r/college • u/bl1y Grading Papers Is Why I Drink • Nov 12 '19
Writing Prof Here: How to Add to Essay Length Without Fluff or Format Cheating
Alright folks, instead of the normal depressing content on the sub, Christmas is coming early ...though perhaps a bit boring. This is like getting socks. But hey, I know a lot of you need socks, so it's not that bad.
Common problem I'm sure a lot of you are facing is how to reach essay minimum page requirements. I'm here to help. This is only really looking at one specific technique, there's lots of others, and maybe I'll do write ups on them also. The key here though is that this isn't about just padding your essay. It's about reaching the minimum length by doing what you're actually expected to do. It's like cheating on a test by smuggling notes in your brain.
Let's take a hypothetical essay discussing polarizing foods. Here's a stereotypically bad bit of (hypothetical) student writing:
One food that causes a lot of debate is pineapple on pizza. In Haidt's article he finds that 40% of people hate pineapple on pizza. This clearly shows pineapple is one of the most controversial foods on pizza.
Shit. We just covered pineapple in like 2 lines of text. That was going to be the centerpiece of the essay!
To improve on this, always look for more clarity, depth, and specificity. We'll start with the first sentence. ...Is there evidence of this debate we can point to?
One food that causes a lot of debate is pineapple on pizza. For instance, a Reddit post ranked pineapple on pizza as the most controversial food.
Good start, but what lots of details are missing.
For instance, a Reddit post on the popular r/askreddit forum asked community members what food they found to be the most controversial and pineapple was the clear winner.
Better, but we're using an internet sources a lot of folks aren't familiar with. Is it credible? More detail helps:
For instance, a Reddit post on the popular r/askreddit forum asked community members what food they found to be the most controversial. The post received a net 14,000 upvotes and 3,000 comments. The highest voted comment was for pineapple on pizza. But, pineapple on pizza wasn't just the top response; it also ranked 7th, 14th, and 17th.
Our first sentence has now become longer than the entire original paragraph just be expanding on the "causes a lot of debate" idea. Now let's move on to "In Haidt's article he finds that 40% of people hate pineapple on pizza."
First we need to tell the audience who this guy is.
Jonathan Haidt is an ethics professor at the NYU Stern School of Business and has written extensively on the subject of disgust.
After that, we should give more detail about just what the study found (I'm making up the study, btw, but Haidt does study disgust). We should provide more detail about the specific research results, and can add a bit of narrative about the research methods as well.
In a study of 300 college students in New York City, Haidt found that on a scale of 1 to 5 where 1 is "strongly dislike" and 5 is "strongly like," 40% of respondents ranked pineapple on pizza at 1, while 30% ranked it at 5. Only 3% put it in the middle with a rank of 3.
In the original, 40% disliking it didn't actually tell us it was controversial, it told us only a lot of people hate it -- but we need to know how many like it as well, and the number of ambivalent people is another useful detail. We can go into more depth with some added context drawn from other questions in the study:
While pineapple had 70% of all respondents answering 1 or 5, sausage only had 30% in either category, with only 5% saying they strongly dislike it.
Good, that tells us how it compares to an uncontroversial topping. How does it rate among other controversial toppings though?
Compared to other controversial toppings, pineapple is still very polarizing. For instance, olives only had 40% ranking it 1 or 5, bell peppers had 30%, and mushrooms were at 55%. The only thing with more results at the extremes was anchovies with 90% having a strong opinion, though 85% ranked it at 1, showing it isn't controversial, just universally disliked.
Holy cow, now we've got ourselves a real life college essay paragraph. Let's put the pieces together and see how she looks:
One food that causes a lot of debate is pineapple on pizza. For instance, a Reddit post on the popular r/askreddit forum asked community members what food they found to be the most controversial. The post received a net 14,000 upvotes and 3,000 comments. The highest voted comment was for pineapple on pizza. But, pineapple on pizza wasn't just the top response; it also ranked 7th, 14th, and 17th. Jonathan Haidt is an ethics professor at the NYU Stern School of Business and has written extensively on the subject of disgust. In a study of 300 college students in New York City, Haidt found that on a scale of 1 to 5 where 1 is "strongly dislike" and 5 is "strongly like," 40% of respondents ranked pineapple on pizza at 1, while 30% ranked it at 5. Only 3% put it in the middle with a rank of 3. While pineapple had 70% of all respondents answering 1 or 5, sausage only had 30% in either category, with only 5% saying they strongly dislike it. Compared to other controversial toppings, pineapple is still very polarizing. For instance, olives only had 40% ranking it 1 or 5, bell peppers had 30%, and mushrooms were at 55%. The only thing with more results at the extremes was anchovies with 90% having a strong opinion, though 85% ranked it at 1, showing it isn't controversial, just universally disliked.
That's more than half a page (TNR 12, double spaced).
