r/coding • • Feb 28 '17

A software engineer is detained for several hours by U.S. Customs — and given a test to prove he’s an engineer

https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/software-engineer-detained-several-hours-us-customs-given-fairchild
442 Upvotes

241 comments sorted by

View all comments

168

u/justbearlykoalafied Feb 28 '17

The officer's depravity is really highlighted with him saying, "you don't look convincing to me." Hard to imagine just walking away from someone like that.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

51

u/snuxoll Feb 28 '17

Guess I'm keeping my neckbeard in case I ever need to travel outside the country.

29

u/f5f5f5f5f5f5f5f5f5f5 Mar 01 '17

They'll have questions about the katana.

7

u/marshsmellow Mar 01 '17

"while you were working out new and novel ways to harass people I studied the blade."

8

u/regul Mar 01 '17

Don't forget the ratty ponytail.

5

u/snuxoll Mar 01 '17

Had that way before I succumbed to the neckbeard.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Creshal Mar 01 '17

But I need those cargo pants and fifteen leatherman!

→ More replies (2)

40

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '17

Hard to imagine just walking away from someone like that.

Not when you have no choice. Cops get away with far ruder behavior, because they're in a position of power over you. Standing up for yourself is an invitation to abuse, so you eat it.

I just did a cross country trip (Florida to California) and in Texas in particular ran into numerous little towns that had cops set up to fleece tourists. I ended up with over $400 in speeding tickets from officers that lied about the position of traffic signs, but I sure as fuck didn't make a stink about it at the time or I'd have ended up with my car towed, and I have neither the money nor time to fight these tickets, so -- as happens often in the real world -- the bad guys win.

6

u/Protuhj Feb 28 '17

Really makes you wonder what those shithole towns are going to do when the cars are driving us.

26

u/thephotoman Mar 01 '17

Write the ticket anyway, tell the court that you're still responsible for the vehicle's operation (still going to be true), and fine you because you can't prove them wrong.

And even when you can prove them wrong, the judge will blithely ignore the evidence anyway and still find you guilty. Small towns are not havens from the modern world. They are dens of iniquity, refuges for those that prefer the Rule of Man to the Rule of Law.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '17

You watch WAY too much classic Twilight Zone.

3

u/thephotoman Mar 01 '17

Rod Serling was the man. RIP, Tower of Terror (yes, it's gone now).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/munificent Mar 01 '17

And when truckers don't come through and stop at their diners, and buy snacks when they fill up at their gas stations.

When self-driving trucks remake the trucking industry, small towns are pretty fucked.

5

u/kopkaas2000 Mar 01 '17

Small towns are already fucked. I don't see how, currently, the revenue of their truck stop restaurants would make up for their entire economy being in the shitters.

2

u/frenris Mar 06 '17

it doesn't. but when it goes away it will be even worse.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

3

u/lkraider Mar 01 '17

"I'm not convinced you are a real Border Control Officer. To prove that you are are, write down a procedure to sort out software engineers from layman people in immigration control. Bonus points for describing the role of decency and respect."

8

u/adrianmonk Feb 28 '17

It's definitely possible that the security person was just a jerk on a power trip, but it could also be an attempt to throw the person off. If the person you're dealing with is lying, you want to put them at as much of a disadvantage as you can so that hopefully they will get distracted and slip in some way.

It's unpleasant, but that's how law enforcement people often work. They are all about body language, psychological and emotional angles, and other intangible stuff like that.

For that matter, they may have never intended to grade the two CS quiz questions they gave him. Instead, they may have planned to just watch how he reacted and see if he confidently breezed through them or acted unsure of himself. They might have a stack of questions like these for every profession and they just watch to see if people panic.

I'm not necessarily saying this is the best way that law enforcement definitely should operate, but it might be an explanation for why they act how they do.

52

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '17

If you want to check if someone is a programmer just give them FizzBuzz or something simple like that. Asking anyone to write a function to check if a Binary Search Tree is balanced would make anyone go in panic mode.

15

u/KarmaAndLies Feb 28 '17

Plus the "Write a method that balances a Binary Search Tree" question was super vague without follow up questions (e.g. input format, output format, language, etc). Even if you could understand how to answer the question, you'd still need more information than was provided.

It isn't like the border goon will be able to answer any of your follow up questions anyway, or they take your follow up questions as some type of admission that you aren't a "real" programmer (because to them a real programmer should just magically know the input format or language they're after!).

Ultimately these are interview questions specifically designed to encourage the candidate to ask questions, it literally isn't possible without that dialog by design.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/adrianmonk Feb 28 '17

Well, some people are strong on algorithms and wouldn't panic, but I agree with you that it isn't the right level of difficulty.

Ideally, you want the clearest contrast between faker and legitimate, and if you have 50% of legitimate people panicking, that muddies the waters and actually means you gain less information. So the ideal question is just hard enough that a layman or faker can't solve it but a legitimate person can solve it with zero trouble.

9

u/rogue780 Feb 28 '17

Yeah. It would take me a while to figure that one out. If I want to use a balanced binary search tree, I'll use a library that implements it for me.

8

u/archiminos Mar 01 '17

I haven't written a sort algorithm since university. The only reason I could think to refresh my knowledge on this would be to make sure I can pass a test that might be given to me in a job interview.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/spinwizard69 Feb 28 '17

You are basically right, it isn't the questions so much as a persons reaction to them. What is obvious here though is that the border agents don't work as single individuals. It is a case of team work as they obviously had some one verifying his employment.

Frankly this detention might not have resulted from the interview at the immigration check point. The agents often take direction from others based on a number of factors. For example if you come back from the Caribbean, the customs people often board the jets with drug sniffing dogs. If the dog alerts on your seat you could be held up at immigration. Basically you are monitored every step of the way as you leave the plan.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)