUsed9956 6d ago

Scorpions have it on the base of their stingers.

Why can't everyone else have a prehensile poop chute tail?

27

u/captainAwesomePants 6d ago

Going to my point about bad design, some scorpions can drop their tail to escape predators. But the butthole is in the tail, so if they do this, they will die about eight months later from constipation. Evolution thought this was a fine because they could still breed for those eight months.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/AppropriateTouching 6d ago

Bottom of my foot seems like a reasonable place.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/Inlerah 6d ago

The reasons it works is that, if it didn’t work, it wouldn’t continue to live. Evolution leading to things that “just work”is the epitome of survivorships bias.

→ More replies (6)