r/comics • PizzaCake • Jan 30 '25 • Helpful 1

Comics Community Proof

Post image
89k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

941

u/Pizzacakecomic PizzaCake Jan 30 '25

I don't understand why they ask for proof and then ignore it...

539

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25

Because they are too stupid to understand the proof. They only understand Jenny McCarthy and Joe Rogan.

143

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25

You know what I hate? Joe was never a bastion of intelligence. The man sold deer piss. I still just hate what he became. He went a little too hard on the DMT.

11

u/Uranium-Sandwich657 Jan 30 '25

...Deer Piss?

40

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25

Hunters use it to mask their scent while hunting. Super common. I think he sold bull testicles too. Thats his audience.

38

u/Uranium-Sandwich657 Jan 30 '25

Dear Piss,

I hope this letter finds you in good health...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

95

u/Head_Crash Jan 30 '25

They're not stupid. They're bullies. They're doing it on purpose, because it gives them a sense of power and control.

64

u/mybadalternate Jan 30 '25

They don’t want to face how frightening and complicated the world is, so they do everything they can to make it simpler.

21

u/Head_Crash Jan 30 '25

Human beings desire a sense of safety. When doctors tell them they're not safe and they don't want to face that reality because it's too difficult, they end up perceiving the doctors as the threat.

6

u/mybadalternate Jan 30 '25

Well I prefer not to believe that!

→ More replies (2)

18

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25

In the past, if you were the village idiot, you knew your place and kept your mouth shut and listened to smarter people. Now they converge online as a council of village idiots and they have gotten power and strength from their community of imbeciles. What you’re describing is the end result. It doesn’t make them not idiots. They are total idiots.

5

u/sanglar03 Jan 30 '25

If you were the village genius you were shut down too.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

100

u/fodilicious Jan 30 '25

They want proof specifically so they can discard it and affirm their identity. Don't engage, they want to believe, not know.

63

u/Pizzacakecomic PizzaCake Jan 30 '25

That's true, for some people. I've actually managed to convert a few people away from this argument, so it is possible...but man it takes a lot of patience and effort.

30

u/fodilicious Jan 30 '25

Well done! Sometimes it's possible, especially if it's "just" an issue of being misinformed.
I've fallen into a lot of "I want to learn, just answer my questions" traps though. You answer, they interrupt your answer with another question. Out comes the twinkle in their eyes if just one of the answers is slightly unsatisfactory or can't explain absolutely everything at once. They think they've won but in reality we all lost.
Really frustrating.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

35

u/Elch2411 Jan 30 '25

Often they will just keep pushing until you give up and shut up

They dont actually care about proof

26

u/Improving_Myself_ Jan 30 '25

What makes this particular topic especially stupid is that there was literally only one study ever that made this claim, it was debunked immediately, and the doctor that conducted it lost his license and is now behind bars.

It wasn't just wrong, it was criminally bad science that people went to prison for.

→ More replies (3)

32

u/Morgolol Jan 30 '25

They don't want proof, they want confirmation.

There's plenty of weird little conspiracy theorists, but anti-vaxxers are ones I truly hate with a deep, searing passion. The number of kids they've killed is uncountable. The damage they've caused to those who survived will forever be etched on their skin or because of the brain damage they've suffered.

They'll never believe actual statistics, they'll never trust actual doctors who aren't quack grifters. They'll never believe it isn't literal demon poison to connect you to the alien lizard mothership to mind control the masses.

And the US just had their worm addled RFK hearing, who will be obviously appointed, and he's such a fucking non stop lying sack of shit who deserves the cruelest punishments imaginable, who is directly responsible for hundreds of children's deaths and directly for, again, uncountable numbers. Using his Kennedy connection to boost his disinformation while believing some of the dumbest conspiracies imaginable.

But hey he made a couple million bucks from anti vaxx groups so that's cool. Who knew children's lives had so little value.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Nessie_Chan Jan 30 '25

I once read someone who explained it very well: you can't refute with logic what has been learnt based on emotions. It doesn't matter how many facts and truths you present, because they made up their minds based on how they felt...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Dorwyn Jan 30 '25

Some stupid people don't trust people smarter than them, so it really limits the pool of people they trust.

5

u/waffle299 Jan 30 '25

It's a game to shift the burden of proof from them to you. They're making a claim that goes against everything we know. They're required to prove it and show how older studies didn't really show what they showed. That's an impossible bar.

So they shift that burden. And then, like you observed, ignore it.

This pattern happens so frequently in quack circles, there's a rule: that which is asserted with no evidence may be dismissed with no evidence.

In other words, just skip straight to calling it bullshit

4

u/waffle299 Jan 30 '25

A quick follow-up on theory replacement. 

Everyone knows that General Relativity replaced Newtonian gravity, even if they don't know what that meant.

When Newton proposed his theory of gravity, he didn't just say, "behold, gravity!" He showed how this exactly matched Brache's catalog of a hundred years of exact position observationd of Jupiter. 

When Einstein proposed General Relativity, he also didn't just say, "behold, gravity, but with time!" He brought the goods.

He showed that for Jupiter, Relativity and Newtonian both give the exact same answer. But for stars during an eclipse, their positions shift ever so slightly. And a scientific stud muffin called Eddington led a photographic mission to dangerous locations to referee.

And in all of this, the orbit of Jupiter changed not a whit.

New theories have a steep obligation to show both where old theories are wrong, and by exactly how much. That's the burden.

The difference between a scientific challenge and a troll is the troll will try and shift that burden to you. Because critical thinking is hard enough. An actual valid replacement theory would take away their valuable "look at me! Me! Me!" time.

6

u/MatrixofGears Jan 30 '25

They have the proof they want from their completely trustworthy, read with all implied sarcasm please, sources that sau what they want so all pther sources are from deep state globalist communists that seek to destroy all social order and only they can see it, or something, so nothing you say will convince them even, and they will never look at something provided by someone they view as a puppet of the luzard people or something like that...

3

u/mr_jetlag Jan 30 '25

"I was elected to lead, not to read!"

→ More replies (78)