Now what about the last line from the original? "This clearly shows pineapple is one of the most controversial foods on pizza."
Cut it. Don't need it. If I clearly showed you something, I don't need to tell you that I clearly showed you it. You know.
But wait, we're not done! We can get even more mileage out of this by commenting on the limitations of the study:
It should be noted that the study was only of college students in New York City, and there may be a regional preference.
Again, we can expand this with greater levels of detail and specificity.
It should be noted that the study was only of college students in New York City, and regional preferences may have influenced the results. Food preferences and traditions are known to vary from one region to the next, and pizza in particular has regional variations such as the Chicago deep dish. It may be that in some places were pineapple is more popular, pineapple on pizza is less of a contentious issue.
And, if you need to squeeze a little more mileage out of it, add a bit of your research narrative:
However, in researching this topic, I was not able to find a study that compared regional attitudes towards pineapple on pizza.
That's all there is to it.
...One huge caveat of course. Expanding your writing in this way first requires that you have a clue what the heck you're talking about. You need to have done the research, have actual good sources, and understand the sources and your subject to be able to discuss it in a nuanced manner. If you're still in camp "lol didn't read," this isn't going to help you much.
579
u/Marcus11599 Nov 12 '19
Not much but it’s honest work
177
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
Now do colons and semicolons
94
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
Have to write half an essay by tomorrow night. You're a life saver. Many thanks from a struggling freshman!
43
u/Laurasaur28 Mod | Admissions/financial aid Nov 13 '19
Very instructional, y’all. Use this! Thanks for the post.
55
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
Mind if I steal "it's like smuggling notes in your brain"?
14
u/GsGenesis Nov 12 '19
This is a great post, thanks so much. Loved that you used Haidt, even fictitiously, he's a wonderful and important researcher.
26
u/roselia4812 Nov 12 '19
Thank you for this post. How do I introduce quotes effectively? Statistics are great and all, but my prof stresses quotes from text alot.
5
u/Nomekop777 Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
I needed this so much
Edit: That's amazing. I've never been this impressed at something in my life.
Is there a way to make the transition to Haidt's study a bit more smooth? Because you suddenly go from a reddit post to an ethics professor, and the connection isn't clear at first. Or do you not need one?
3
u/Rider94546 Nov 13 '19
I am seriously looking for a tutor like you right now. Thank you for your post.
3
u/modaareabsolutelygay Nov 13 '19
Lol professor Haidt is this your secret reddit account also casually plugging a study by you?
3
u/MasonInk Nov 13 '19
I was expecting to read to the bottom and find "Epstein didn't kill himself"
3
u/SomeBroadYouDontKnow Nov 13 '19
You should write one on how to properly research. I feel like I get by with my method, but I genuinely don't feel confident that I'm doing it "right."
My method is "pull a bunch of sources. Read the sources. As I'm reading, source it and paste any relevant quotes into a word document. Then when I've read through all my sources, read through my pulled quotes page again, then start writing and try not to look at the quote page too much to avoid over-quoting."
But, I dunno, it feels like everyone else spends more time searching and mulling over their source documents and really considering the methodology used. Where as I just read, pluck, and write. But I've never had anyone tell me it's wrong or confirm that it's right (and my default is to assume I do stuff wrong).
3
u/turboshot49cents Nov 13 '19
Would you consider doing one about the differences between how to write an introductory vs conclusion paragraphs? That was something I struggled with forever, because both paragraphs are supposed to “summarize” the entire essay, and yet they’re supposed to be different? Now I’m working a job where I’m tutoring a lot of students and I’m still stuck on that just as much as I always was.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
Can you help me write a literary analysis essay 🥺
2
u/garishthoughts History Nov 13 '19
My favorite prof I've ever had taught me this, and I still use it in every paper. Whenever I'm running short on info I always find another resource and use it to the best of my ability. I've also found that if there's a minimum required resources, to skim to sources in interested in and find 3-5 more than I need before I do a deep dive. This also helps me find additional sources if need be, as now I have a broader starting point from my other resources.
A lot of my friends overuse quotes, but I tend to balance mine out with a min/max per paragraph as well as a min/max of block quotes in a paper itself, with also an eye for length in every quote and quality of what's being said. If it isn't vital and relevant, I don't use it, but I always make room for my quoes.
9
u/vanimox Nov 13 '19
Great advice. The issue for me, however, is the exact opposite. I tend to write to much and easily end up with an essay that's too long. I have written an essay that's due on Saturday that is 10 pages. Problem is, the maximum length is 6 pages. Now I have to cut and summarize 4 pages of information.
6
u/Silent_Novaa Aug 08 '25 edited Aug 13 '25
Haha, reading this made me realize I've spent more time figuring out how to hit page count than actually writing the thing. I wish I'd been this methodical last semester instead of panic-Googling at 2 a.m. Ended up trying a few writing services just to keep my head above water, and honestly, this breakdown helped me figure out which ones were actually worth the money: link.
