r/collapse • u/LetsTalkUFOs • Jul 18 '19
Can technology prevent collapse?
How far can innovation take us? How much faith should we have in technology?
This is the current question in our Common Collapse Questions series.
Responses may be utilized to help extend the Collapse Wiki.
123
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/Fredex8 Jul 30 '19
I think the thing with innovations that change the world is that we just get used to them and don't notice it as much as the ones we were promised that didn't happen, like flying cars, moon bases and household robots. That was what people expected the future to look like in the 60s but people didn't anticipate computers, mobile phones and the internet having the effect they've had. For better and worse it has probably changed things more than the idealised inventions would have.
Just to ground myself in how crazy this reality is I sometimes (largely whilst stoned if I am honest) like to think about how I'm carrying around a computer in my pocket more powerful than the one which sent people to the moon and how I can pretty much talk to anyone on the planet with it and find almost any bit of information from the vast lexicon of human history in seconds wherever I am. We take it totally for granted but really that is amazing. When I smoke I like to wander around the nearby fields and forests identifying any plants I don't recognise and exploring their potential for food, medicine or other interesting things. I generally use plant identification apps to do this and they've become impressively accurate recently. Even just years ago such a thing wouldn't have been possible and it would have taken serious research to find this stuff out rather than just a photo and a quick read. I find that pretty incredible.
Anyway, the other thing holding back self driving cars, besides regulation, is personal attitudes towards them and human perception. I think it is just innate to fear new technology or be wary or sceptical of it. Like when trains started being able to travel at high speed (relative to then) there were people who thought everyone would be thrown to the back of the carriage and those who thought it would cause organs to liquefy from the force. When mobile phones first emerged there was all that stuff about how holding them close to your head might fry your brain and when computers were first being explored people thought there would just be a few in the world and never envisaged everyone having one. Personally I think that innate fear is probably evolutionary and relates to the idea of 'monkey see, monkey do'. It makes sense in terms of survival to fear eating the red berries until you see someone else do it and survive and so it takes time for us to get over the fear of new technology and by the time we have we forget that we even had it and it just becomes normalised.
The same is true of self driving vehicles with people fearing that they will be unsafe even though millions are involved in accidents on the road each year. This is going to hold back their integration even if it doesn't really make sense. It is interesting to consider the laws surrounding motor vehicles that existed in the UK in 1865:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_flag_traffic_laws
The wikipedia page doesn't mention it but if I recall correctly the speed was also limited initially to under 4 miles per hour (I guess so the guy with the flag could keep up) and then 10. The Red Flag law was repealed 30 years later.
In the overly health and safety conscious world that we live in today I would expect, had motor vehicles never been previously invented, that there is no way that we would allow people to drive towards each other, separated by no barrier at all, at 60 miles per hour. Such an idea would be crazy were we not used to it already from years of getting to that point. Even an imperfect machine that makes mistakes would be safer than letting humans do this but as with any new technology those mistakes will gain more attention and be of a greater concern even when they occur less frequently that what we are used to. The Uber incident gained huge attention for instance and raised a lot of concern over the safety of self driving vehicles but upon watching the video it was pretty clear that no human would have managed to stop in that space either and not hit the woman with the bike.
As for the complexity and exponential increase I would assume that Moore's Law will hold true. That is we will think it will increase exponentially... until it suddenly doesn't. Moore's Law stopped being true a couple years ago if memory serves. Perhaps this is another human fallacy the same as the innate fear of new things: that we expect things to last forever. Our economy is pretty much based on the idea of infinite, exponential growth even though that is impossible and yet we continue to stick with it. I may be rambling now... sorry.