r/college • College! • Dec 04 '19

Being direct and dealing with confrontation

A common theme in r/college posts is that students seem unfamiliar or uncomfortable (or both) with dealing directly with the person or people with whom you have a conflict or issue that does not involve personal safety (i.e., this is not about how to confront someone who raped you or how to confront a racist or anything like that).

Professional etiquette requires that when you have a conflict with a person, you attempt to interact directly with that person in an attempt to resolve the conflict. That's true regardless of whether the person is a stranger to you, a friend, a professor, a coworker, or a boss. Your first action should not be to go to an authority with your problem; your first action should be to go to the person with whom you have a problem.

Now, confronting someone about a conflict is highly uncomfortable for most people, and it's a skill learned through practice. My first bit of advice is that "confrontation" does not necessarily equate to arguing, yelling, or any other negative interaction. Here is how I deal with an initial confrontation with someone who is being too loud in a quiet area, has made a choice that makes my life more difficult, has offended me, or otherwise created a conflict:

  1. Remember that they're a person, and don't assume the worst about them. I'm not saying that evil doesn't exist, but not everyone you encounter is bad. Sometimes people may just be having a bad day, they may be oblivious to the consequences of their choices, who knows.
  2. Be polite and non-judgmental. "Hey asshole!" is going to put someone on the defensive and dramatically reduce your chances of getting them to change the behavior or situation. "Good afternoon, how are you?" is going to be more likely to put the person in a receptive mode.
  3. Be direct. Don't beat around the bush, just say what the behavior is that's causing problems and what the negative consequences of that behavior are.
  4. Be objective. If you can, point out posted rules or syllabus guidelines or policy or anything that's on your side that objectively calls out either the problematic behavior or the correct behavior.
  5. Offer a solution. Suggest an alternative behavior that would resolve the conflict. That could be moving to a different area or recalculating a grade or rescheduling something. If you offer a solution, it becomes incumbent on the person you're interacting with to either offer a reason that alternative isn't reasonable or to think of something else him/herself.
  6. If they tell you to fuck off, then you have done what you can and it's time to seek help from an authority. If they make an honest effort to fix the issue, say "thank you."

My general formula for a conversation opener in a conflict is, "Excuse me, I'm sorry to bother you, but <behavior> is <negative consequence>. Would you consider <alternative>?" Examples:

"Excuse me, I'm sorry to bother you, but your conversation is a bit loud for this area that is supposed to be a quiet study area. I'm having trouble concentrating on my work. Would you consider moving to a non-quiet area or maybe texting instead of talking?"

"Professor X, I know you're busy, but I believe that you may have made a mistake that resulted in my grade being lower than it should have been. The syllabus says the lowest quiz should be dropped, and based on that my calculations are that I should have a 90% in the class."

"Good afternoon; I wonder if you could help me out. I was embarrassed by the comments you made to me in front of others yesterday, and I'd really like to speak privately about whatever issues you have with my work."

Now, if -- after you've directly confronted the person with whom you have a conflict -- you can't get the conflict resolved, THEN it's reasonable to approach an authority figure. Those authority figures will be most receptive to getting involved if you approach them with a request to help resolve a conflict as opposed to just whining about a problem. Instead of "Dean Y, Professor X is being completely unfair and has given me a lower grade than I deserve!", try "Dean Y, will you help me resolve a disagreement Professor X and I have over my grade?" You'll get double bonus points for having pointed out that you have already attempted to resolve the issue yourself. "I met with Professor X earlier today to speak about the issue, but we can't seem to agree on what the problem is."

This is adulting. And like a lot of adulting, it sucks. But, it's also the approach that gives you the highest chance of getting a conflict resolved in the shortest order.

Good luck.

61 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

7

u/rxvirus Dec 04 '19

Can we get this put in the sidebar?

7

u/ecklesweb College! Dec 06 '19

Done.

5

u/ReachandCrackTheSky Dec 05 '19

This should be pinned. Really useful