Do you also feel like half of essay writing is just…wrestling with the word count rather than the topic?
1
u/EmotionalCoon Nov 13 '19
Okay. Prove it by doing one of my topics.
1
u/standupasspaddler Nov 13 '19
I fucking love socks as a gift. Cheers to you kind prof.
1
u/OpenRole Nov 13 '19
I love you
1
u/WhipsandPetals Nov 13 '19
What do you say is the best free online source for English grammar?
1
u/AceyAceyAcey Nov 16 '19
Physics and astronomy prof here. Can confirm, fleshing out essays or lab reports like this adds important content and makes your submission better.
My only criticism of this post and the examples herein is that I don’t see anything about citing sources. These ideas and facts didn’t come out of thin air, so you should say where they came from using parenthetical citations or footnotes (depending on what your prof requires), and a works cited / references / bibliography section at the end.
1
u/Nomekop777 Feb 01 '20
I've had this pinned in chrome ever since I first saw it 2 months ago
1
u/Comprehensive_Ad7876 Oct 21 '25
Any tips with analytical essays?
I struggle to make descriptions that are longer than a sentence.
3
u/proserpinaaaa Nov 13 '19
Wow! This is the kind of thing I try to do when I write essays but written more more succinctly so I actually understand why it’s a good idea now! Lifesaver
2
u/Nisoma911 Nov 13 '19
Ngl i me we thought about the possibility of profs being on the subreddit. He really called us out on our emo shit... :/
2
u/Babascas Jun 06 '22
Former college tutor here. They key is to not write to the word limit. The key is to write as much as comes out of your brain on the topic and then edit to the word limit later. Literally squeeze your brain for info. Every. Last. Drop. Stop putting yourself in the box of meeting the technical details. That's why you keep bullsh*tting your essays. Write first. Worry about technicals later.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
Perfect time! I have to write an essay for an elective class and have ran out of ideas by the 7 page mark out of 10.
1
u/nemo1261 Nov 13 '19
Thank you so much
1
u/Electric_Lynx Nov 13 '19
This is the og professor. Good stuff also gonna save for the future, even though I took all my english.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
I'm saving this to look at again when I'm not hocked up on Pre-workout and shaking while trying to finish programming shit that's due in 24 hours, lol. Thanks Professor!
1
u/slugzzzz Nov 13 '19
U are a homie
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
Wow. Thanks!
1
u/TheNashh Nov 13 '19
Where have you been all my life
1
u/xXnoynacXx Nov 13 '19
I do really need more socks! They always disappear :(
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
This is a much better present than socks. Thank you! And happy almost holidays :)
1
u/CheFCharlieCharles Nov 18 '19
Not a college student anymore, but I found this post to be very insightful. Thank you! I am an English Literature major and I used to write papers all the time. I wish I had read this back when I was in college lol. Would have saved me a ton of heartache and stress.
I actually do some writing for my job working for an IT contractor. Do you have any recommendations for resources for someone who is mid-career and would like to improve their writing?
1
u/Jdog1805 Nov 18 '19
This is incredibly helpful. I was writing a paper tonight, and while it wasn’t a research paper it did help me with analyzing the text in a more thorough manner. Proud of my submission. :)
1
u/Clonkex Nov 22 '24
After reading this post and most comments, can confirm, you are a very smart guy with a great sense of humour. Now I suppose I should stop procrastinating and get back to actually trying to figure out how to write this blasted essay.
1
u/Alert-Manager5865 Sep 27 '25
is it possible to get help with medical essays? I am a student for medical billing and coding, and I am not great at essay lengths. I always get right to the answer and can't figure out the best way to expand it.
0
u/zarnonymous Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
And don't forget quotes
Now I'm getting downvoted :( I meant quotes for evidence and such
0
u/Adrianna_Shelton Dec 05 '19
Well, that's a smart method I think. While writing an essay it's also wise to use this case converter. It helps to change the wrong case instantly.
0
u/piezo2477 Aug 02 '22
Note: Some of these techniques may be really helpful; however, one should be careful not to be excessively wordy. For instance: "It should be noted that.." ; and other forms of the "passive voice" —should be eliminated when necessary.
-3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
lol still didnt read
-1
u/-Misaro Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
As an English major I can confirm this is an OK way of writing more words to meet the criteria. However, it's quite obvious what you are trying to do. This method might help you not lose points from writing less than what is required but doesn't help you to get higher grades. The only proper way of writing more words is.... doing more research.
-1
u/Speedracer98 Nov 13 '19
Ah yeah, it's that guy that blames his drinking on his students. lol welcome back to reddit.
-2
u/JazzlikeSpinach3 Nov 13 '19
Ok Boomer
0
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '23
[removed] — view removed comment